Make a map of the above four posters as separate candidates

[RFayette 🇻🇦]

MormDem and Enderman act as spoilers, with the race going to Congress
Antonio (D) - 251
Goldwater (R) - 252
MormDem(I) - 6
Enderman (C) - 29

[RFayette 🇻🇦]

MormDem/Tim Kaine (D) - 324
Superman/Marco Rubio(R) - 120
Leinad/Rand Paul(L) - 36
Thomas/Mike Huckabee (C) - 58


In a fractured 2016 race, moderate, establishment conservative Superman causes a fracture within the party, leading to the libertarian Leinad and socon Thomas from NJ running 3rd party, allowing an easy win by MormDem the Democrat, whose social conservatism went largely unnoticed due to Thomas's presence.  

[RFayette 🇻🇦]

Leinad (R-GA)/Rand Paul - 283
Evergreen (I)/Russ Feingold - 21
darthebearnc (Socialist)/Kay Hagan - 15
NeverAgain (D-VA)/Al Franken - 219

With a split Democratic field, libertarian-turned Republican Leinad glides to a relatively easy victory.  Evergreen carries Wisconsin, New Hampshire, and Vermont thanks to Russ Feingold's campaigning with Bernie Sanders on behalf of the campaign (Leinad toned down his libertarianism to help win Southern states).  Darthebear could not gain appeal beyond North Carolina, but he also siphoned votes from NeverAgain, helping Leinad win despite his numerous vulnerabilities (flip-flopping, most notably).