Yeah bgwah and I were discussing this county in IRC. It's apparent the numbers are wrong. Compare 2008 votes to 2012:
379 McCain
146 Obama
25 Ron Paul
421 Romney
98 Johnson
25 Obama
Note that Obama got EXACTLY the same number of votes that Ron Paul did when he was on the ballot in 2008! The numbers make so much more since if Johnson and Obama are switched. Random results are one thing, but Johnson didn't even break 5% in any other county in the state.
Should've guessed. Wasn't there something similar in ND or something last time around?