1916 Presidential Election
Fmr. Congressman Charles W. Fairbanks (American-Indiana)/ Senator Hiram Johnson (American-California): 333 Electoral Votes; 42.9% popular votesCongresswoman Jeanette Rankin (People's-Montana)/ Congressman Upton Sinclair (People's-California): 127 Electoral Votes; 31.4% popular votesGovernor George Chamberlain (Democratic-Oregon)/ Congressman James M. Cox (Democratic-Ohio): 71 Electoral Votes; 20.0% popular votesJournalist Allan Benson (Socialist-New York)/ Mr. George R. Kirkpatrick (Socialist-New Jersey): 0 Electoral Votes; 5.7% popular votesA slumbering economy, concerns that Rankin's pacifism would make the United States easy pickings for the "German Menace", and the defection of Underwood supporters to the opposition all spelled trouble for the Populist ticket in 1916. With the American Party once again united after the calamitous election of 1912, Charles W. Fairbanks was able to capitalize on public concern for national security to win a smashing victory in both the electoral college and the popular vote. While the Democrats performed far better than they had four years earlier, Allan Benson's Socialist ticket would fail to catch on, with most laborers remaining loyal to the Populists.