Talk Elections

Other Elections - Analysis and Discussion => Congressional Elections => Topic started by: Хahar 🤔 on July 23, 2009, 12:59:31 PM



Title: Naming American Constituencies
Post by: Хahar 🤔 on July 23, 2009, 12:59:31 PM
There have been threads about this before, but this time I'll try it for real.

AL-1: Mobile
AL-2: Montgomery
AL-3: East Alabama
AL-4: Decatur—Gadsden
AL-5: North Alabama
AL-6: Outer Birmingham
AL-7: Birmingham—Tuscaloosa
AK-AL: Alaska
AZ-1: Northeast Arizona
AZ-2: Northwest Arizona
AZ-3: Phoenix North
AZ-4: Phoenix South
AZ-5: Scottsdale—Tempe
AZ-6: Chandler—Mesa
AZ-7: Southwest Arizona
AZ-8: Cochise—Tucson
AR-1: Arkansas Delta
AR-2: Little Rock
AR-3: Northwest Arkansas
AR-4: South Arkansas
CA-1: Napa—North Coast
CA-2: Redding
CA-3: Outer Sacramento
CA-4: Northeast California
CA-5: Sacramento
CA-6: Marin—Sonoma
CA-7: Richmond—Vacaville
CA-8: San Francisco
CA-9: Oakland
CA-10: Fairfield—Livermore
CA-11: Dublin—Tracy
CA-12: San Mateo
CA-13: Alameda—Fremont
CA-14: Redwood City
CA-15: San Jose West
CA-16: San Jose East
CA-17: Monterey
CA-18: San Joaquin West
CA-19: Yosemite
CA-20: Fresno
CA-21: San Joaquin East
CA-22: Bakersfield
CA-23: Central Coast—Channel Islands
CA-24: Santa Ynez
CA-25: Inner California
CA-26: San Gabriel Valley
CA-27: San Fernando West
CA-28: San Fernando East
CA-29: Glendale—Pasadena
CA-30: Santa Monica
CA-31: Los Angeles Center
CA-32: East Los Angeles
CA-33: Culver City
CA-34: Huntington Park
CA-35: Inglewood
CA-36: Torrance—Venice
CA-37: Long Beach
CA-38: Norwalk—Pomona
CA-39: Lynwood
CA-40: Orange North
CA-41: Inland Empire
CA-42: Los Angeles—Orange
CA-43: San Bernardino
CA-44: Orange—Riverside
CA-45: Riverside
CA-46: Santa Catalina
CA-47: Santa Ana
CA-48: Orange South
CA-49: Oceanside—Temecula
CA-50: Escondido
CA-51: Chula Vista—Imperial
CA-52: San Diego East
CA-53: San Diego
CO-1: Denver
CO-2: Boulder
CO-3: West Colorado
CO-4: East Colorado
CO-5: Colorado Springs
CO-6: Aurora—Littleton
CO-7: Outer Denver
CT-1: Hartford
CT-2: East Connecticut
CT-3: New Haven
CT-4: Fairfield
CT-5: Northwest Connecticut
DE-AL: Delaware


Title: Re: Naming American Constituencies
Post by: Badger on July 23, 2009, 01:38:58 PM
There have been threads about this before, but this time I'll try it for real.

AL-1: Mobile
AL-2: Montgomery
AL-3: East Alabama
AL-4: Decatur—Gadsden
AL-5: North Alabama
AL-6: Outer Birmingham
AL-7: Birmingham—Tuscaloosa
AK-AL: Alaska
AZ-1: Northeast Arizona
AZ-2: Northwest Arizona
AZ-3: Phoenix North
AZ-4: Phoenix South
AZ-5: Scottsdale—Tempe
AZ-6: Chandler—Mesa
AZ-7: Southwest Arizona
AZ-8: Cochise—Tucson
AR-1: Arkansas Delta
AR-2: Little Rock
AR-3: Northwest Arkansas
AR-4: South Arkansas
Neat! Sounds much cooler this way as in England.

Gets to be difficult when constituencies are gerrymandered into odd geographical mishmashes though.

Try mine for example: OH-4


Title: Re: Naming American Constituencies
Post by: memphis on July 23, 2009, 01:51:54 PM
The Voting Rights Act districts should be fun. Negroes of Maryland perhaps...


Title: Re: Naming American Constituencies
Post by: Verily on July 23, 2009, 02:40:07 PM
The Voting Rights Act districts should be fun. Negroes of Maryland perhaps...

The Earmuffs Empire of Chicago.


Title: Re: Naming American Constituencies
Post by: Meeker on July 23, 2009, 03:20:47 PM
Don't they sometimes, especially in Australia, name them after famous residents of the constituency/near-by area?


Title: Re: Naming American Constituencies
Post by: Verily on July 23, 2009, 03:42:48 PM
Don't they sometimes, especially in Australia, name them after famous residents of the constituency/near-by area?

In the US, that would probably result in them being named for their current congresspeople...

(Quebec also does that sometimes, both federally and provincially. It's also worth pointing out that the em-dash is Canadian style; in Britain, they would use "and" instead.)


Title: Re: Naming American Constituencies
Post by: Padfoot on July 23, 2009, 09:07:45 PM
There have been threads about this before, but this time I'll try it for real.

AL-1: Mobile
AL-2: Montgomery
AL-3: East Alabama
AL-4: Decatur—Gadsden
AL-5: North Alabama
AL-6: Outer Birmingham
AL-7: Birmingham—Tuscaloosa
AK-AL: Alaska
AZ-1: Northeast Arizona
AZ-2: Northwest Arizona
AZ-3: Phoenix North
AZ-4: Phoenix South
AZ-5: Scottsdale—Tempe
AZ-6: Chandler—Mesa
AZ-7: Southwest Arizona
AZ-8: Cochise—Tucson
AR-1: Arkansas Delta
AR-2: Little Rock
AR-3: Northwest Arkansas
AR-4: South Arkansas
Neat! Sounds much cooler this way as in England.

Gets to be difficult when constituencies are gerrymandered into odd geographical mishmashes though.

Try mine for example: OH-4

Lima-Mansfield seems appropriate for OH-4.  Its not pretty but it could be worse.  OH-6, OH-13, and OH-18 are the worst ones.


Title: Re: Naming American Constituencies
Post by: Smid on July 23, 2009, 09:43:41 PM
Don't they sometimes, especially in Australia, name them after famous residents of the constituency/near-by area?

In the US, that would probably result in them being named for their current congresspeople...

(Quebec also does that sometimes, both federally and provincially. It's also worth pointing out that the em-dash is Canadian style; in Britain, they would use "and" instead.)

Yes (federally, state-wise they're all named after locations) - we name some after geographic locations and some after famous people.

http://www.aec.gov.au/Electorates/Electoral_DPM/Guideline.htm
http://www.aec.gov.au/Electorates/Electoral_DPM/Origin_Current_Division.htm
http://www.aec.gov.au/Electorates/Electoral_DPM/Origin_Abolished_Division.htm

The famous people have to be dead in order to qualify. Sometimes they're named after an explorer through the area (eg. Leichardt, Bass, Cunningham), social workers (eg. Chisholm), Prime Ministers (very common), other famous politicians such as Premiers or Leaders of the Opposition, even poets (see the proposed new Queensland electorate announced today in a disgusting gerrymander of Wright, named after poet Judith Wright).


Title: Re: Naming American Constituencies
Post by: muon2 on July 23, 2009, 09:48:00 PM
The Voting Rights Act districts should be fun. Negroes of Maryland perhaps...

The Earmuffs Empire of Chicago.

IL-17 is a fun one, too.


Title: Re: Naming American Constituencies
Post by: Hatman 🍁 on July 23, 2009, 09:50:12 PM
I hate districts with names of people. I don't know why it has become so popular in Quebec.

Anyways, I remember doing this when I first joined the Atlas. It certainly had its moments.


Title: Re: Naming American Constituencies
Post by: Hatman 🍁 on July 23, 2009, 09:54:15 PM
Don't they sometimes, especially in Australia, name them after famous residents of the constituency/near-by area?

In the US, that would probably result in them being named for their current congresspeople...

(Quebec also does that sometimes, both federally and provincially. It's also worth pointing out that the em-dash is Canadian style; in Britain, they would use "and" instead.)

Yes (federally, state-wise they're all named after locations) - we name some after geographic locations and some after famous people.

http://www.aec.gov.au/Electorates/Electoral_DPM/Guideline.htm
http://www.aec.gov.au/Electorates/Electoral_DPM/Origin_Current_Division.htm
http://www.aec.gov.au/Electorates/Electoral_DPM/Origin_Abolished_Division.htm

The famous people have to be dead in order to qualify. Sometimes they're named after an explorer through the area (eg. Leichardt, Bass, Cunningham), social workers (eg. Chisholm), Prime Ministers (very common), other famous politicians such as Premiers or Leaders of the Opposition, even poets (see the proposed new Queensland electorate announced today in a disgusting gerrymander of Wright, named after poet Judith Wright).

Disgusting :(

Another cool project would be giving names to the Australian divisions.


Title: Re: Naming American Constituencies
Post by: Filuwaúrdjan on July 24, 2009, 03:58:07 AM
There's actually a British constituency named after a person rather than a geographical location; Islwyn (the pen-name of 19th century poet William Thomas) in South Wales.


Title: Re: Naming American Constituencies
Post by: minionofmidas on July 24, 2009, 05:59:22 AM
Oh. I thought that was some obscure geographic term for the area.


Title: Re: Naming American Constituencies
Post by: Filuwaúrdjan on July 24, 2009, 06:26:14 AM
Oh. I thought that was some obscure geographic term for the area.

An obscure term for part of the area is Mynyddislwyn (which is what Thomas took Islwyn from). But until the 1974 local government vandalism, "Islwyn" on its own was only associated with the poet.


Title: Re: Naming American Constituencies
Post by: Badger on July 24, 2009, 12:48:51 PM
There have been threads about this before, but this time I'll try it for real.

AL-1: Mobile
AL-2: Montgomery
AL-3: East Alabama
AL-4: Decatur—Gadsden
AL-5: North Alabama
AL-6: Outer Birmingham
AL-7: Birmingham—Tuscaloosa
AK-AL: Alaska
AZ-1: Northeast Arizona
AZ-2: Northwest Arizona
AZ-3: Phoenix North
AZ-4: Phoenix South
AZ-5: Scottsdale—Tempe
AZ-6: Chandler—Mesa
AZ-7: Southwest Arizona
AZ-8: Cochise—Tucson
AR-1: Arkansas Delta
AR-2: Little Rock
AR-3: Northwest Arkansas
AR-4: South Arkansas
Neat! Sounds much cooler this way as in England.

Gets to be difficult when constituencies are gerrymandered into odd geographical mishmashes though.

Try mine for example: OH-4

Lima-Mansfield seems appropriate for OH-4.  Its not pretty but it could be worse.  OH-6, OH-13, and OH-18 are the worst ones.
Reasonable enough, I agree.


Title: Re: Naming American Constituencies
Post by: MaxQue on July 29, 2009, 09:54:24 PM
I hate districts with names of people. I don't know why it has become so popular in Quebec.

Anyways, I remember doing this when I first joined the Atlas. It certainly had its moments.

By the way, Elections Canada is talking of the ''March 9, 2009'' 40th general election!

http://www.elections.ca/content.asp?section=ele&dir=40ge&document=index&lang=e&textonly=false (http://www.elections.ca/content.asp?section=ele&dir=40ge&document=index&lang=e&textonly=false)


Title: Re: Naming American Constituencies
Post by: Person Man on July 30, 2009, 12:23:50 AM
Let me continue this list-
Names probably suck because of rapid growth and corruption on top of it (gerrymandering)

FL-01 - West Florida
FL-02- Pensacola
FL-03- St. John's-University of Florida
FL-04- Lake City
FL-05- Nature Coast
FL-06- Ocala Forest
FL-07- St.Augustine
FL-08- Orlando
FL-09- Clearwater-Thonotosasa
FL-10- Rural Pinellas
FL-11- Tampa Bay
FL-12- Lakeland
FL-13- Sarasota-Brandenton
FL-14- Naples
FL-15- St.Cloud-Atlantic
FL-16- Palm Beach-Okeechobee
FL-17- North Miami
FL-18- Miami-Keys
FL-19- Coral Springs- North
FL-20- Ft. Lauderdale
FL-21- Haileah
FL-22- North Gold Coast
FL-23- Pompano- Okeechobee
FL-24- Space Coast
FL-25- Crocodile Bay

Georgia
GA-1- South Savanah
GA-2- Southest Georgia
GA-3- Western Georgia
GA-4- East Atlanta
GA-5- Atlanta
GA-6- North Atlanta
GA-7- Exurban North Atlanta
GA-8- Macon
GA-9- Georgia Mountain Zone
GA-10- Athens
GA-11- Northeastern Georgia
GA-12- Savanah
GA-13- South Atlanta

Hawaii

HI-1- North Hawaii
HI-2- Oahu

Idaho-
ID-1- Teton West Slope
ID-2- Couer D'Arlene-Boise

Illinois-
IL-1- Nearer Eastern Chicago
IL-2- Further Eastern Chicago
IL-3- South Chicago
IL-4- Chicago Centro
IL-5- Chicago Northlake
IL-6- Northeast Chicago Exurbs
IL-7- Northern Chicago
IL-8- Northern Chicago Exurbs
IL-9- Northen Chicaho Suburbs
IL-10- North Chicago
IL-11- Bloomington-Normal
IL-12- East St. Louis
IL-13- Southwestern Chicago
IL-14- Aurora
IL-15- Champaign
IL-16- Rockford
IL-17- Quad Cities
IL-18- Springfeild
IL-19- Mount Vernon


Title: Re: Naming American Constituencies
Post by: Vepres on July 30, 2009, 12:52:21 AM
More names:

CO-2: Hippies of the west
CO-5: The we're almost as radical as the Mormons district
MN-6: WTF
AZ-2: So gerrymandered it's not even funny
CA-30: Rats

Hope you get the last one.


Title: Re: Naming American Constituencies
Post by: Platypus on July 30, 2009, 12:04:31 PM
I like the Australian system, because it's inclusive. Take my seat for example - its current name is Melbourne Ports, which is ridiculous because it doesn't even include the current main port, although it did at federation - it linked the naval base at williamstown through the yarra mouth docks to Port Melbourne, which was the main passenger dock as well as important for shipping. Now, it heads along the beach to the southeastern suburbs. Even if the name had changed over time, it'd be something like Caulfield-St. Kilda-South Melbourne, excluding all the other localities within the seat. Changing it something like "Crean", "Whitlam" or "Cheng" would be great - or at least "Hobson's Bay" or "Port Phillip".


Title: Re: Naming American Constituencies
Post by: True Federalist (진정한 연방 주의자) on July 30, 2009, 03:45:11 PM
Suggestions for SC:

SC-1:Charleston-Grand Strand
SC-2:Midlands-Lower Savannah River
SC-3:Upper Savannah River
SC-4:Greenville-Spartanburg
SC-5:Northern South Carolina
SC-6:Lowcountry


Title: Re: Naming American Constituencies
Post by: muon2 on July 30, 2009, 10:28:26 PM
Illinois-
IL-1- Nearer Eastern Chicago
IL-2- Further Eastern Chicago
IL-3- South Chicago
IL-4- Chicago Centro
IL-5- Chicago Northlake
IL-6- Northeast Chicago Exurbs
IL-7- Northern Chicago
IL-8- Northern Chicago Exurbs
IL-9- Northen Chicaho Suburbs
IL-10- North Chicago
IL-11- Bloomington-Normal
IL-12- East St. Louis
IL-13- Southwestern Chicago
IL-14- Aurora
IL-15- Champaign
IL-16- Rockford
IL-17- Quad Cities
IL-18- Springfeild
IL-19- Mount Vernon

I'd make a few changes to your list for IL:

IL-1- Nearer Eastern Chicago (Chicago South Side): This is really the heart of the south side going into South Cook. It would be confusing to put any compass direction in front of "Chicago" since there are suburbs that use that form.

IL-2- Further Eastern Chicago (Chicago South Shore): East Chicago is in IN, so it's confusing here. The lake is an easy reference and the district even includes a neighborhood known as South Shore.

IL-3- South Chicago (Chicago Midway): The Chicago parts of this district are never called south, but they are called southwest. Midway airport is centrally located and is a frequent reference name for the neighborhoods in that area, though if you used Chicago-Southwest Cook I wouldn't complain.

IL-4- Chicago Centro (Chicago Logan Square-Cicero): Your name is cute, but it isn't really the center which is in CD-7. Logan Square is the dominant neighborhood in the northern piece and Cicero (10th largest in IL) is the largest non-Chicago community on the south piece of the district, though you could just as easily use the neighborhood name and call it Chicago Logan Square - Little Village.

IL-5- Chicago Northlake (Chicago North Side): Northlake isn't that big, and not much of the district is outside the city. There's a lot of separate neighborhood names I might choose from, but north side says it pretty well.

IL-6- Northeast Chicago Exurbs (DuPage): The suburbs here aren't in the northeast, if anything they include a large part of what are called the northwest and west suburbs. These are also not exurbs - those are currently in CDs 11, 14 and 16 a good 20 miles farther out than CD 6. DuPage County dominates the district and is a pretty clear choice for this district unless you want to use Wheaton which is the county seat and largest city in the district.

IL-7- Northern Chicago (Chicago West Side): There's nothing northern about this district. I could use the dominant neighborhood and call it Chicago Austin (over 100 K residents), but west side is pretty clear.

IL-8- Northern Chicago Exurbs (Schaumburg): The McHenry and far northern Lake parts of the district are exurban, but a lot of the population is in northwest Cook County. Schaumburg anchors NW Cook, is the 16th largest community in IL, and is the 2nd largest job center in the state after the Loop.

IL-9- Northen Chicaho Suburbs (Evanston): Northern Chicago Suburbs suggests parts of CD 8 and 10 to the locals here. Evanston or Evanston-North Cook would describe this better.

IL-10- North Chicago (Waukegan-Arlington Heights) Waukegan (9th largest in IL) and Arlington Heights (14th largest) are both much more significant communities than North Chicago and they nicely anchor ends of the district.

IL-11- Bloomington-Normal (Joliet): B-N is at the end of a gerrymander and is not that significant to the district. This is the Will County seat and Joliet is the 4th largest city in the state.

IL-12- East St. Louis: Not a bad choice, but if a hyphen was used East St. Louis-Carbondale would give a better sense of the scope of the district.

IL-13- Southwestern Chicago (Naperville): Naperville is the fifth largest city in the state and dominates the district with almost a quarter of the population.

IL-14- Aurora (Aurora-Elgin): Elgin (8th largest in IL) is almost as significant of a community as Aurora in the district, especially since the DuPage part of Aurora is in IL 13. If you had to go with one, Aurora is the right choice.

IL-15- Champaign: Good choice

IL-16- Rockford: Good choice

IL-17- Quad Cities: Good choice

IL-18- Springfeild (Peoria): Springfield is fairly evenly split between IL-18 and 19 with a block-wide slice of IL-17 down the middle. Peoria is the dominant city in the district.

IL-19- Mount Vernon (Southern Illinois): There's no dominant community in this district, and a big chunk of the population is in the Metro East suburbs of St. Louis. I'd go with the generic name.


Title: Re: Naming American Constituencies
Post by: ?????????? on July 30, 2009, 10:33:50 PM

FL-09- Clearwater-Thonotosasa
FL-10- Rural Pinellas

FL-09- Rural Greece to Rural Biblebelt
FL-10- Beachfront and Bayside

I'd hardly call FL 10 rural. That's hilarious to say the least. And you spelled Thonotosassa wrong.


Title: Re: Naming American Constituencies
Post by: Hatman 🍁 on July 30, 2009, 10:49:49 PM
Many of the names presented are fail. muon seems to understand how this works, though.


Title: Re: Naming American Constituencies
Post by: fezzyfestoon on July 30, 2009, 11:06:38 PM
New Jersey:
1 - Camden
2 - South Jersey
3 - Cherry Hill-Long Beach
4 - Trenton-Point Pleasant
5 - North Bergen-Phillipsburg
6 - New Brunswick-Asbury Park
7 - Union-North Hunterdon
8 - Paterson
9 - South Bergen
10 - Newark
11 - Morris
12 - Princeton
13 - Hudson

It's hard when most of them stretch across the state joining completely unrelated areas.


Title: Re: Naming American Constituencies
Post by: HAnnA MArin County on July 31, 2009, 12:35:09 AM
Oh yay, this sounds fun! Can I submit Missouri? I don't know if I did it right, but here goes! :)

MO-01: St. Louis City - University City, Maryland Heights, Florissant
MO-02: St. Louis Suburbs - St. Charles, St. Peters, Chesterfield, Kirkwood
MO-03: Southern St. Louis & Suburbs - Webster Groves, Oakville, Mehlville, Arnold, Festus, Ste. Genevieve
MO-04: West Central - Jefferson City, Sedalia, Warrensburg, Marshall, Lebanon
MO-05: Kansas City - Independence, Raytown, Lees Summit
MO-06: Northwest - St. Joseph, Blue Springs, Liberty, Maryville, Excelsior Springs
MO-07: Southwest - Springfield, Joplin, Neosho, Carthage, Branson
MO-08: Southeast - Cape Girardeau, Rolla, Sikeston, Poplar Bluff, Farmington, Jackson, West Plains, Kennett
MO-09: Northeast - Columbia, Moberly, Hannibal, Kirksville


Title: Re: Naming American Constituencies
Post by: muon2 on July 31, 2009, 12:41:05 AM
Many of the names presented are fail. muon seems to understand how this works, though.


Thanks. :)


Title: Re: Naming American Constituencies
Post by: Хahar 🤔 on July 31, 2009, 03:53:47 PM
Many of the names presented are fail. muon seems to understand how this works, though.

Do I?


Title: Re: Naming American Constituencies
Post by: TeePee4Prez on July 31, 2009, 03:56:57 PM
Pennsylvania

PA-01: Philadelphia East and Southwest
PA-02: Philadelphia North and West
PA-03: Northwestern Pennsylvania- Erie
PA-04: Northern Pittsburgh Suburbs
PA-05: North Central PA- State College
PA-06: Western Philadelphia Suburbs- Norristown
PA-07: Southwestern Philadelphia Suburbs- Media
PA-08: Northern Philadelphia Suburbs- Doylestown
PA-09: West South Central Pennsylvania- Altoona
PA-10: Far Northeastern Pennsylvania- Williamsport, Eastern Poconos
PA-11: Lower Northeastern Pennsylvania- Scranton, Hazelton, Stroudsburg
PA-12:  MURTHASTAN.  No kidding! Southwestern Pennsylvania- Johnstown, Uniontown
PA-13: Northeast Philadelphia-Eastern Montgomery
PA-14: Greater Pittsburgh
PA-15: Lehigh Valley-  Allentown, Bethlehem, Easton
PA-16: (East South Central/Outer Southeast?) Pennsylvania- West Chester, Lancaster
PA-17: East Central Pennsylvania- Harrisburg, Pottsville
PA-18: Southern Pittsburgh Suburbs
PA-19: South Central Pennsylvania- York, Gettysburg   


Title: Re: Naming American Constituencies
Post by: Hatman 🍁 on July 31, 2009, 04:51:39 PM
Many of the names presented are fail. muon seems to understand how this works, though.

Do I?

Somewhat, although one should never use a direction before a name, unless that is a common name for the area. In Canada, only one riding starts with a direction (South Surrey). They rest end in a direction. Otherwise, they're decent names. Love the emdashes!


Title: Re: Naming American Constituencies
Post by: Verily on July 31, 2009, 05:07:59 PM
NY-01: Suffolk Outer
NY-02: Suffolk Inner
NY-03: Levittown and Islip
NY-04: Hempstead
NY-05: Great Neck and Queens Flushing
NY-06: Queens Jamaica
NY-07: Bronx East and Queens Elmhurst
NY-08: Manhattan West and Brooklyn Gravesend
NY-09: Brooklyn Marine Park, Queens Woodhaven and Rockaway
NY-10: Brooklyn Bedford-Stuyvesant and New Lots
NY-11: Brooklyn Prospect Park
NY-12: Brooklyn Williamsburg and Greenwood
NY-13: Staten Island and Brooklyn Bay Ridge
NY-14: Manhattan East and Queens Astoria
NY-15: Manhattan North
NY-16: Bronx South
NY-17: Bronx North and Rockland
NY-18: Westchester (alternatively, White Plains)
NY-19: Hudson Valley South
NY-20: Hudson Valley North
NY-21: Albany and Schenectady
NY-22: Kingston and Ithaca
NY-23: Watertown and the Adirondacks
NY-24: Utica and Auburn (I don't know, this district sucks)
NY-25: Syracuse
NY-26: Batavia
NY-27: Buffalo
NY-28: Rochester and Niagara Falls
NY-29: Southern Tier


Title: Re: Naming American Constituencies
Post by: Hatman 🍁 on July 31, 2009, 05:19:29 PM
"outer" and "inner" should never be used in constituency names. I don't think they do that in the UK, do they?


Title: Re: Naming American Constituencies
Post by: Filuwaúrdjan on July 31, 2009, 05:20:56 PM
The idiots at the boundary commision have started to, alas. Still rare though.


Title: Re: Naming American Constituencies
Post by: Hatman 🍁 on July 31, 2009, 05:34:39 PM
Massachusetts

MA1 - Massachusetts West-Montachusett
MA2 - Springfield-Northampton-South County-Blackstone Valley
MA3 - Worcester-Middlesex-Norfolk-Bristol
MA4 - South Coast-Boston Southwest
MA5 - Merrimack Valley
MA6 - North Shore
MA7 - Boston North-Framingham
MA8 - Boston-Chelsea-Middlesex
MA 9 - Boston South
MA10 - South Shore-Cape Cod-The Islands


Title: Re: Naming American Constituencies
Post by: afleitch on July 31, 2009, 05:40:32 PM
That reminds me...I used that applet to create UK sized consituencies for some states - need to remember to post them.


Title: Re: Naming American Constituencies
Post by: Verily on July 31, 2009, 07:31:44 PM
"outer" and "inner" should never be used in constituency names. I don't think they do that in the UK, do they?

York Outer is a constituency on the new UK map. Plus, Suffolk Outer and Suffolk Inner describe the two seats better than Suffolk East and Suffolk West, which doesn't capture that the eastern seat is rural and exurban while the western seat is suburban.


Title: Re: Naming American Constituencies
Post by: Hatman 🍁 on July 31, 2009, 08:15:58 PM
CT 1 - Hartford-Litchfield Hills
CT 2 - Connecticut East
CT 3 - Connecticut South Central
CT 4 - Connecticut Panhandle
CT 5 - Connecticut Northwest


Title: Re: Naming American Constituencies
Post by: Hatman 🍁 on July 31, 2009, 08:39:52 PM
PA 1 - South Philadelphia-Delaware
PA 2 - West Philadelphia-Cheltenham
PA 3 - Pennsylvania Northwest
PA 4 - Lawrence-Mercer-Pittsburgh North
PA 5 - Pennsylvania North Central
PA 6 - Montgomery-Chester-Berks-Lehigh
PA 7 - Delaware-Chester-Montgomery
PA 8 - Bucks-Montgomery-Philadelphia
PA 9 - Pennsylvania South Central
PA 10 - Pennsylvania North East
PA 11 - Coal Region-Monroe
PA 12 - Pennsylvania Southwest
PA 13 - Montgomery-Philadelphia
PA 14 - Pittsburgh
PA 15 - Lehigh Valley-Montgomery
PA 16 - Lancaster-Chester-Berks
PA 17 - Dutch Country-Schuykill
PA 18 - Washington-Allegheny-Westmoreland
PA 19 - York-Adams-Cumberland


Title: Re: Naming American Constituencies
Post by: TeePee4Prez on July 31, 2009, 09:21:20 PM
PA 1 - South Philadelphia-Delaware
PA 2 - West Philadelphia-Cheltenham
PA 3 - Pennsylvania Northwest
PA 4 - Lawrence-Mercer-Pittsburgh North
PA 5 - Pennsylvania North Central
PA 6 - Montgomery-Chester-Berks-Lehigh
PA 7 - Delaware-Chester-Montgomery
PA 8 - Bucks-Montgomery-Philadelphia
PA 9 - Pennsylvania South Central
PA 10 - Pennsylvania North East
PA 11 - Coal Region-Monroe
PA 12 - Pennsylvania Southwest
PA 13 - Montgomery-Philadelphia
PA 14 - Pittsburgh
PA 15 - Lehigh Valley-Montgomery
PA 16 - Lancaster-Chester-Berks
PA 17 - Dutch Country-Schuykill
PA 18 - Washington-Allegheny-Westmoreland
PA 19 - York-Adams-Cumberland

PA 17 is not really Dutch Country, but it has some elements.  The heart of Dutch Country is in PA 16.  PA 17 could be called "Capital Region-Berks-Schuykill"


Title: Re: Naming American Constituencies
Post by: Hatman 🍁 on August 01, 2009, 12:17:36 AM
NY 1 - Suffolk East
NY 2 - Suffolk West-Plainview
NY 3 - Nassau East-South Shore
NY 4 - Nassau South
NY 5 - North Shore Long Island
NY 6 - Queens Southeast
NY 7 - Queens-Bronx
NY 8 - West Side-Brooklyn
NY 9 - Brooklyn-Queens
NY 10 - Brooklyn Northeast
NY 11 - Brooklyn Center
NY 12 - Brooklyn-Queens-Lower East Side
NY 13 - Staten Island-Brooklyn
NY 14 - East Side-Queens
NY 15 - Upper Manhattan-Queens
NY 16 - Bronx West
NY 17 - Rockland-Westchester-Bronx
NY 18 - Westchester-Rockland
NY 19 - Lower Hudson Valley
NY 20 - Upper Hudson Valley-Catskills
NY 21 - Capital District
NY 22 - Catskills-Finger Lakes
NY 23 - Adirondacks-Seaway
NY 24 - New York Central
NY 25 - Syracuse-Lake Ontario
NY 26 - New York West
NY 27 - Erie-Chautauqua
NY 28 - Buffalo-Niagara-Lake Ontario-Rochester
NY 29 - Southern Tier-Finger Lakes


Title: Re: Naming American Constituencies
Post by: Hatman 🍁 on August 01, 2009, 12:18:49 AM
PA 1 - South Philadelphia-Delaware
PA 2 - West Philadelphia-Cheltenham
PA 3 - Pennsylvania Northwest
PA 4 - Lawrence-Mercer-Pittsburgh North
PA 5 - Pennsylvania North Central
PA 6 - Montgomery-Chester-Berks-Lehigh
PA 7 - Delaware-Chester-Montgomery
PA 8 - Bucks-Montgomery-Philadelphia
PA 9 - Pennsylvania South Central
PA 10 - Pennsylvania North East
PA 11 - Coal Region-Monroe
PA 12 - Pennsylvania Southwest
PA 13 - Montgomery-Philadelphia
PA 14 - Pittsburgh
PA 15 - Lehigh Valley-Montgomery
PA 16 - Lancaster-Chester-Berks
PA 17 - Dutch Country-Schuykill
PA 18 - Washington-Allegheny-Westmoreland
PA 19 - York-Adams-Cumberland

PA 17 is not really Dutch Country, but it has some elements.  The heart of Dutch Country is in PA 16.  PA 17 could be called "Capital Region-Berks-Schuykill"

That might work. I was going by Wikipedia's definition of regions, since that's all I have to base some of these places.


Title: Re: Naming American Constituencies
Post by: Hatman 🍁 on August 01, 2009, 01:03:20 AM
NJ 1 - Camden-Gloucester-Burlington
NJ 2 - South Jersey
NJ 3 - Burlington-Ocean-Cherry Hill
NJ 4 - Burlington-Monmouth-Mercer-Ocean
NJ 5 - Bergen-Passaic-Sussex-Warren
NJ 6 - Monmouth-Sussex-Franklin-Plainfield
NJ 7 - Hunterdon-Middlesex-Somerset-Union
NJ 8 - Essex-Passaic
NJ 9 - Bergen-Hudson-Hawthorne
NJ 10 - Essex-Hudson-Union
NJ 11 - Skylands
NJ 12 - Central Jersey
NJ 13 - Hudson-Middlesex-Essex-Newark


Title: Re: Naming American Constituencies
Post by: Hatman 🍁 on August 01, 2009, 01:10:58 AM
MD 1 - Eastern Shore-Anne Arundel-Baltimore-Harford
MD 2 - Baltimore-Chesapeake
MD 3 - Baltimore-Anne Arundel-Harford
MD 4 - Prince George's-Montgomery
MD 5 - Maryland South-Capital
MD 6 - Maryland West
MD 7 - Baltimore-Howard
MD 8 - Capital North


Title: Re: Naming American Constituencies
Post by: Lunar on August 01, 2009, 02:38:32 AM
better names than the major cities for WV?

WV 1 - Parkersburg-Morgantown
WV 2 – Charleston-Martinsburg
WV 3 – Huntington-Bluefield


Title: Re: Naming American Constituencies
Post by: Lief 🗽 on August 01, 2009, 04:18:46 AM
Here's my (probably mediocre) shot at Texas. Is there a certain order the locations are supposed to go in in a constituency name? From biggest to smallest or from west to east or something?

TX-01: Tyler-Longview
TX-02: Beaumont-Port Arthur-Houston Northeast
TX-03: Plano-Dallas Northeast
TX-04: Rayburn (or Sherman-Paris-Texarkana, if you want to be boring)
TX-05: Dallas Southeast-Jacksonville
TX-06: Dallas Southwest-Crockett
TX-07: Houston West
TX-08: The Woodlands-Beaumont North
TX-09: Houston South
TX-10: East Central Texas
TX-11: West Central Texas
TX-12: Fort Worth West
TX-13: Texas Panhandle-Wichita Falls
TX-14: Texas Coastal Bend North
TX-15: South Central Texas
TX-16: El Paso
TX-17: Waco-College Station
TX-18: Houston Center
TX-19: Lubbock-Abilene
TX-20: San Antonio
TX-21: Texas Hill Country
TX-22: Sugarland-Houston Southeast
TX-23: Southwest Texas
TX-24: Fort Worth East-Dallas West
TX-25: Austin
TX-26: Denton
TX-27: Texas Coastal Bend South
TX-28: Laredo-San Antonio South
TX-29: Houston East-Baytown
TX-30: Dallas Center and South
TX-31: Round Rock-Killeen
TX-32: Dallas North


Title: Re: Naming American Constituencies
Post by: Hatman 🍁 on August 01, 2009, 09:39:40 AM
Here's my (probably mediocre) shot at Texas. Is there a certain order the locations are supposed to go in in a constituency name? From biggest to smallest or from west to east or something?


I think it's usually bigger to smaller, but I'm not 100% sure to be honest (for Canada, anyways). Sometimes it's in geographical order as well (Glengarry-Prescott-Russell comes to mind).


Title: Re: Naming American Constituencies
Post by: Hatman 🍁 on August 01, 2009, 09:59:00 AM
VA 1 - Chesepeake
VA 2 - Peninsula-Hampton Roads-Virginia Beach
VA 3 - James River
VA 4 - Virginia Southeast
VA 5 - Virginia South Central
VA 6 - Roanoke-Lynchburg-Shenandoah
VA 7 - Richmond-Appalachia
VA 8 - Arlington-Fairfax-Alexandria-Falls Church
VA 9 - Virginia Southwest
VA 10 - Virginia North
VA 11 - Fairfax-Prince William


Title: Re: Naming American Constituencies
Post by: fezzyfestoon on August 01, 2009, 10:06:35 AM
NJ 1 - Camden-Gloucester-Burlington
NJ 2 - South Jersey
NJ 3 - Burlington-Ocean-Cherry Hill
NJ 4 - Burlington-Monmouth-Mercer-Ocean
NJ 5 - Bergen-Passaic-Sussex-Warren
NJ 6 - Monmouth-Sussex-Franklin-Plainfield
NJ 7 - Hunterdon-Middlesex-Somerset-Union
NJ 8 - Essex-Passaic
NJ 9 - Bergen-Hudson-Hawthorne
NJ 10 - Essex-Hudson-Union
NJ 11 - Skylands
NJ 12 - Central Jersey
NJ 13 - Hudson-Middlesex-Essex-Newark

Skylands is kind of a stretch to call the Morris County based 11, but I like these.  What do you think of the ones I did?  I'll admit I don't know much about this. :P


Title: Re: Naming American Constituencies
Post by: Hatman 🍁 on August 01, 2009, 10:15:35 AM
NJ 1 - Camden-Gloucester-Burlington
NJ 2 - South Jersey
NJ 3 - Burlington-Ocean-Cherry Hill
NJ 4 - Burlington-Monmouth-Mercer-Ocean
NJ 5 - Bergen-Passaic-Sussex-Warren
NJ 6 - Monmouth-Sussex-Franklin-Plainfield
NJ 7 - Hunterdon-Middlesex-Somerset-Union
NJ 8 - Essex-Passaic
NJ 9 - Bergen-Hudson-Hawthorne
NJ 10 - Essex-Hudson-Union
NJ 11 - Skylands
NJ 12 - Central Jersey
NJ 13 - Hudson-Middlesex-Essex-Newark

Skylands is kind of a stretch to call the Morris County based 11, but I like these.  What do you think of the ones I did?  I'll admit I don't know much about this. :P

Quote
1 - Camden
2 - South Jersey
3 - Cherry Hill-Long Beach
4 - Trenton-Point Pleasant
5 - North Bergen-Phillipsburg
6 - New Brunswick-Asbury Park
7 - Union-North Hunterdon
8 - Paterson
9 - South Bergen
10 - Newark
11 - Morris
12 - Princeton
13 - Hudson
Not too bad actually, but I'm not a fan of using singular names for regions that encompass a greater area. And also, directionals should not precede the district name (South Jersey being an exception).


Title: Re: Naming American Constituencies
Post by: Sbane on August 03, 2009, 07:36:21 AM

CA-1: Napa—North Coast
CA-2: Redding
CA-3: Outer Sacramento
CA-4: Northeast California
CA-5: Sacramento
CA-6: Marin—Sonoma
CA-7: Richmond—Vacaville
CA-8: San Francisco
CA-9: Oakland
CA-10: Fairfield—Livermore
CA-11: Dublin—Tracy
CA-12: San Mateo
CA-13: Alameda—Fremont
CA-14: Redwood City
CA-15: San Jose West
CA-16: San Jose East
CA-17: Monterey
CA-18: San Joaquin West
CA-19: Yosemite
CA-20: Fresno
CA-21: San Joaquin East
CA-22: Bakersfield
CA-23: Central Coast—Channel Islands
CA-24: Santa Ynez
CA-25: Inner California
CA-26: San Gabriel Valley
CA-27: San Fernando West
CA-28: San Fernando East
CA-29: Glendale—Pasadena
CA-30: Santa Monica
CA-31: Los Angeles Center
CA-32: East Los Angeles
CA-33: Culver City
CA-34: Huntington Park
CA-35: Inglewood
CA-36: Torrance—Venice
CA-37: Long Beach
CA-38: Norwalk—Pomona
CA-39: Lynwood
CA-40: Orange North
CA-41: Inland Empire
CA-42: Los Angeles—Orange
CA-43: San Bernardino
CA-44: Orange—Riverside
CA-45: Riverside
CA-46: Santa Catalina
CA-47: Santa Ana
CA-48: Orange South
CA-49: Oceanside—Temecula
CA-50: Escondido
CA-51: Chula Vista—Imperial
CA-52: San Diego East
CA-53: San Diego


Here are my changes for some of the California districts.

CA-3: Citrus Heights-Elk Grove
CA-9: Oakland-Berkeley
CA-10: Fairfield- Walnut Creek-Livermore
CA-11: Pleasanton-Tracy
CA-12: San Mateo-Daly City
CA-14: Sunnyvale-Redwood City
CA-17: Monterey-Santa Cruz
CA-18: Stockton-Modesto
CA-19: Fresno north-Turlock
CA-20: Fresno-Bakersfield east
CA-21: Clovis-Visalia
CA-22: Bakersfield-Lancaster
CA-23: Santa Barbara-Oxnard
CA-24: Thousand Oaks-Simi Valley
CA-25: Santa Clarita-Palmdale
CA-26: Rancho Cucamonga-Arcadia
CA-27: Burbank-San Fernando valley west
CA-28: San Fernando valley east
CA-30: Santa Monica- Los Angeles west
CA-31: Hollywood- Griffith park
CA-32: El Monte-West Covina
CA-33: Culver City- Miracle mile
CA-34: Downtown Los Angeles-Downey
CA-35: Los Angeles south-Inglewood
CA-37: Long Beach-Compton
CA-38: Norwalk-Pico Rivera-Pomona
CA-39: Whittier-Lakewood-South Gate
CA-40: Fullerton-Orange
CA-41: Redlands-Hesperia
CA-42: Mission Viejo-Yorba Linda-Chino valley
CA-43: San Bernardino-Ontario
CA-44: Riverside-Corona
CA-45: Palm Springs-Moreno Valley
CA-46: Huntington Beach-Westminster
CA-47: Santa Ana-Anaheim
CA-48: Irvine-Laguna
CA-50: Escondido-Carlsbad
CA-52: San Diego east- El Cajon





Title: Re: Naming American Constituencies
Post by: Brittain33 on August 03, 2009, 11:33:17 AM

Vale of Merrimack


Title: Re: Naming American Constituencies
Post by: minionofmidas on August 03, 2009, 04:49:01 PM
The idiots at the boundary commision have started to, alas. Still rare though.
Outer, yes. But not Inner.

But of course Suffolk Central and Suffolk Outer makes no sense.


Title: Re: Naming American Constituencies
Post by: minionofmidas on August 03, 2009, 04:50:02 PM
AZ-1: Northeast Arizona
AZ-2: Northwest Arizona
AZ-3: Phoenix North
AZ-4: Phoenix South
AZ-5: Scottsdale—Tempe
AZ-6: Chandler—Mesa
AZ-7: Southwest Arizona
AZ-8: Cochise—Tucson
Both Chandler and Mesa are partly in the fifth. 7 and 8 might be Tucson - Yuma and Tucson - Cochise, in classic Canadian emdash style.


Title: Re: Naming American Constituencies
Post by: nclib on August 03, 2009, 07:43:31 PM
NC-1: northern Coastal Plain
NC-2: Raleigh south and east
NC-3: southern Coastal Plain and Outer Banks
NC-4: Research Triangle
NC-5: Winston-Salem and northwest NC
NC-6: outer Greensboro
NC-7: Fayetteville-Wilmington
NC-8: Charlotte and south central NC
NC-9: Charlotte-Gastonia
NC-10: Foothills
NC-11: Mountain West
NC-12: Charlotte and I-85 corridor
NC-13: Greensboro-Raleigh


Title: Re: Naming American Constituencies
Post by: Verily on August 03, 2009, 08:44:33 PM
NJ 1 - Camden
NJ 2 - Atlantic City and Vineland
NJ 3 - Willingboro, Mount Holly and Toms River
NJ 4 - Trenton East, Freehold and Point Pleasant
NJ 5 - Piedmont
NJ 6 - New Brunswick and Long Branch
NJ 7 - Scotch Plains and something? (I don't know.)
NJ 8 - Paterson
NJ 9 - Hackensack
NJ 10 - Newark
NJ 11 - Morristown
NJ 12 - Trenton West and the Brunswicks
NJ 13 - Jersey City


Title: Re: Naming American Constituencies
Post by: The Illinoisian on August 05, 2009, 01:16:35 AM
The Voting Rights Act districts should be fun. Negroes of Maryland perhaps...

The Earmuffs Empire of Chicago.

IL-17 is a fun one, too.

I'll say.  I guess, Moline-Decatur-Springfield


Title: Re: Naming American Constituencies
Post by: Joe Republic on August 05, 2009, 01:19:34 AM
NC-12 = 'Piedmont Piss-Streak'


Title: Re: Naming American Constituencies
Post by: muon2 on August 05, 2009, 06:53:27 AM
The Voting Rights Act districts should be fun. Negroes of Maryland perhaps...

The Earmuffs Empire of Chicago.

IL-17 is a fun one, too.

I'll say.  I guess, Moline-Decatur-Springfield

The trick is that there isn't more than about a third of Springfield in the district, primarily on the northeast side. The part of the district on the west side and downtown is one block wide. The rest of Springfield is split between CD's 18 and 19 on either side of that thin line of CD 17.


Title: Re: Naming American Constituencies
Post by: The Illinoisian on August 05, 2009, 10:51:05 AM
The Voting Rights Act districts should be fun. Negroes of Maryland perhaps...

The Earmuffs Empire of Chicago.

IL-17 is a fun one, too.

I'll say.  I guess, Moline-Decatur-Springfield

The trick is that there isn't more than about a third of Springfield in the district, primarily on the northeast side. The part of the district on the west side and downtown is one block wide. The rest of Springfield is split between CD's 18 and 19 on either side of that thin line of CD 17.

Yeah, I remember when I was an intern for Shimkus they had a blown up map of Springfield, that way they could know for sure if the person calling was from the 19th.  Litterally at one point, on the south side of a street was the 19th, the street was the 17th, and the northside was the 18th.


Title: Re: Naming American Constituencies
Post by: The Illinoisian on August 05, 2009, 12:25:25 PM
Illinois-
IL-1- Nearer Eastern Chicago
IL-2- Further Eastern Chicago
IL-3- South Chicago
IL-4- Chicago Centro
IL-5- Chicago Northlake
IL-6- Northeast Chicago Exurbs
IL-7- Northern Chicago
IL-8- Northern Chicago Exurbs
IL-9- Northen Chicaho Suburbs
IL-10- North Chicago
IL-11- Bloomington-Normal
IL-12- East St. Louis
IL-13- Southwestern Chicago
IL-14- Aurora
IL-15- Champaign
IL-16- Rockford
IL-17- Quad Cities
IL-18- Springfeild
IL-19- Mount Vernon

I'd make a few changes to your list for IL:

IL-1- Nearer Eastern Chicago (Chicago South Side): This is really the heart of the south side going into South Cook. It would be confusing to put any compass direction in front of "Chicago" since there are suburbs that use that form.

IL-2- Further Eastern Chicago (Chicago South Shore): East Chicago is in IN, so it's confusing here. The lake is an easy reference and the district even includes a neighborhood known as South Shore.

IL-3- South Chicago (Chicago Midway): The Chicago parts of this district are never called south, but they are called southwest. Midway airport is centrally located and is a frequent reference name for the neighborhoods in that area, though if you used Chicago-Southwest Cook I wouldn't complain.

IL-4- Chicago Centro (Chicago Logan Square-Cicero): Your name is cute, but it isn't really the center which is in CD-7. Logan Square is the dominant neighborhood in the northern piece and Cicero (10th largest in IL) is the largest non-Chicago community on the south piece of the district, though you could just as easily use the neighborhood name and call it Chicago Logan Square - Little Village.

IL-5- Chicago Northlake (Chicago North Side): Northlake isn't that big, and not much of the district is outside the city. There's a lot of separate neighborhood names I might choose from, but north side says it pretty well.

IL-6- Northeast Chicago Exurbs (DuPage): The suburbs here aren't in the northeast, if anything they include a large part of what are called the northwest and west suburbs. These are also not exurbs - those are currently in CDs 11, 14 and 16 a good 20 miles farther out than CD 6. DuPage County dominates the district and is a pretty clear choice for this district unless you want to use Wheaton which is the county seat and largest city in the district.

IL-7- Northern Chicago (Chicago West Side): There's nothing northern about this district. I could use the dominant neighborhood and call it Chicago Austin (over 100 K residents), but west side is pretty clear.

IL-8- Northern Chicago Exurbs (Schaumburg): The McHenry and far northern Lake parts of the district are exurban, but a lot of the population is in northwest Cook County. Schaumburg anchors NW Cook, is the 16th largest community in IL, and is the 2nd largest job center in the state after the Loop.

IL-9- Northen Chicaho Suburbs (Evanston): Northern Chicago Suburbs suggests parts of CD 8 and 10 to the locals here. Evanston or Evanston-North Cook would describe this better.

IL-10- North Chicago (Waukegan-Arlington Heights) Waukegan (9th largest in IL) and Arlington Heights (14th largest) are both much more significant communities than North Chicago and they nicely anchor ends of the district.

IL-11- Bloomington-Normal (Joliet): B-N is at the end of a gerrymander and is not that significant to the district. This is the Will County seat and Joliet is the 4th largest city in the state.

IL-12- East St. Louis: Not a bad choice, but if a hyphen was used East St. Louis-Carbondale would give a better sense of the scope of the district.

IL-13- Southwestern Chicago (Naperville): Naperville is the fifth largest city in the state and dominates the district with almost a quarter of the population.

IL-14- Aurora (Aurora-Elgin): Elgin (8th largest in IL) is almost as significant of a community as Aurora in the district, especially since the DuPage part of Aurora is in IL 13. If you had to go with one, Aurora is the right choice.

IL-15- Champaign: Good choice

IL-16- Rockford: Good choice

IL-17- Quad Cities: Good choice

IL-18- Springfeild (Peoria): Springfield is fairly evenly split between IL-18 and 19 with a block-wide slice of IL-17 down the middle. Peoria is the dominant city in the district.

IL-19- Mount Vernon (Southern Illinois): There's no dominant community in this district, and a big chunk of the population is in the Metro East suburbs of St. Louis. I'd go with the generic name.


Good choices, though for 12 I would say Belleville is a better choice then ESL, as it is the dominiate community in St. Clair County.  So maybe, Alton-Belleville-Carbondale?


Title: Re: Naming American Constituencies
Post by: muon2 on August 05, 2009, 04:11:52 PM
Illinois-
IL-1- Nearer Eastern Chicago
IL-2- Further Eastern Chicago
IL-3- South Chicago
IL-4- Chicago Centro
IL-5- Chicago Northlake
IL-6- Northeast Chicago Exurbs
IL-7- Northern Chicago
IL-8- Northern Chicago Exurbs
IL-9- Northen Chicaho Suburbs
IL-10- North Chicago
IL-11- Bloomington-Normal
IL-12- East St. Louis
IL-13- Southwestern Chicago
IL-14- Aurora
IL-15- Champaign
IL-16- Rockford
IL-17- Quad Cities
IL-18- Springfeild
IL-19- Mount Vernon

I'd make a few changes to your list for IL:

IL-1- Nearer Eastern Chicago (Chicago South Side): This is really the heart of the south side going into South Cook. It would be confusing to put any compass direction in front of "Chicago" since there are suburbs that use that form.

IL-2- Further Eastern Chicago (Chicago South Shore): East Chicago is in IN, so it's confusing here. The lake is an easy reference and the district even includes a neighborhood known as South Shore.

IL-3- South Chicago (Chicago Midway): The Chicago parts of this district are never called south, but they are called southwest. Midway airport is centrally located and is a frequent reference name for the neighborhoods in that area, though if you used Chicago-Southwest Cook I wouldn't complain.

IL-4- Chicago Centro (Chicago Logan Square-Cicero): Your name is cute, but it isn't really the center which is in CD-7. Logan Square is the dominant neighborhood in the northern piece and Cicero (10th largest in IL) is the largest non-Chicago community on the south piece of the district, though you could just as easily use the neighborhood name and call it Chicago Logan Square - Little Village.

IL-5- Chicago Northlake (Chicago North Side): Northlake isn't that big, and not much of the district is outside the city. There's a lot of separate neighborhood names I might choose from, but north side says it pretty well.

IL-6- Northeast Chicago Exurbs (DuPage): The suburbs here aren't in the northeast, if anything they include a large part of what are called the northwest and west suburbs. These are also not exurbs - those are currently in CDs 11, 14 and 16 a good 20 miles farther out than CD 6. DuPage County dominates the district and is a pretty clear choice for this district unless you want to use Wheaton which is the county seat and largest city in the district.

IL-7- Northern Chicago (Chicago West Side): There's nothing northern about this district. I could use the dominant neighborhood and call it Chicago Austin (over 100 K residents), but west side is pretty clear.

IL-8- Northern Chicago Exurbs (Schaumburg): The McHenry and far northern Lake parts of the district are exurban, but a lot of the population is in northwest Cook County. Schaumburg anchors NW Cook, is the 16th largest community in IL, and is the 2nd largest job center in the state after the Loop.

IL-9- Northen Chicaho Suburbs (Evanston): Northern Chicago Suburbs suggests parts of CD 8 and 10 to the locals here. Evanston or Evanston-North Cook would describe this better.

IL-10- North Chicago (Waukegan-Arlington Heights) Waukegan (9th largest in IL) and Arlington Heights (14th largest) are both much more significant communities than North Chicago and they nicely anchor ends of the district.

IL-11- Bloomington-Normal (Joliet): B-N is at the end of a gerrymander and is not that significant to the district. This is the Will County seat and Joliet is the 4th largest city in the state.

IL-12- East St. Louis: Not a bad choice, but if a hyphen was used East St. Louis-Carbondale would give a better sense of the scope of the district.

IL-13- Southwestern Chicago (Naperville): Naperville is the fifth largest city in the state and dominates the district with almost a quarter of the population.

IL-14- Aurora (Aurora-Elgin): Elgin (8th largest in IL) is almost as significant of a community as Aurora in the district, especially since the DuPage part of Aurora is in IL 13. If you had to go with one, Aurora is the right choice.

IL-15- Champaign: Good choice

IL-16- Rockford: Good choice

IL-17- Quad Cities: Good choice

IL-18- Springfeild (Peoria): Springfield is fairly evenly split between IL-18 and 19 with a block-wide slice of IL-17 down the middle. Peoria is the dominant city in the district.

IL-19- Mount Vernon (Southern Illinois): There's no dominant community in this district, and a big chunk of the population is in the Metro East suburbs of St. Louis. I'd go with the generic name.


Good choices, though for 12 I would say Belleville is a better choice then ESL, as it is the dominiate community in St. Clair County.  So maybe, Alton-Belleville-Carbondale?

I agree that Belleville is better than ESL, but Alton and ESL are about the same size, so I'd just go with one town from Metro East. Thus, Belleville-Carbondale.


Title: Re: Naming American Constituencies
Post by: Hillary 2016 on August 08, 2009, 02:58:02 AM
Here's mine for PA:

1. Chester-South Philadelphia (D)
2. North Philadelphia (D)
3. Erie (D)
4. West Pennsylvania (D)
5. North Central Pennsylvania (R)
6. Berks-Chester-Montgomery (R)
7. Delaware (D)
8. Bucks (D)
9. South Central Pennsylvania (R)
10. Northeast Pennsylvania (D)
11. Coal Country (D)
12. Gerrymandered Piece of BS (D)
13. Montgomery (D)
14. Pittsburgh (D)
15. Lehigh Valley (D)
16. Amish Country (R)
17. Chocolateland (R)
18. Republican Gerrymandered Piece of BS (R)
19. York (R)

And this would not work in the good old USA.  Too much gerrymandering, not enough regional identification - although if I lived in PA-17, I'd sure remember my district(-:


Title: Re: Naming American Constituencies
Post by: RI on August 08, 2009, 02:29:15 PM
My try at Washington.

WA-01: Shoreline-Kirkland-Kitsap North (I'm sure someone can come up with a better name...)
WA-02: Everett-Bellingham-Islands
WA-03: Olympia-Vancouver
WA-04: Yakima-Wenatchee-Tri-Cities
WA-05: Washington East
WA-06: Tacoma-Olympic Peninsula
WA-07: Seattle-Vashon
WA-08: Eastside
WA-09: Puget Sound South


Title: Re: Naming American Constituencies
Post by: bgwah on August 08, 2009, 05:26:06 PM
WA-01: Northside
WA-02: Northwestern Washington
WA-03: Southwestern Washington
WA-04: Central Washington
WA-05: Eastern Washington
WA-06: Tacoma-Olympic Peninsula (I hate this district's borders)
WA-07: Seattle
WA-08: Eastside
WA-09: Southside