Talk Elections

Other Elections - Analysis and Discussion => Gubernatorial/State Elections => Topic started by: Maxwell on October 19, 2014, 09:38:29 PM



Title: Which non-incumbent candidate is each party's strongest or weakest recruit?
Post by: Maxwell on October 19, 2014, 09:38:29 PM
Strongest -

R's: Tom Foley
D's: Tom Wolf

Weakest -

R's: Walt Havenstein
D's: Ed Fitzgerald, though Wendy Davis takes a good second


Title: Re: Which non-incumbent candidate is each party's strongest or weakest recruit?
Post by: Flake on October 19, 2014, 09:59:25 PM
Pubs: Foley
Dems: Carter

Pubs: Astorino
Dems: FitzGerald (really the clearest answer for weakest Democrat)


Title: Re: Which non-incumbent candidate is each party's strongest or weakest recruit?
Post by: IceSpear on October 19, 2014, 10:06:43 PM
Why bother asking weakest Democrat? That's a fact, not an opinion. :P

Strongest D: Tom Wolf
Strongest R: Charlie Baker

Weakest R: Pete Ricketts


Title: Re: Which non-incumbent candidate is each party's strongest or weakest recruit?
Post by: Vosem on October 19, 2014, 10:09:56 PM
Strongest D: Tom Wolf
Strongest R: Asa Hutchinson

Weakest D: Bob Goodman
Weakest R: Pete Ricketts


Title: Re: Which non-incumbent candidate is each party's strongest or weakest recruit?
Post by: moderatevoter on October 19, 2014, 10:11:49 PM
Strongest R: Charlie Baker, Asa Hutchison, or Bruce Rauner
Strongest D: Jason Carter

Weakest R: Pete Ricketts
Weakest D: People like Charlie Brown, Goodman, Hatch, and King weren't winning anyway. Out of the competitive ones, Ed FitzGerald.


Title: Re: Which non-incumbent candidate is each party's strongest or weakest recruit?
Post by: LeBron on October 20, 2014, 12:01:04 AM
Another attackfest on Fitzy. Oh joy. :-\

Strongest:
Republicans - Doug Ducey, a strong well-known, well-funded GOP nominee whose been running a smart campaign including on the immigration issue. Hutchinson (AR), Aiona (HI), Fung (RI), and Foley (CT) are honorable mentions.

Democrats - Jason Carter, though the runoff will keep him from winning, unfortunately despite his strength. Michaud (ME), Brown (MD), Wolf (PA), and Dorman (OK)/Balukoff (ID) are honorable mentions.

Weakest:
Republicans - Pete Ricketts, who's spending loads of money yet might still blow it again in a very red state (or come close to blowing it at least). Havenstein (NH) and Richardson (OR) are honorable mentions.

Democrats - Bob Goodman; the only Democratic candidate this year who didn't come in first for the nomination and is such a weak pick he won't be able to even break 40% in Nevada. Griffith (AL), Chrles Brown (TN), Coakley (MA) and Hatch (IA) also get honorable mentions. There's a good handful of others besides just them that come to mind as well.


Title: Re: Which non-incumbent candidate is each party's strongest or weakest recruit?
Post by: free my dawg on October 20, 2014, 12:10:02 AM
D: Mary Burke
R: Bruce Rauner

Weakest:
R: Pete Ricketts
D: Martha Coakley/Ed FitzGerald


Title: Re: Which non-incumbent candidate is each party's strongest or weakest recruit?
Post by: Miles on October 20, 2014, 12:10:53 AM
Best:

D: Carter or Michaud
R: Baker

Worst:

D: FitzGerald. They fielded Some Dudes in states like NV and TN but those were always expected to be Safe R.
R: Ricketts, but that's somewhat due to they really competitive primary which wasn't really his fault.