Opinion of Amish romance fiction

[memphis]

You have your panties in a wad because the setting in a romance novel isn't portrayed accurately? I've never read a romance novel, but they probably don't get the facts about the lives of cowboys, firemen, or lumberjacks right either. It's just erotica for bored American women of a certain age. There's no need to "deconstruct" it.

[memphis]

All you're doing is digging desperately for a story in which religious people in America are somehow the victims because that, in turn, makes you feel noble for exposing some trifling little concern. It isn't as if the novels are accusing them of poisoning wells. In a country where people are suffering under the weight of unemployment, cancer, and all the rest of the humanity's plagues, you're sounding the alarm because the details of Amish people's theology and worship style are not accurately presented in romance novels? By all means, cry wolf on that account.

[memphis]

Ad hominem attacks are always the foundation of a winning debate strategy. Well played, sir