I can understand the resistance in the US to such an idea, especially on a forum full of Whites who went to private schools. The public education system in the US is so deplorable, that the idea of forcing everyone to go to a public school sounds horrible. Such a move would require a huge overhaul in the public education system first, of course.
I'm pretty sure we've done the poll before and we overwhelming went to public school. The US public school system has problems, no doubt, but the typical school district isn't a trainwreck* and actually does a fairly decent job at educating. Yes, there are some horrid school districts, and they bring the numbers for everybody else down, but they are the exception, not the rule.
*some have large financial issues coming to a head thanks to some stupid pension deals, but those are largely correctable