Talk Elections

?

option three, of course, but if the Hell as described in the New Testament exists, he almost certainly is.

question: are members of Hell allowed/able to mingle with one another?

Great topic for the Christian haters, BRTD!  ::)

I more want to see jmfcst and BushOklahoma rave about his sinful lifestyle.

topics like these tend to not attract jmfcst.  I have his forum behavioral patterns pretty well sketched out in my mind; I've been watching him for over 5.5 years, after all.

I actually think Harvey Milk and Jesus Christ are two very similar and comparable figures.

Option 4 - Don't know

Not because am unsure if his "lifestyle" itself is a one way ticket to Hell, as I don't think it was, but I don't know enough about the rest of the man to make any kind of judgment, nor can I say with any certainty how forgiving God is.  For all I know, everyone on this forum will end up in Hell, or perhaps none of us... or almost none of us, I guess sounds more likely.

There is no permanent hell.

Yes (Christian)

Not for me, or any of us for that matter, to say.

Even if they can't I hear there is wi-fi so they can chat online.

Wow, did you know that Harvey Milk's appointed successor was also gay and the guy almost beat Nancy Pelosi in 1987?

Secondary question then:

Does that mean seeing the movie is a sin?

And Milk served on the City Council at the same time as Ronald Pelosi, Nancy's father-in-law.

Everything's connected...

option 2 or 3 (Christian/Catholic)

Yes.

No such thing. The concept of 'Hell' is laughably childish/anthropomorphic.

If Christianity is correct I suppose so.

Was he a good person? 

I don't think being gay has any effect on going to Heaven or Hell.  (Catholic)

I can't wait to meet him at the gay bar in hell.

If he was anything like portrayed in the movie, the answer is an overwhelming yes.

Does the movie mention his links to the People's Temple? (not that that was especially unusual for San Francisco Democrats at the time).

dude...step off!  LOL!  you're a little too close for comfort and it's really weirding me out.

No.

Afraid he saw you slipping into the peeps?

But I suppose that's only in real life..

we can only live in secret for so long, hun

as long as don't try anything funny or tell me I walk confidently, like Keystone Phil told Naso, I'll let you hang around me.  but give me a little space and don't act stupid in front of the girls

anything for you

You do understand that our time is limited, don't you?...Ooops, sorry, my goldfish just died, looks like you're about to experience the exquisite pain of the homosexual, who goes home alone.

For the record, when I saw Naso a year ago (as opposed to two years ago when I said he walked confidently), he started walking around like he owned the place. I wanted to smack him.

Going home alone is hardly the exclusive misfortune of the homosexual, jmfcst.  In fact, I would venture to assert that he is actually less likely to go home alone than the heterosexual, male and female sexual proclivities being what they are.  But certainly no more likely. 

However, in fairness, if he is closeted and afraid to broach the topic with a fellow male, or to visit venues where homosexuality is assumed, then, perhaps you have hit the nail on the head.

By the way, speaking on topics of homosexuality generally, I recently had a few hours to kill in the Capital, and I betook myself to a place known as 'Babylon', a gay bathhouse.  Interestingly, however, I found the place and the patrons a huge turnoff.  Apparently enjoyment of the Ladyboy does not equal enjoyment of the masculine looking male.  I left entirely unrequited, and even a bit creeped out!

The old religious saying that man was made in God's image says nothing good about God if you look at it literally. Then again Old Testament god was an authoritarian dick.

3

Was he an atheist?

I chose 3.
Is the movie good? I heard it was good, but I want to hear it from a real person, as opposed to a newspaper columnist :-)

why is this being discussed?

My thoughts exactly!

Because the original poster is going to hell.  And if Harvey Milk is also there, he thinks he might at least be good for a handjob.

(Sorry BRTD -- you know I'm just teasing!)

Bipartisanship rules. This is what I would put down too.

This poll is missing the "No, he's in purgatory",  "No, he's in Valhalla", "No, he's in Tartarus", "No, he's in Mechanus"  and "No, he got reincarnated" options.  :P