a) Flaherty/Elliott were/are socially liberal red Tories, so Elliott was going to be a non-starter with a large minority of the party.
Actually, Flaherty was more the right-populist standard-bearer in his runs for the leadership vs Eves and Tory--it's only Elliott that's positioned herself as a "mainstream" Davis heir.
I never heard that before. Interesting. Mea culpa.
Also, Flaherty took socially conservative positions on abortion and gay marriage.
Flaherty was raised as a Catholic, and after marriage joined the Anglican church where Elliott went, but he seems to have retained the basic Catholic position on these issues.