|
Title: NAPOLEON's marshals survivor - DAVOUT is a survivor ! Post by: big bad fab on January 13, 2010, 08:34:41 AM ()
Another one I wanted to start... Between bad soldiers, old and new morons, old, new and multiple traitors, you've got plenty of reasons to pick one of them ! Of course, they only exist by their year of promotion, so here is the simplest list: 1804: 1. Berthier 2. Murat 3. Moncey 4. Jourdan 5. Masséna 6. Augereau 7. Bernadotte 8. Brune 9. Soult 10. Lannes 11. Mortier 12. Ney 13. Davout 14. Bessières 15. Kellermann 16. Lefebvre 17. Pérignon 18. Sérurier 1807: 19. Victor 1809: 20. MacDonald 21. Oudinot 22. Marmont 1811: 23. Suchet 1812: 24. Gouvion Saint-Cyr 1813: 25. Poniatowski 1815: 26. Grouchy Results: Round one: Rules: In each round, you vote for the marshal you want to eliminate. The marshal who has received the biggest total of votes is eliminated. In case of a tie, the marshal who has received the biggest total of votes in previous rounds is eliminated. In case of a new tie, I, Emperor of this survivor, will decide who is ousted. Each round is open for 24 hours +. ROUND ONE IS OPEN ! Vote away ! Title: Re: Napoleon's marshals survivor - round 1 Post by: big bad fab on January 13, 2010, 09:02:34 AM I begin with Bernadotte, for obvious reasons...
Title: Re: Napoleon's marshals survivor - round 1 Post by: MASHED POTATOES. VOTE! on January 13, 2010, 09:16:42 AM Poniatowski
Title: Re: Napoleon's marshals survivor - round 1 Post by: big bad fab on January 13, 2010, 09:20:05 AM Title: Re: Napoleon's marshals survivor - round 1 Post by: k-onmmunist on January 13, 2010, 10:22:01 AM Grouchy. Time to get that incompetent fool out :P
Title: Re: Napoleon's marshals survivor - round 1 Post by: Hash on January 13, 2010, 11:09:11 AM Bernadotte, obviously.
Title: Re: Napoleon's marshals survivor - round 1 Post by: Hans-im-Glück on January 13, 2010, 12:57:00 PM Bernadotte, obviously. Title: Re: Napoleon's marshals survivor - round 1 Post by: Associate Justice PiT on January 13, 2010, 03:23:54 PM Bernadotte
Title: Re: Napoleon's marshals survivor - round 1 Post by: Хahar 🤔 on January 13, 2010, 04:17:50 PM Soult
Opportunist. Title: Re: Napoleon's marshals survivor - round 1 Post by: Edu on January 13, 2010, 06:21:01 PM Bernadotte
Title: Re: Napoleon's marshals survivor - round 1 Post by: big bad fab on January 14, 2010, 02:55:01 AM Grouchy. Time to get that incompetent fool out :P In fact, he was "a bit late" but Napoleon viewed him, even after Waterloo, as a good one, if not a very good one. Circumstances were more important than Grouchy's personal role. Title: Re: Napoleon's marshals survivor - round 2 Post by: big bad fab on January 14, 2010, 05:18:54 PM ()
1804: 1. Berthier 2. Murat 3. Moncey 4. Jourdan 5. Masséna 6. Augereau 8. Brune 9. Soult 10. Lannes 11. Mortier 12. Ney 13. Davout 14. Bessières 15. Kellermann 16. Lefebvre 17. Pérignon 18. Sérurier 1807: 19. Victor 1809: 20. MacDonald 21. Oudinot 22. Marmont 1811: 23. Suchet 1812: 24. Gouvion Saint-Cyr 1813: 25. Poniatowski 1815: 26. Grouchy Results: Round one: Bernadotte 5, Grouchy 1, Poniatowski 1, Soult 1 Rules: In each round, you vote for the marshal you want to eliminate. The marshal who has received the biggest total of votes is eliminated. In case of a tie, the marshal who has received the biggest total of votes in previous rounds is eliminated. In case of a new tie, I, Emperor of this survivor, will decide who is ousted. Each round is open for 24 hours +. ROUND TWO IS OPEN ! Vote away ! Title: Re: Napoleon's marshals survivor - round 2 Post by: big bad fab on January 14, 2010, 05:25:06 PM Brune
Corrupted, brutal, without big military deeds,... Title: Re: Napoleon's marshals survivor - round 2 Post by: Хahar 🤔 on January 14, 2010, 07:15:05 PM Soult
Title: Re: Napoleon's marshals survivor - round 2 Post by: Hash on January 14, 2010, 07:29:12 PM Brune
Title: Re: Napoleon's marshals survivor - round 2 Post by: Associate Justice PiT on January 14, 2010, 10:46:36 PM Brune
Title: Re: Napoleon's marshals survivor - round 2 Post by: big bad fab on January 15, 2010, 08:50:02 AM BUMP
Don't forget this survivor ! Title: Re: Napoleon's marshals survivor - round 2 Post by: MASHED POTATOES. VOTE! on January 15, 2010, 09:20:48 AM Are we in round 2 already?
Title: Re: Napoleon's marshals survivor - round 2 Post by: Hans-im-Glück on January 15, 2010, 01:06:25 PM Soult
Title: Re: Napoleon's marshals survivor - round 2 Post by: Edu on January 15, 2010, 02:56:18 PM Brune
Title: Re: Napoleon's marshals survivor - round 2 Post by: Hash on January 15, 2010, 04:56:59 PM Soult
Title: Re: Napoleon's marshals survivor - round 2 Post by: MASHED POTATOES. VOTE! on January 15, 2010, 05:37:00 PM Grouchy
Title: Re: Napoleon's marshals survivor - round 2 Post by: Dr. Cynic on January 16, 2010, 06:56:58 PM What about Kleber? The guy who Napoleon left in Egypt?
Title: Re: Napoleon's marshals survivor - round 3 Post by: big bad fab on January 17, 2010, 11:04:02 AM ()
1804: 1. Berthier 2. Murat 3. Moncey 4. Jourdan 5. Masséna 6. Augereau 9. Soult 10. Lannes 11. Mortier 12. Ney 13. Davout 14. Bessières 15. Kellermann 16. Lefebvre 17. Pérignon 18. Sérurier 1807: 19. Victor 1809: 20. MacDonald 21. Oudinot 22. Marmont 1811: 23. Suchet 1812: 24. Gouvion Saint-Cyr 1813: 25. Poniatowski 1815: 26. Grouchy Results: Round one: Bernadotte 5, Grouchy 1, Poniatowski 1, Soult 1 Round two: Brune 4, Soult 2, Grouchy 1 Rules: In each round, you vote for the marshal you want to eliminate. The marshal who has received the biggest total of votes is eliminated. In case of a tie, the marshal who has received the biggest total of votes in previous rounds is eliminated. In case of a new tie, I, Emperor of this survivor, will decide who is ousted. Each round is open for 24 hours +. ROUND THREE IS OPEN ! Vote away ! Title: Re: Napoleon's marshals survivor - round 3 Post by: big bad fab on January 17, 2010, 11:07:41 AM - Kléber wasn't maréchal de France under Napoleon.
- I haven't counted Hash's second vote: he may have thought Brune was already eliminated. And, in this round, sure, I vote myself Soult, paragon of opportunism. Title: Re: Napoleon's marshals survivor - round 3 Post by: Hans-im-Glück on January 17, 2010, 01:06:38 PM Soult
Title: Re: Napoleon's marshals survivor - round 3 Post by: Associate Justice PiT on January 17, 2010, 03:50:24 PM Grouchy
Title: Re: Napoleon's marshals survivor - round 3 Post by: Hash on January 17, 2010, 04:48:07 PM Title: Re: Napoleon's marshals survivor - round 3 Post by: The Dowager Mod on January 17, 2010, 06:25:39 PM Lefebvre.
Title: Re: Napoleon's marshals survivor - round 3 Post by: Edu on January 18, 2010, 08:02:59 AM Title: Re: Napoleon's marshals survivor - round 4 Post by: big bad fab on January 18, 2010, 11:14:00 AM ()
1804: 1. Berthier 2. Murat 3. Moncey 4. Jourdan 5. Masséna 6. Augereau 10. Lannes 11. Mortier 12. Ney 13. Davout 14. Bessières 15. Kellermann 16. Lefebvre 17. Pérignon 18. Sérurier 1807: 19. Victor 1809: 20. MacDonald 21. Oudinot 22. Marmont 1811: 23. Suchet 1812: 24. Gouvion Saint-Cyr 1813: 25. Poniatowski 1815: 26. Grouchy Results: Round one: Bernadotte 5, Grouchy 1, Poniatowski 1, Soult 1 Round two: Brune 4, Soult 2, Grouchy 1 Round three: Soult 4, Grouchy 1, Lefebvre 1 Rules: In each round, you vote for the marshal you want to eliminate. The marshal who has received the biggest total of votes is eliminated. In case of a tie, the marshal who has received the biggest total of votes in previous rounds is eliminated. In case of a new tie, I, Emperor of this survivor, will decide who is ousted. Each round is open for 24 hours +. ROUND FOUR IS OPEN ! Vote away ! Title: Re: Napoleon's marshals survivor - round 4 Post by: CatoMinor on January 18, 2010, 11:18:41 AM Ney
Title: Re: Napoleon's marshals survivor - round 4 Post by: big bad fab on January 18, 2010, 11:24:02 AM Augereau
A nasty and ambitious traitor. And he was part of the repression of Vendée. Title: Re: Napoleon's marshals survivor - round 4 Post by: big bad fab on January 18, 2010, 11:53:33 AM The problem with Napoleon's marshals is that they were all traitors in the end, except Davout.
Those who came back to support Napoleon during the Cent Jours and betrayed again after that were worse in a way. In the case of Ney, well, he died for all that and he was a real good military leader, that's why he deserves to remain here for a bit longer, I think. Lefebvre was probably a good idea, apart from my Augereau vote ;). Or Marmont, of course. But he was also a good general. Title: Re: Napoleon's marshals survivor - round 4 Post by: Hash on January 18, 2010, 01:37:27 PM Grouchy
Title: Re: Napoleon's marshals survivor - round 4 Post by: Hans-im-Glück on January 18, 2010, 01:44:45 PM Grouchy
Title: Re: Napoleon's marshals survivor - round 4 Post by: MASHED POTATOES. VOTE! on January 18, 2010, 02:06:54 PM Title: Re: Napoleon's marshals survivor - round 4 Post by: Associate Justice PiT on January 18, 2010, 04:49:26 PM Grouchy
Title: Re: Napoleon's marshals survivor - round 4 Post by: The Dowager Mod on January 18, 2010, 08:20:00 PM Lefebvre.
Title: Re: Napoleon's marshals survivor - round 5 Post by: big bad fab on January 19, 2010, 12:07:40 PM ()
1804: 1. Berthier 2. Murat 3. Moncey 4. Jourdan 5. Masséna 6. Augereau 10. Lannes 11. Mortier 12. Ney 13. Davout 14. Bessières 15. Kellermann 16. Lefebvre 17. Pérignon 18. Sérurier 1807: 19. Victor 1809: 20. MacDonald 21. Oudinot 22. Marmont 1811: 23. Suchet 1812: 24. Gouvion Saint-Cyr 1813: 25. Poniatowski 26. Grouchy Results: Round one: Bernadotte 5, Grouchy 1, Poniatowski 1, Soult 1 Round two: Brune 4, Soult 2, Grouchy 1 Round three: Soult 4, Grouchy 1, Lefebvre 1 Round four: Grouchy 4, Lefebvre 1, Augereau 1, Ney 1 Rules: In each round, you vote for the marshal you want to eliminate. The marshal who has received the biggest total of votes is eliminated. In case of a tie, the marshal who has received the biggest total of votes in previous rounds is eliminated. In case of a new tie, I, Emperor of this survivor, will decide who is ousted. Each round is open for 24 hours +. ROUND FIVE IS OPEN ! Vote away ! Title: Re: Napoleon's marshals survivor - round 5 Post by: big bad fab on January 19, 2010, 12:13:09 PM Augereau
Title: Re: Napoleon's marshals survivor - round 5 Post by: Hans-im-Glück on January 19, 2010, 12:14:25 PM Lefebvre
Title: Re: Napoleon's marshals survivor - round 5 Post by: The Dowager Mod on January 19, 2010, 06:40:07 PM Lefebvre.
Title: Re: Napoleon's marshals survivor - round 5 Post by: MASHED POTATOES. VOTE! on January 19, 2010, 06:58:19 PM Poniatowski
Title: Re: Napoleon's marshals survivor - round 6 Post by: big bad fab on January 21, 2010, 03:29:05 AM ()
1804: 1. Berthier 2. Murat 3. Moncey 4. Jourdan 5. Masséna 6. Augereau 10. Lannes 11. Mortier 12. Ney 13. Davout 14. Bessières 15. Kellermann 17. Pérignon 18. Sérurier 1807: 19. Victor 1809: 20. MacDonald 21. Oudinot 22. Marmont 1811: 23. Suchet 1812: 24. Gouvion Saint-Cyr 1813: 25. Poniatowski 26. Grouchy Results: Round one: Bernadotte 5, Grouchy 1, Poniatowski 1, Soult 1 Round two: Brune 4, Soult 2, Grouchy 1 Round three: Soult 4, Grouchy 1, Lefebvre 1 Round four: Grouchy 4, Lefebvre 1, Augereau 1, Ney 1 Round five: Lefebvre 2, Poniatowski 1, Augereau 1 Rules: In each round, you vote for the marshal you want to eliminate. The marshal who has received the biggest total of votes is eliminated. In case of a tie, the marshal who has received the biggest total of votes in previous rounds is eliminated. In case of a new tie, I, Emperor of this survivor, will decide who is ousted. Each round is open for 24 hours +. ROUND SIX IS OPEN ! Vote away ! Title: Re: Napoleon's marshals survivor - round 6 Post by: big bad fab on January 21, 2010, 03:33:32 AM In a very low turnout (:(), Madame Sans-Gêne's husband is out... (and, of course, one who took part in the 18 Brumaire coup)
As my Augereau vote isn't very successful for the moment, I try an ambitious traitor: Marmont Title: Re: Napoleon's marshals survivor - round 6 Post by: MASHED POTATOES. VOTE! on January 21, 2010, 06:10:19 AM Poniatowski
Title: Re: Napoleon's marshals survivor - round 6 Post by: Hash on January 21, 2010, 08:11:06 AM Marmont
Title: Re: Napoleon's marshals survivor - round 6 Post by: Edu on January 21, 2010, 08:13:26 AM Title: Re: Napoleon's marshals survivor - round 6 Post by: Hans-im-Glück on January 21, 2010, 10:17:23 AM Title: Re: Napoleon's marshals survivor - round 6 Post by: The Dowager Mod on January 21, 2010, 07:37:45 PM Marmont.
Title: Re: Napoleon's marshals survivor - round 7 Post by: big bad fab on January 22, 2010, 03:25:08 AM ()
1804: 1. Berthier 2. Murat 3. Moncey 4. Jourdan 5. Masséna 6. Augereau 10. Lannes 11. Mortier 12. Ney 13. Davout 14. Bessières 15. Kellermann 17. Pérignon 18. Sérurier 1807: 19. Victor 1809: 20. MacDonald 21. Oudinot 1811: 23. Suchet 1812: 24. Gouvion Saint-Cyr 1813: 25. Poniatowski 26. Grouchy Results: Round one: Bernadotte 5, Grouchy 1, Poniatowski 1, Soult 1 Round two: Brune 4, Soult 2, Grouchy 1 Round three: Soult 4, Grouchy 1, Lefebvre 1 Round four: Grouchy 4, Lefebvre 1, Augereau 1, Ney 1 Round five: Lefebvre 2, Poniatowski 1, Augereau 1 Round six: Marmont 5, Poniatowski 1 Rules: In each round, you vote for the marshal you want to eliminate. The marshal who has received the biggest total of votes is eliminated. In case of a tie, the marshal who has received the biggest total of votes in previous rounds is eliminated. In case of a new tie, I, Emperor of this survivor, will decide who is ousted. Each round is open for 24 hours +. ROUND SEVEN IS OPEN ! Vote away ! Title: Re: Napoleon's marshals survivor - round 7 Post by: big bad fab on January 22, 2010, 03:40:02 AM Augereau
Title: Re: Napoleon's marshals survivor - round 7 Post by: Hash on January 22, 2010, 10:55:55 AM Augereau
Title: Re: Napoleon's marshals survivor - round 7 Post by: Hans-im-Glück on January 22, 2010, 12:34:04 PM Poniatowski
Title: Re: Napoleon's marshals survivor - round 7 Post by: MASHED POTATOES. VOTE! on January 23, 2010, 09:55:49 PM Title: Re: Napoleon's marshals survivor - round 8 Post by: big bad fab on January 25, 2010, 02:59:29 AM ()
1804: 1. Berthier 2. Murat 3. Moncey 4. Jourdan 5. Masséna 6. Augereau 10. Lannes 11. Mortier 12. Ney 13. Davout 14. Bessières 15. Kellermann 17. Pérignon 18. Sérurier 1807: 19. Victor 1809: 20. MacDonald 21. Oudinot 1811: 23. Suchet 1812: 24. Gouvion Saint-Cyr 25. Poniatowski 26. Grouchy Results: Round one: Bernadotte 5, Grouchy 1, Poniatowski 1, Soult 1 Round two: Brune 4, Soult 2, Grouchy 1 Round three: Soult 4, Grouchy 1, Lefebvre 1 Round four: Grouchy 4, Lefebvre 1, Augereau 1, Ney 1 Round five: Lefebvre 2, Poniatowski 1, Augereau 1 Round six: Marmont 5, Poniatowski 1 Round seven: Poniatowski 2 (3 in previous rounds), Augereau 2 (2 in previous rounds) Rules: In each round, you vote for the marshal you want to eliminate. The marshal who has received the biggest total of votes is eliminated. In case of a tie, the marshal who has received the biggest total of votes in previous rounds is eliminated. In case of a new tie, I, Emperor of this survivor, will decide who is ousted. Each round is open for 24 hours +. ROUND EIGHT IS OPEN ! Vote away ! Title: Re: Napoleon's marshals survivor - round 8 Post by: big bad fab on January 25, 2010, 03:00:50 AM Sometimes, I hate my tie-breaking rule ;D
Augereau Title: Re: Napoleon's marshals survivor - round 8 Post by: Hans-im-Glück on January 25, 2010, 10:18:09 AM Augereau
Title: Re: Napoleon's marshals survivor - round 9 Post by: big bad fab on January 26, 2010, 03:19:10 AM ()
1804: 1. Berthier 2. Murat 3. Moncey 4. Jourdan 5. Masséna 10. Lannes 11. Mortier 12. Ney 13. Davout 14. Bessières 15. Kellermann 17. Pérignon 18. Sérurier 1807: 19. Victor 1809: 20. MacDonald 21. Oudinot 1811: 23. Suchet 1812: 24. Gouvion Saint-Cyr 25. Poniatowski 26. Grouchy Results: Round one: Bernadotte 5, Grouchy 1, Poniatowski 1, Soult 1 Round two: Brune 4, Soult 2, Grouchy 1 Round three: Soult 4, Grouchy 1, Lefebvre 1 Round four: Grouchy 4, Lefebvre 1, Augereau 1, Ney 1 Round five: Lefebvre 2, Poniatowski 1, Augereau 1 Round six: Marmont 5, Poniatowski 1 Round seven: Poniatowski 2 (3 in previous rounds), Augereau 2 (2 in previous rounds) Round eight: Augereau 2 Rules: In each round, you vote for the marshal you want to eliminate. The marshal who has received the biggest total of votes is eliminated. In case of a tie, the marshal who has received the biggest total of votes in previous rounds is eliminated. In case of a new tie, I, Emperor of this survivor, will decide who is ousted. Each round is open for 24 hours +. ROUND NINE IS OPEN ! Vote away ! Title: Re: Napoleon's marshals survivor - round 9 Post by: big bad fab on January 26, 2010, 03:23:37 AM 2 votes... :( :( :(
Come on guys ! We need a higher a turnout ! Jourdan a complaining guy; successful when he was young, but not after; supporter of the Revolution but of course loyal to the King after 1815... Title: Re: Napoleon's marshals survivor - round 9 Post by: Hans-im-Glück on January 26, 2010, 01:31:12 PM Gouvion Saint-Cyr
Title: Re: Napoleon's marshals survivor - round 9 Post by: Hash on January 27, 2010, 08:05:59 AM Gouvion Saint-Cyr
Title: Re: Napoleon's marshals survivor - round 10 Post by: big bad fab on January 27, 2010, 08:26:40 AM ()
1804: 1. Berthier 2. Murat 3. Moncey 4. Jourdan 5. Masséna 10. Lannes 11. Mortier 12. Ney 13. Davout 14. Bessières 15. Kellermann 17. Pérignon 18. Sérurier 1807: 19. Victor 1809: 20. MacDonald 21. Oudinot 1811: 23. Suchet 24. Gouvion Saint-Cyr 25. Poniatowski 26. Grouchy Results: Round one: Bernadotte 5, Grouchy 1, Poniatowski 1, Soult 1 Round two: Brune 4, Soult 2, Grouchy 1 Round three: Soult 4, Grouchy 1, Lefebvre 1 Round four: Grouchy 4, Lefebvre 1, Augereau 1, Ney 1 Round five: Lefebvre 2, Poniatowski 1, Augereau 1 Round six: Marmont 5, Poniatowski 1 Round seven: Poniatowski 2 (3 in previous rounds), Augereau 2 (2 in previous rounds) Round eight: Augereau 2 Round nine: Gouvion-Saint-Cyr 2, Jourdan 1 Rules: In each round, you vote for the marshal you want to eliminate. The marshal who has received the biggest total of votes is eliminated. In case of a tie, the marshal who has received the biggest total of votes in previous rounds is eliminated. In case of a new tie, I, Emperor of this survivor, will decide who is ousted. Each round is open for 24 hours +. ROUND TEN IS OPEN ! Vote away ! Title: Re: Napoleon's marshals survivor - round 10 Post by: big bad fab on January 27, 2010, 08:29:47 AM Well, I'm a bit surprised by the ousting of Gouvion-St-Cyr, who was quite a good marshal and not a bad guy. He was a realistic soldier, was able to disagree with Napoleon and was, overall, a patriot more than the servant of the 3 regimes he knew.
I vote for Jourdan again. Title: Re: Napoleon's marshals survivor - round 10 Post by: GMantis on January 27, 2010, 09:48:57 AM Jourdan
Title: Re: Napoleon's marshals survivor - round 10 Post by: Hans-im-Glück on January 27, 2010, 01:21:57 PM Title: Re: Napoleon's marshals survivor - round 10 Post by: The Dowager Mod on January 28, 2010, 12:04:33 AM Kellermann.
Title: Re: Napoleon's marshals survivor - round 10 Post by: Hash on January 28, 2010, 11:09:59 AM Jourdan
Title: Re: Napoleon's marshals survivor - round 11 Post by: big bad fab on January 28, 2010, 11:51:25 AM ()
1804: 1. Berthier 2. Murat 3. Moncey 5. Masséna 10. Lannes 11. Mortier 12. Ney 13. Davout 14. Bessières 15. Kellermann 17. Pérignon 18. Sérurier 1807: 19. Victor 1809: 20. MacDonald 21. Oudinot 1811: 23. Suchet 24. Gouvion Saint-Cyr 25. Poniatowski 26. Grouchy Results: Round one: Bernadotte 5, Grouchy 1, Poniatowski 1, Soult 1 Round two: Brune 4, Soult 2, Grouchy 1 Round three: Soult 4, Grouchy 1, Lefebvre 1 Round four: Grouchy 4, Lefebvre 1, Augereau 1, Ney 1 Round five: Lefebvre 2, Poniatowski 1, Augereau 1 Round six: Marmont 5, Poniatowski 1 Round seven: Poniatowski 2 (3 in previous rounds), Augereau 2 (2 in previous rounds) Round eight: Augereau 2 Round nine: Gouvion-Saint-Cyr 2, Jourdan 1 Round ten: Jourdan 4, Kellermann 1 Rules: In each round, you vote for the marshal you want to eliminate. The marshal who has received the biggest total of votes is eliminated. In case of a tie, the marshal who has received the biggest total of votes in previous rounds is eliminated. In case of a new tie, I, Emperor of this survivor, will decide who is ousted. Each round is open for 24 hours +. ROUND ELEVEN IS OPEN ! Vote away ! Title: Re: Napoleon's marshals survivor - round 11 Post by: big bad fab on January 28, 2010, 11:55:38 AM Berthier
Not a big soldier, not so loyal a man. Title: Re: Napoleon's marshals survivor - round 11 Post by: Hans-im-Glück on January 28, 2010, 12:30:12 PM Kellermann
Title: Re: Napoleon's marshals survivor - round 11 Post by: The Dowager Mod on January 28, 2010, 11:46:50 PM Kellermann.
Title: Re: Napoleon's marshals survivor - round 12 Post by: big bad fab on January 30, 2010, 05:09:04 AM ()
1804: 1. Berthier 2. Murat 3. Moncey 5. Masséna 10. Lannes 11. Mortier 12. Ney 13. Davout 14. Bessières 17. Pérignon 18. Sérurier 1807: 19. Victor 1809: 20. MacDonald 21. Oudinot 1811: 23. Suchet 24. Gouvion Saint-Cyr 25. Poniatowski 26. Grouchy Results: Round one: Bernadotte 5, Grouchy 1, Poniatowski 1, Soult 1 Round two: Brune 4, Soult 2, Grouchy 1 Round three: Soult 4, Grouchy 1, Lefebvre 1 Round four: Grouchy 4, Lefebvre 1, Augereau 1, Ney 1 Round five: Lefebvre 2, Poniatowski 1, Augereau 1 Round six: Marmont 5, Poniatowski 1 Round seven: Poniatowski 2 (3 in previous rounds), Augereau 2 (2 in previous rounds) Round eight: Augereau 2 Round nine: Gouvion-Saint-Cyr 2, Jourdan 1 Round ten: Jourdan 4, Kellermann 1 Round eleven: Kellermann 2, Berthier 1 Rules: In each round, you vote for the marshal you want to eliminate. The marshal who has received the biggest total of votes is eliminated. In case of a tie, the marshal who has received the biggest total of votes in previous rounds is eliminated. In case of a new tie, I, Emperor of this survivor, will decide who is ousted. Each round is open for 24 hours +. ROUND TWELVE IS OPEN ! Vote away ! Title: Re: Napoleon's marshals survivor - round 12 Post by: big bad fab on January 30, 2010, 05:12:43 AM You know what ? I'm happy ! I didn't believe Valmy's hero could go so early...
Fine ! It seems as if the very small pack of voters (:() want the honorary marshals to go. So, I try Pérignon this round. Title: Re: Napoleon's marshals survivor - round 12 Post by: Swedish Rainbow Capitalist Cheese on January 30, 2010, 05:32:56 AM I never noticed this thread before...
Why did you vote out Bernadotte ??? Just because he became king of the most awsome kingdom on earth, and betrayed his own homecountry by allying with Frances enemy because he realised that the Napoleon Empire eventually was domed to fail. That's not a good enough reason :P Title: Re: Napoleon's marshals survivor - round 12 Post by: Hans-im-Glück on January 30, 2010, 10:23:20 AM Pérignon
Title: Re: Napoleon's marshals survivor - round 12 Post by: big bad fab on January 30, 2010, 10:52:26 AM I never noticed this thread before... Why did you vote out Bernadotte ??? Just because he became king of the most awsome kingdom on earth, and betrayed his own homecountry by allying with Frances enemy because he realised that the Napoleon Empire eventually was domed to fail. That's not a good enough reason :P I can't speak for the others, but, from a Napoleonic viewpoint, he was indeed the biggest traitor. And he wasn't a good marshal in the campaigns he took part in... In this survivor, it's a mix between military criterias and "national" criterias. I can't reveal my favourite for the moment, but he's quite obvious ;) As you know, there can't be any rule to force voters to have some "universally objective" criteria. In a way, one is allowed to eliminate Mandela and to keep Stalin if he wishes... Title: Re: Napoleon's marshals survivor - round 12 Post by: CatoMinor on January 30, 2010, 09:49:47 PM Ney
Title: Re: Napoleon's marshals survivor - round 12 Post by: The Dowager Mod on January 30, 2010, 10:48:35 PM Sérurier.
Title: Re: Napoleon's marshals survivor - round 12 Post by: MASHED POTATOES. VOTE! on January 30, 2010, 10:50:58 PM Murat
Title: Re: Napoleon's marshals survivor - round 13 Post by: big bad fab on February 01, 2010, 03:07:55 AM ()
1804: 1. Berthier 2. Murat 3. Moncey 5. Masséna 10. Lannes 11. Mortier 12. Ney 13. Davout 14. Bessières 18. Sérurier 1807: 19. Victor 1809: 20. MacDonald 21. Oudinot 1811: 23. Suchet 24. Gouvion Saint-Cyr 25. Poniatowski 26. Grouchy Results: Round one: Bernadotte 5, Grouchy 1, Poniatowski 1, Soult 1 Round two: Brune 4, Soult 2, Grouchy 1 Round three: Soult 4, Grouchy 1, Lefebvre 1 Round four: Grouchy 4, Lefebvre 1, Augereau 1, Ney 1 Round five: Lefebvre 2, Poniatowski 1, Augereau 1 Round six: Marmont 5, Poniatowski 1 Round seven: Poniatowski 2 (3 in previous rounds), Augereau 2 (2 in previous rounds) Round eight: Augereau 2 Round nine: Gouvion-Saint-Cyr 2, Jourdan 1 Round ten: Jourdan 4, Kellermann 1 Round eleven: Kellermann 2, Berthier 1 Round twelve: Pérignon 2, Ney 1, Murat 1, Sérurier 1 Rules: In each round, you vote for the marshal you want to eliminate. The marshal who has received the biggest total of votes is eliminated. In case of a tie, the marshal who has received the biggest total of votes in previous rounds is eliminated. In case of a new tie, I, Emperor of this survivor, will decide who is ousted. Each round is open for 24 hours +. ROUND THIRTEEN IS OPEN ! Vote away ! Title: Re: Napoleon's marshals survivor - round 13 Post by: big bad fab on February 01, 2010, 03:09:48 AM Sérurier, just to end all the "old" guys...
Title: Re: Napoleon's marshals survivor - round 13 Post by: Hans-im-Glück on February 01, 2010, 09:49:54 AM Sérurier
Title: Re: Napoleon's marshals survivor - round 13 Post by: The Dowager Mod on February 01, 2010, 09:50:09 PM Sérurier
Title: Re: Napoleon's marshals survivor - round 13 Post by: MASHED POTATOES. VOTE! on February 01, 2010, 10:15:18 PM Sérurier, just to end all the "old" guys... Title: Re: Napoleon's marshals survivor - round 14 Post by: big bad fab on February 02, 2010, 03:37:52 AM ()
1804: 1. Berthier 2. Murat 3. Moncey 5. Masséna 10. Lannes 11. Mortier 12. Ney 13. Davout 14. Bessières 1807: 19. Victor 1809: 20. MacDonald 21. Oudinot 1811: 23. Suchet 24. Gouvion Saint-Cyr 25. Poniatowski 26. Grouchy Results: Round one: Bernadotte 5, Grouchy 1, Poniatowski 1, Soult 1 Round two: Brune 4, Soult 2, Grouchy 1 Round three: Soult 4, Grouchy 1, Lefebvre 1 Round four: Grouchy 4, Lefebvre 1, Augereau 1, Ney 1 Round five: Lefebvre 2, Poniatowski 1, Augereau 1 Round six: Marmont 5, Poniatowski 1 Round seven: Poniatowski 2 (3 in previous rounds), Augereau 2 (2 in previous rounds) Round eight: Augereau 2 Round nine: Gouvion-Saint-Cyr 2, Jourdan 1 Round ten: Jourdan 4, Kellermann 1 Round eleven: Kellermann 2, Berthier 1 Round twelve: Pérignon 2, Ney 1, Murat 1, Sérurier 1 Round thirteen: Sérurier 4 Rules: In each round, you vote for the marshal you want to eliminate. The marshal who has received the biggest total of votes is eliminated. In case of a tie, the marshal who has received the biggest total of votes in previous rounds is eliminated. In case of a new tie, I, Emperor of this survivor, will decide who is ousted. Each round is open for 24 hours +. ROUND FOURTEEN IS OPEN ! Vote away ! Title: Re: Napoleon's marshals survivor - round 11 Post by: big bad fab on February 02, 2010, 03:40:21 AM Berthier Not a big soldier, not so loyal a man. Title: Re: Napoleon's marshals survivor - round 14 Post by: big bad fab on February 02, 2010, 03:42:02 AM Now, I think the field is clear for fiercer battles between big soldiers and/or big names...
Title: Re: Napoleon's marshals survivor - round 14 Post by: Hans-im-Glück on February 02, 2010, 02:03:54 PM Ney
Title: Re: Napoleon's marshals survivor - round 14 Post by: The Dowager Mod on February 02, 2010, 08:11:19 PM Mortier.
Title: Re: Napoleon's marshals survivor - round 14 Post by: big bad fab on February 03, 2010, 04:32:47 AM BUMP
Come & vote, guys ! Title: Re: Napoleon's marshals survivor - round 14 -come: only fine & known soldiers left ! Post by: MASHED POTATOES. VOTE! on February 03, 2010, 10:41:14 AM Murat
Title: Re: Napoleon's marshals survivor - round 15 Post by: big bad fab on February 03, 2010, 11:41:00 AM ()
1804: 1. Berthier 2. Murat 3. Moncey 5. Masséna 10. Lannes 11. Mortier 13. Davout 14. Bessières 1807: 19. Victor 1809: 20. MacDonald 21. Oudinot 1811: 23. Suchet 24. Gouvion Saint-Cyr 25. Poniatowski 26. Grouchy Results: Round one: Bernadotte 5, Grouchy 1, Poniatowski 1, Soult 1 Round two: Brune 4, Soult 2, Grouchy 1 Round three: Soult 4, Grouchy 1, Lefebvre 1 Round four: Grouchy 4, Lefebvre 1, Augereau 1, Ney 1 Round five: Lefebvre 2, Poniatowski 1, Augereau 1 Round six: Marmont 5, Poniatowski 1 Round seven: Poniatowski 2 (3 in previous rounds), Augereau 2 (2 in previous rounds) Round eight: Augereau 2 Round nine: Gouvion-Saint-Cyr 2, Jourdan 1 Round ten: Jourdan 4, Kellermann 1 Round eleven: Kellermann 2, Berthier 1 Round twelve: Pérignon 2, Ney 1, Murat 1, Sérurier 1 Round thirteen: Sérurier 4 Round fourteen: Ney 1 (2 in previous rounds), Murat 1 (1 in previous rounds), Berthier 1 (1 in previous rounds), Mortier 1 (0 in previous rounds) Rules: In each round, you vote for the marshal you want to eliminate. The marshal who has received the biggest total of votes is eliminated. In case of a tie, the marshal who has received the biggest total of votes in previous rounds is eliminated. In case of a new tie, I, Emperor of this survivor, will decide who is ousted. Each round is open for 24 hours +. ROUND FIFTEEN IS OPEN ! Vote away ! Title: Re: NAPOLEON's marshals survivor - round 15 -come: only fine & known soldiers left ! Post by: big bad fab on February 03, 2010, 11:46:05 AM A very sad round: again a low turnout, but Ney, a colourful one (;)), is eliminated before "lesser" fine ones... and with only one vote...
And he was a damn good soldier... he would have been fine in the last 5 (not more, sure, he was also a fine traitor...) Be careful, Hans ! ;) Berthier again. I understand Kal's vote against Murat (I sometimes compare him with Göring, due to titles, uniforms, ridiculousness... ;D but Murat was REALLY courageous and a REAL good soldier, even if a very poor politician). After Berthier and another one, I'll vote for Murat. Title: Re: NAPOLEON's marshals survivor - round 15 -come: only fine & known soldiers left ! Post by: Hash on February 03, 2010, 12:59:09 PM Berthier
Title: Re: NAPOLEON's marshals survivor - round 15 -come: only fine & known soldiers left ! Post by: Edu on February 03, 2010, 04:16:18 PM Title: Re: NAPOLEON's marshals survivor - round 15 -come: only fine & known soldiers left ! Post by: Hans-im-Glück on February 03, 2010, 04:31:52 PM Title: Re: Napoleon's marshals survivor - round 16 Post by: big bad fab on February 04, 2010, 11:11:09 AM ()
1804: 2. Murat 3. Moncey 5. Masséna 10. Lannes 11. Mortier 13. Davout 14. Bessières 1807: 19. Victor 1809: 20. MacDonald 21. Oudinot 1811: 23. Suchet 24. Gouvion Saint-Cyr 25. Poniatowski 26. Grouchy Results: Round one: Bernadotte 5, Grouchy 1, Poniatowski 1, Soult 1 Round two: Brune 4, Soult 2, Grouchy 1 Round three: Soult 4, Grouchy 1, Lefebvre 1 Round four: Grouchy 4, Lefebvre 1, Augereau 1, Ney 1 Round five: Lefebvre 2, Poniatowski 1, Augereau 1 Round six: Marmont 5, Poniatowski 1 Round seven: Poniatowski 2 (3 in previous rounds), Augereau 2 (2 in previous rounds) Round eight: Augereau 2 Round nine: Gouvion-Saint-Cyr 2, Jourdan 1 Round ten: Jourdan 4, Kellermann 1 Round eleven: Kellermann 2, Berthier 1 Round twelve: Pérignon 2, Ney 1, Murat 1, Sérurier 1 Round thirteen: Sérurier 4 Round fourteen: Ney 1 (2 in previous rounds), Murat 1 (1 in previous rounds), Berthier 1 (1 in previous rounds), Mortier 1 (0 in previous rounds) Round fifteen: Berthier 4 Rules: In each round, you vote for the marshal you want to eliminate. The marshal who has received the biggest total of votes is eliminated. In case of a tie, the marshal who has received the biggest total of votes in previous rounds is eliminated. In case of a new tie, I, Emperor of this survivor, will decide who is ousted. Each round is open for 24 hours +. ROUND SIXTEEN IS OPEN ! Vote away ! Title: Re: NAPOLEON's marshals survivor - round 16 -come: only fine soldiers left ! Post by: big bad fab on February 04, 2010, 11:18:54 AM Victor
wasn't a big soldier, hadn't big moral principles I think he can go before Murat ;) Title: Re: NAPOLEON's marshals survivor - round 16 -come: only fine soldiers left ! Post by: Hans-im-Glück on February 04, 2010, 01:20:53 PM Murat
Title: Re: NAPOLEON's marshals survivor - round 16 -come: only fine soldiers left ! Post by: The Dowager Mod on February 04, 2010, 08:52:53 PM Victor.
Title: Re: NAPOLEON's marshals survivor - round 16 -come: only fine soldiers left ! Post by: Edu on February 04, 2010, 09:27:07 PM Title: Re: NAPOLEON's marshals survivor - round 16 -come: only fine soldiers left ! Post by: Hash on February 05, 2010, 08:14:22 AM Victor
Title: Re: NAPOLEON's marshals survivor - round 16 -come: only fine soldiers left ! Post by: big bad fab on February 05, 2010, 08:15:58 AM Wow, I was posting Murat's defeat.... I take this into account, of course ! ;) Title: Re: Napoleon's marshals survivor - round 17 Post by: big bad fab on February 05, 2010, 08:18:36 AM ()
1804: 2. Murat 3. Moncey 5. Masséna 10. Lannes 11. Mortier 13. Davout 14. Bessières 19. Victor 1809: 20. MacDonald 21. Oudinot 1811: 23. Suchet 24. Gouvion Saint-Cyr 25. Poniatowski 26. Grouchy Results: Round one: Bernadotte 5, Grouchy 1, Poniatowski 1, Soult 1 Round two: Brune 4, Soult 2, Grouchy 1 Round three: Soult 4, Grouchy 1, Lefebvre 1 Round four: Grouchy 4, Lefebvre 1, Augereau 1, Ney 1 Round five: Lefebvre 2, Poniatowski 1, Augereau 1 Round six: Marmont 5, Poniatowski 1 Round seven: Poniatowski 2 (3 in previous rounds), Augereau 2 (2 in previous rounds) Round eight: Augereau 2 Round nine: Gouvion-Saint-Cyr 2, Jourdan 1 Round ten: Jourdan 4, Kellermann 1 Round eleven: Kellermann 2, Berthier 1 Round twelve: Pérignon 2, Ney 1, Murat 1, Sérurier 1 Round thirteen: Sérurier 4 Round fourteen: Ney 1 (2 in previous rounds), Murat 1 (1 in previous rounds), Berthier 1 (1 in previous rounds), Mortier 1 (0 in previous rounds) Round fifteen: Berthier 4 Round sixteen: Victor 3, Murat 2 Rules: In each round, you vote for the marshal you want to eliminate. The marshal who has received the biggest total of votes is eliminated. In case of a tie, the marshal who has received the biggest total of votes in previous rounds is eliminated. In case of a new tie, I, Emperor of this survivor, will decide who is ousted. Each round is open for 24 hours +. ROUND SEVENTEEN IS OPEN ! Vote away ! Title: Re: NAPOLEON's marshals survivor - round 17 - come & vote: only fine soldiers left ! Post by: big bad fab on February 05, 2010, 08:22:34 AM Hashemite has saved Murat, but not for long, I think.
Murat ! Fascinating soldier, but sort of a satrap... I really regret that Ney didn't last a bit longer, at least longer than Masséna, Mortier, Suchet. Title: Re: NAPOLEON's marshals survivor - round 17 - come & vote: only fine soldiers left ! Post by: MASHED POTATOES. VOTE! on February 05, 2010, 11:36:23 AM Murat
Title: Re: NAPOLEON's marshals survivor - round 17 - come & vote: only fine soldiers left ! Post by: Hans-im-Glück on February 05, 2010, 12:39:31 PM Title: Re: NAPOLEON's marshals survivor - round 17 - come & vote: only fine soldiers left ! Post by: The Dowager Mod on February 05, 2010, 08:01:39 PM Murat.
Title: Re: NAPOLEON's marshals survivor - round 17 - come & vote: only fine soldiers left ! Post by: Edu on February 06, 2010, 07:32:42 AM Title: Re: Napoleon's marshals survivor - round 18 Post by: big bad fab on February 06, 2010, 09:16:08 AM ()
1804: 3. Moncey 5. Masséna 10. Lannes 11. Mortier 13. Davout 14. Bessières 19. Victor 1809: 20. MacDonald 21. Oudinot 1811: 23. Suchet 24. Gouvion Saint-Cyr 25. Poniatowski 26. Grouchy Results: Round one: Bernadotte 5, Grouchy 1, Poniatowski 1, Soult 1 Round two: Brune 4, Soult 2, Grouchy 1 Round three: Soult 4, Grouchy 1, Lefebvre 1 Round four: Grouchy 4, Lefebvre 1, Augereau 1, Ney 1 Round five: Lefebvre 2, Poniatowski 1, Augereau 1 Round six: Marmont 5, Poniatowski 1 Round seven: Poniatowski 2 (3 in previous rounds), Augereau 2 (2 in previous rounds) Round eight: Augereau 2 Round nine: Gouvion-Saint-Cyr 2, Jourdan 1 Round ten: Jourdan 4, Kellermann 1 Round eleven: Kellermann 2, Berthier 1 Round twelve: Pérignon 2, Ney 1, Murat 1, Sérurier 1 Round thirteen: Sérurier 4 Round fourteen: Ney 1 (2 in previous rounds), Murat 1 (1 in previous rounds), Berthier 1 (1 in previous rounds), Mortier 1 (0 in previous rounds) Round fifteen: Berthier 4 Round sixteen: Victor 3, Murat 2 Round seventeen: Murat 5 Rules: In each round, you vote for the marshal you want to eliminate. The marshal who has received the biggest total of votes is eliminated. In case of a tie, the marshal who has received the biggest total of votes in previous rounds is eliminated. In case of a new tie, I, Emperor of this survivor, will decide who is ousted. Each round is open for 24 hours +. ROUND EIGHTEEN IS OPEN ! Vote away ! Title: Re: NAPOLEON's marshals survivor - round 18 - come & vote: only fine soldiers left ! Post by: big bad fab on February 06, 2010, 09:18:51 AM Masséna
Repressive looter and stealer... Title: Re: NAPOLEON's marshals survivor - round 18 - come & vote: only fine soldiers left ! Post by: Hans-im-Glück on February 06, 2010, 01:36:50 PM Title: Re: NAPOLEON's marshals survivor - round 18 - come & vote: only fine soldiers left ! Post by: The Dowager Mod on February 06, 2010, 10:13:07 PM Mortier.
Title: Re: NAPOLEON's marshals survivor - round 18 - come & vote: only fine soldiers left ! Post by: MASHED POTATOES. VOTE! on February 07, 2010, 10:10:14 PM Title: Re: Napoleon's marshals survivor - round 19 Post by: big bad fab on February 08, 2010, 03:30:37 AM ()
1804: 3. Moncey 5. Masséna 10. Lannes 13. Davout 14. Bessières 19. Victor 1809: 20. MacDonald 21. Oudinot 1811: 23. Suchet 24. Gouvion Saint-Cyr 25. Poniatowski 26. Grouchy Results: Round one: Bernadotte 5, Grouchy 1, Poniatowski 1, Soult 1 Round two: Brune 4, Soult 2, Grouchy 1 Round three: Soult 4, Grouchy 1, Lefebvre 1 Round four: Grouchy 4, Lefebvre 1, Augereau 1, Ney 1 Round five: Lefebvre 2, Poniatowski 1, Augereau 1 Round six: Marmont 5, Poniatowski 1 Round seven: Poniatowski 2 (3 in previous rounds), Augereau 2 (2 in previous rounds) Round eight: Augereau 2 Round nine: Gouvion-Saint-Cyr 2, Jourdan 1 Round ten: Jourdan 4, Kellermann 1 Round eleven: Kellermann 2, Berthier 1 Round twelve: Pérignon 2, Ney 1, Murat 1, Sérurier 1 Round thirteen: Sérurier 4 Round fourteen: Ney 1 (2 in previous rounds), Murat 1 (1 in previous rounds), Berthier 1 (1 in previous rounds), Mortier 1 (0 in previous rounds) Round fifteen: Berthier 4 Round sixteen: Victor 3, Murat 2 Round seventeen: Murat 5 Round eighteen: Mortier 2 (1 in previous rounds), Masséna 2 (0 in previous rounds) Rules: In each round, you vote for the marshal you want to eliminate. The marshal who has received the biggest total of votes is eliminated. In case of a tie, the marshal who has received the biggest total of votes in previous rounds is eliminated. In case of a new tie, I, Emperor of this survivor, will decide who is ousted. Each round is open for 24 hours +. ROUND NINETEEN IS OPEN ! Vote away ! Title: Re: NAPOLEON's marshals survivor - round 18 - come & vote: only fine soldiers left ! Post by: big bad fab on February 08, 2010, 03:32:21 AM A bit unfair, I think, to oust Mortier, a brave and mostly honest officier, before Masséna.
Masséna again. Title: Re: NAPOLEON's marshals survivor - round 19 - vote in the top 8 Post by: Hans-im-Glück on February 08, 2010, 09:49:07 AM Masséna
Title: Re: Napoleon's marshals survivor - round 20 Post by: big bad fab on February 09, 2010, 04:11:08 AM ()
1804: 3. Moncey 10. Lannes 13. Davout 14. Bessières 19. Victor 1809: 20. MacDonald 21. Oudinot 1811: 23. Suchet 24. Gouvion Saint-Cyr 25. Poniatowski 26. Grouchy Results: Round one: Bernadotte 5, Grouchy 1, Poniatowski 1, Soult 1 Round two: Brune 4, Soult 2, Grouchy 1 Round three: Soult 4, Grouchy 1, Lefebvre 1 Round four: Grouchy 4, Lefebvre 1, Augereau 1, Ney 1 Round five: Lefebvre 2, Poniatowski 1, Augereau 1 Round six: Marmont 5, Poniatowski 1 Round seven: Poniatowski 2 (3 in previous rounds), Augereau 2 (2 in previous rounds) Round eight: Augereau 2 Round nine: Gouvion-Saint-Cyr 2, Jourdan 1 Round ten: Jourdan 4, Kellermann 1 Round eleven: Kellermann 2, Berthier 1 Round twelve: Pérignon 2, Ney 1, Murat 1, Sérurier 1 Round thirteen: Sérurier 4 Round fourteen: Ney 1 (2 in previous rounds), Murat 1 (1 in previous rounds), Berthier 1 (1 in previous rounds), Mortier 1 (0 in previous rounds) Round fifteen: Berthier 4 Round sixteen: Victor 3, Murat 2 Round seventeen: Murat 5 Round eighteen: Mortier 2 (1 in previous rounds), Masséna 2 (0 in previous rounds) Round nineteen: Masséna 2 Rules: In each round, you vote for the marshal you want to eliminate. The marshal who has received the biggest total of votes is eliminated. In case of a tie, the marshal who has received the biggest total of votes in previous rounds is eliminated. In case of a new tie, I, Emperor of this survivor, will decide who is ousted. Each round is open for 24 hours +. ROUND TWENTY IS OPEN ! Vote away ! Title: Re: NAPOLEON's marshals survivor - round 20 - top 7 ! Post by: big bad fab on February 09, 2010, 04:14:35 AM It's always fine to be face to face with my friend Hans, but a turnout of 2... :(
Come & vote ! It's really hard now, becausde the guys are no longer horrible ones and are pretty good soldiers. I think Bessières wasn't so good "strategically", though he was brave and able to lead in the field. And we need to pick someone... Title: Re: NAPOLEON's marshals survivor - round 20 - top 7 ! Post by: Hans-im-Glück on February 09, 2010, 10:49:51 AM Oudinot
Title: Re: NAPOLEON's marshals survivor - round 20 - top 7 ! Post by: Edu on February 09, 2010, 04:53:02 PM Bessières
Title: Re: Napoleon's marshals survivor - round 21 Post by: big bad fab on February 10, 2010, 05:36:56 AM ()
1804: 3. Moncey 10. Lannes 13. Davout 19. Victor 1809: 20. MacDonald 21. Oudinot 1811: 23. Suchet 24. Gouvion Saint-Cyr 25. Poniatowski 26. Grouchy Results: Round one: Bernadotte 5, Grouchy 1, Poniatowski 1, Soult 1 Round two: Brune 4, Soult 2, Grouchy 1 Round three: Soult 4, Grouchy 1, Lefebvre 1 Round four: Grouchy 4, Lefebvre 1, Augereau 1, Ney 1 Round five: Lefebvre 2, Poniatowski 1, Augereau 1 Round six: Marmont 5, Poniatowski 1 Round seven: Poniatowski 2 (3 in previous rounds), Augereau 2 (2 in previous rounds) Round eight: Augereau 2 Round nine: Gouvion-Saint-Cyr 2, Jourdan 1 Round ten: Jourdan 4, Kellermann 1 Round eleven: Kellermann 2, Berthier 1 Round twelve: Pérignon 2, Ney 1, Murat 1, Sérurier 1 Round thirteen: Sérurier 4 Round fourteen: Ney 1 (2 in previous rounds), Murat 1 (1 in previous rounds), Berthier 1 (1 in previous rounds), Mortier 1 (0 in previous rounds) Round fifteen: Berthier 4 Round sixteen: Victor 3, Murat 2 Round seventeen: Murat 5 Round eighteen: Mortier 2 (1 in previous rounds), Masséna 2 (0 in previous rounds) Round nineteen: Masséna 2 Round twenty: Bessières 2, Oudinot 1 Rules: In each round, you vote for the marshal you want to eliminate. The marshal who has received the biggest total of votes is eliminated. In case of a tie, the marshal who has received the biggest total of votes in previous rounds is eliminated. In case of a new tie, I, Emperor of this survivor, will decide who is ousted. Each round is open for 24 hours +. ROUND TWENTY-ONE IS OPEN ! Vote away ! Title: Re: NAPOLEON's marshals survivor - round 21 - top 6 ! Post by: big bad fab on February 10, 2010, 05:44:06 AM Moncey
Quite harsh in Spain and... in France. Even if he was aware of the risks of 1812 campaign. Even if he was loyal. But we need to keep on eliminating... Title: Re: NAPOLEON's marshals survivor - round 21 - top 6 ! Post by: Hans-im-Glück on February 10, 2010, 10:20:44 AM Oudinot
Title: Re: NAPOLEON's marshals survivor - round 21 - top 6 ! Post by: Edu on February 10, 2010, 12:57:53 PM Title: Re: Napoleon's marshals survivor - round 22 Post by: big bad fab on February 11, 2010, 04:41:28 AM ()
1804: 10. Lannes 13. Davout 19. Victor 1809: 20. MacDonald 21. Oudinot 1811: 23. Suchet 24. Gouvion Saint-Cyr 25. Poniatowski 26. Grouchy Results: Round one: Bernadotte 5, Grouchy 1, Poniatowski 1, Soult 1 Round two: Brune 4, Soult 2, Grouchy 1 Round three: Soult 4, Grouchy 1, Lefebvre 1 Round four: Grouchy 4, Lefebvre 1, Augereau 1, Ney 1 Round five: Lefebvre 2, Poniatowski 1, Augereau 1 Round six: Marmont 5, Poniatowski 1 Round seven: Poniatowski 2 (3 in previous rounds), Augereau 2 (2 in previous rounds) Round eight: Augereau 2 Round nine: Gouvion-Saint-Cyr 2, Jourdan 1 Round ten: Jourdan 4, Kellermann 1 Round eleven: Kellermann 2, Berthier 1 Round twelve: Pérignon 2, Ney 1, Murat 1, Sérurier 1 Round thirteen: Sérurier 4 Round fourteen: Ney 1 (2 in previous rounds), Murat 1 (1 in previous rounds), Berthier 1 (1 in previous rounds), Mortier 1 (0 in previous rounds) Round fifteen: Berthier 4 Round sixteen: Victor 3, Murat 2 Round seventeen: Murat 5 Round eighteen: Mortier 2 (1 in previous rounds), Masséna 2 (0 in previous rounds) Round nineteen: Masséna 2 Round twenty: Bessières 2, Oudinot 1 Round twenty-one: Moncey 2, Oudinot 1 Rules: In each round, you vote for the marshal you want to eliminate. The marshal who has received the biggest total of votes is eliminated. In case of a tie, the marshal who has received the biggest total of votes in previous rounds is eliminated. In case of a new tie, I, Emperor of this survivor, will decide who is ousted. Each round is open for 24 hours +. ROUND TWENTY-TWO IS OPEN ! Vote away ! Title: Re: NAPOLEON's marshals survivor - round 22 - top 5 ! Post by: big bad fab on February 11, 2010, 04:43:55 AM Suchet
(sorry, Hans, I can't for the Guard's marshal... La Garde meurt et ne se rend pas ! ;)) (oh, but I must add he is not my favourite... so I'll vote for Oudinot one day...) Title: Re: NAPOLEON's marshals survivor - round 22 - top 5 ! Post by: MASHED POTATOES. VOTE! on February 11, 2010, 08:39:22 AM Suchet
Title: Re: NAPOLEON's marshals survivor - round 22 - top 5 ! Post by: Edu on February 11, 2010, 11:55:07 AM Oudinot
Title: Re: NAPOLEON's marshals survivor - round 22 - top 5 ! Post by: Hans-im-Glück on February 11, 2010, 02:22:20 PM Title: Re: Napoleon's marshals survivor - round 23 Post by: big bad fab on February 12, 2010, 03:49:24 AM ()
1804: 10. Lannes 13. Davout 19. Victor 1809: 20. MacDonald 1811: 23. Suchet 24. Gouvion Saint-Cyr 25. Poniatowski 26. Grouchy Results: Round one: Bernadotte 5, Grouchy 1, Poniatowski 1, Soult 1 Round two: Brune 4, Soult 2, Grouchy 1 Round three: Soult 4, Grouchy 1, Lefebvre 1 Round four: Grouchy 4, Lefebvre 1, Augereau 1, Ney 1 Round five: Lefebvre 2, Poniatowski 1, Augereau 1 Round six: Marmont 5, Poniatowski 1 Round seven: Poniatowski 2 (3 in previous rounds), Augereau 2 (2 in previous rounds) Round eight: Augereau 2 Round nine: Gouvion-Saint-Cyr 2, Jourdan 1 Round ten: Jourdan 4, Kellermann 1 Round eleven: Kellermann 2, Berthier 1 Round twelve: Pérignon 2, Ney 1, Murat 1, Sérurier 1 Round thirteen: Sérurier 4 Round fourteen: Ney 1 (2 in previous rounds), Murat 1 (1 in previous rounds), Berthier 1 (1 in previous rounds), Mortier 1 (0 in previous rounds) Round fifteen: Berthier 4 Round sixteen: Victor 3, Murat 2 Round seventeen: Murat 5 Round eighteen: Mortier 2 (1 in previous rounds), Masséna 2 (0 in previous rounds) Round nineteen: Masséna 2 Round twenty: Bessières 2, Oudinot 1 Round twenty-one: Moncey 2, Oudinot 1 Round twenty-two: Oudinot 2 (2 in previous rounds), Suchet 2 (0 in previous rounds) Rules: In each round, you vote for the marshal you want to eliminate. The marshal who has received the biggest total of votes is eliminated. In case of a tie, the marshal who has received the biggest total of votes in previous rounds is eliminated. In case of a new tie, I, Emperor of this survivor, will decide who is ousted. Each round is open for 24 hours +. ROUND TWENTY-THREE IS OPEN ! Vote away ! Title: Re: NAPOLEON's marshals survivor - round 23 - top 4 ! Post by: big bad fab on February 12, 2010, 04:39:20 AM :(
Why Oudinot ? I really don't understand. Sure, I'd voted for him anyway in 1 or 2 rounds, but still, it's a bit early. Suchet for the moment. Title: Re: NAPOLEON's marshals survivor - round 23 - top 4 ! Post by: Hans-im-Glück on February 12, 2010, 10:39:03 AM Suchet
fab, I voted Oudinot in the last round I don't like his post-Napoleon life Title: Re: NAPOLEON's marshals survivor - round 23 - top 4 ! Post by: big bad fab on February 12, 2010, 10:45:41 AM Suchet fab, I voted Oudinot in the last round I don't like his post-Napoleon life Apart from Davout, all their post-Napoleon lives are pretty bad, therefore I may not take them into consideration enough ! Title: Re: NAPOLEON's marshals survivor - round 23 - top 4 ! Post by: Edu on February 12, 2010, 12:49:26 PM Suchet
fab, it's getting hard to chose some of these guys now, i'm no expert on napoleonic history and from what i read this was a good moment to oust him :P Title: Re: NAPOLEON's marshals survivor - round 23 - top 4 ! Post by: The Dowager Mod on February 13, 2010, 12:39:50 AM Suchet.
Title: Re: Napoleon's marshals survivor - round 24 Post by: big bad fab on February 13, 2010, 04:47:48 PM ()
1804: 10. Lannes 13. Davout 19. Victor 1809: 20. MacDonald 23. Suchet 24. Gouvion Saint-Cyr 25. Poniatowski 26. Grouchy Results: Round one: Bernadotte 5, Grouchy 1, Poniatowski 1, Soult 1 Round two: Brune 4, Soult 2, Grouchy 1 Round three: Soult 4, Grouchy 1, Lefebvre 1 Round four: Grouchy 4, Lefebvre 1, Augereau 1, Ney 1 Round five: Lefebvre 2, Poniatowski 1, Augereau 1 Round six: Marmont 5, Poniatowski 1 Round seven: Poniatowski 2 (3 in previous rounds), Augereau 2 (2 in previous rounds) Round eight: Augereau 2 Round nine: Gouvion-Saint-Cyr 2, Jourdan 1 Round ten: Jourdan 4, Kellermann 1 Round eleven: Kellermann 2, Berthier 1 Round twelve: Pérignon 2, Ney 1, Murat 1, Sérurier 1 Round thirteen: Sérurier 4 Round fourteen: Ney 1 (2 in previous rounds), Murat 1 (1 in previous rounds), Berthier 1 (1 in previous rounds), Mortier 1 (0 in previous rounds) Round fifteen: Berthier 4 Round sixteen: Victor 3, Murat 2 Round seventeen: Murat 5 Round eighteen: Mortier 2 (1 in previous rounds), Masséna 2 (0 in previous rounds) Round nineteen: Masséna 2 Round twenty: Bessières 2, Oudinot 1 Round twenty-one: Moncey 2, Oudinot 1 Round twenty-two: Oudinot 2 (2 in previous rounds), Suchet 2 (0 in previous rounds) Round twenty-three: Suchet 4 Rules: In each round, you vote for the marshal you want to eliminate. The marshal who has received the biggest total of votes is eliminated. In case of a tie, the marshal who has received the biggest total of votes in previous rounds is eliminated. In case of a new tie, I, Emperor of this survivor, will decide who is ousted. Each round is open for 24 hours +. ROUND TWENTY-FOUR IS OPEN ! Vote away ! Title: Re: NAPOLEON's marshals survivor - round 24 - top 3 ! Post by: big bad fab on February 13, 2010, 04:51:33 PM Glad to see Texasgurl back among us.
Well, this is really difficult now... or not ? Macdonald of course, because I can't deny the final to Lannes ;) Title: Re: NAPOLEON's marshals survivor - round 24 - top 3 ! Post by: Edu on February 13, 2010, 05:26:30 PM Macdonald
Title: Re: NAPOLEON's marshals survivor - round 24 - top 3 ! Post by: The Dowager Mod on February 13, 2010, 05:47:48 PM MacDonald.
Title: Re: NAPOLEON's marshals survivor - round 24 - top 3 ! Post by: Hans-im-Glück on February 14, 2010, 05:28:26 AM Lannes
Title: Re: NAPOLEON's marshals survivor - round 24 - top 3 ! Post by: MASHED POTATOES. VOTE! on February 14, 2010, 06:50:52 AM Title: Re: Napoleon's marshals survivor - round 25 Post by: big bad fab on February 15, 2010, 04:33:08 AM ()
1804: 10. Lannes 13. Davout 19. Victor 20. MacDonald 23. Suchet 24. Gouvion Saint-Cyr 25. Poniatowski 26. Grouchy Results: Round one: Bernadotte 5, Grouchy 1, Poniatowski 1, Soult 1 Round two: Brune 4, Soult 2, Grouchy 1 Round three: Soult 4, Grouchy 1, Lefebvre 1 Round four: Grouchy 4, Lefebvre 1, Augereau 1, Ney 1 Round five: Lefebvre 2, Poniatowski 1, Augereau 1 Round six: Marmont 5, Poniatowski 1 Round seven: Poniatowski 2 (3 in previous rounds), Augereau 2 (2 in previous rounds) Round eight: Augereau 2 Round nine: Gouvion-Saint-Cyr 2, Jourdan 1 Round ten: Jourdan 4, Kellermann 1 Round eleven: Kellermann 2, Berthier 1 Round twelve: Pérignon 2, Ney 1, Murat 1, Sérurier 1 Round thirteen: Sérurier 4 Round fourteen: Ney 1 (2 in previous rounds), Murat 1 (1 in previous rounds), Berthier 1 (1 in previous rounds), Mortier 1 (0 in previous rounds) Round fifteen: Berthier 4 Round sixteen: Victor 3, Murat 2 Round seventeen: Murat 5 Round eighteen: Mortier 2 (1 in previous rounds), Masséna 2 (0 in previous rounds) Round nineteen: Masséna 2 Round twenty: Bessières 2, Oudinot 1 Round twenty-one: Moncey 2, Oudinot 1 Round twenty-two: Oudinot 2 (2 in previous rounds), Suchet 2 (0 in previous rounds) Round twenty-three: Suchet 4 Round twenty-four: MacDonald 4, Lannes 1 Rules: In each round, you vote for the marshal you want to eliminate. The marshal who has received the biggest total of votes is eliminated. In case of a tie, the marshal who has received the biggest total of votes in previous rounds is eliminated. In case of a new tie, I, Emperor of this survivor, will decide who is ousted. Each round is open for 24 hours +. ROUND TWENTY-FIVE IS OPEN ! Vote away ! Beware: you still vote for the marshal you want to ELIMINATE. Title: Re: NAPOLEON's marshals survivor - round 25 - finale DAVOUT vs LANNES Post by: big bad fab on February 15, 2010, 04:35:01 AM No surprise in this finale.
No surprise in my vote, as Davout was both a good soldier and a fair, loyal and honest man: Eliminate Lannes Title: Re: NAPOLEON's marshals survivor - round 25 - finale DAVOUT vs LANNES Post by: MASHED POTATOES. VOTE! on February 15, 2010, 07:12:57 AM Eliminate Lannes
Title: Re: NAPOLEON's marshals survivor - round 25 - finale DAVOUT vs LANNES Post by: Hans-im-Glück on February 15, 2010, 10:36:41 AM Eliminate Lannes Title: Re: NAPOLEON's marshals survivor - round 25 - finale DAVOUT vs LANNES Post by: big bad fab on February 15, 2010, 11:44:36 AM Will Davout win without any negative vote ?
(I can remember only of Kim Dae Jung managing such a performance in a previous round) Title: Re: NAPOLEON's marshals survivor - round 25 - finale DAVOUT vs LANNES Post by: Edu on February 15, 2010, 12:08:46 PM Eliminate Davout
Just to mess with fab a little ;D Title: Re: NAPOLEON's marshals survivor - round 25 - finale DAVOUT vs LANNES Post by: RodPresident on February 15, 2010, 04:00:19 PM Bye Bye Lannes!
Title: Re: NAPOLEON's marshals survivor - round 25 - finale DAVOUT vs LANNES Post by: The Dowager Mod on February 15, 2010, 08:22:15 PM Lannes.
Title: Re: Napoleon's marshals survivor - round 25 Post by: big bad fab on February 16, 2010, 03:53:11 AM ()
1804: SURVIVOR 13. DavoutSURVIVOR 19. Victor 20. MacDonald 23. Suchet 24. Gouvion Saint-Cyr 25. Poniatowski 26. Grouchy Results: Round one: Bernadotte 5, Grouchy 1, Poniatowski 1, Soult 1 Round two: Brune 4, Soult 2, Grouchy 1 Round three: Soult 4, Grouchy 1, Lefebvre 1 Round four: Grouchy 4, Lefebvre 1, Augereau 1, Ney 1 Round five: Lefebvre 2, Poniatowski 1, Augereau 1 Round six: Marmont 5, Poniatowski 1 Round seven: Poniatowski 2 (3 in previous rounds), Augereau 2 (2 in previous rounds) Round eight: Augereau 2 Round nine: Gouvion-Saint-Cyr 2, Jourdan 1 Round ten: Jourdan 4, Kellermann 1 Round eleven: Kellermann 2, Berthier 1 Round twelve: Pérignon 2, Ney 1, Murat 1, Sérurier 1 Round thirteen: Sérurier 4 Round fourteen: Ney 1 (2 in previous rounds), Murat 1 (1 in previous rounds), Berthier 1 (1 in previous rounds), Mortier 1 (0 in previous rounds) Round fifteen: Berthier 4 Round sixteen: Victor 3, Murat 2 Round seventeen: Murat 5 Round eighteen: Mortier 2 (1 in previous rounds), Masséna 2 (0 in previous rounds) Round nineteen: Masséna 2 Round twenty: Bessières 2, Oudinot 1 Round twenty-one: Moncey 2, Oudinot 1 Round twenty-two: Oudinot 2 (2 in previous rounds), Suchet 2 (0 in previous rounds) Round twenty-three: Suchet 4 Round twenty-four: MacDonald 4, Lannes 1 Round twenty-five: Lannes 5, Davout 1 Davout is a survivor ! () |