Hmm, idk. Despite co-existing on this forum during both my prior incarnation and my present existence, I've never really interacted with Memphis nor paid much attention to his posts. All I know is his avatar is D-TN. If he is somehow pro-rape as implied then he definitely would not get my vote as I detest the rape culture that is pervasive in the U.S.
Maddalena, I have mixed feelings about. Back in the summer during my first request to be unbanned I was intrigued by different religions besides my Catholic upbringing, in particular LGBTQ-affirming religions, I was told to ask the poster then known as Nathan about such religions, so I PMed him and asked him some questions about religion hoping for a thought-provoking discussion, he said he was busy but would get back to me with answers but never did even though I was in limbo on the forum for like 3 months before the mods at the time rejected my unban request.
And so I remain a religion-hating atheist.
Also she has the whole asexual 'sex-negative' thing, which I respect though personally disagree with. But because I mentioned my orgy parties and told a dating story that included some sex scenes and complained about prudes she seemed to have included I was sex crazy when this is hardly the case, while I am 'sex-positive', I really do believe in sex only as part of a loving relationship would truly make me happy. I could easily go without sex as long as I just had a loving partner to cuddle with.
But besides my personal interactions with her, I've read many of her posts and they are most insightful and bring a unique perspective to things, even in cases where I disagree with her.
So my vote goes to Madeleine.