AZ a non-toss up toss up (user search)
       |           

Welcome, Guest. Please login or register.
Did you miss your activation email?
June 13, 2024, 12:54:22 AM
News: Election Simulator 2.0 Released. Senate/Gubernatorial maps, proportional electoral votes, and more - Read more

  Talk Elections
  Election Archive
  Election Archive
  2004 U.S. Presidential Election
  2004 U.S. Presidential Election Polls
  AZ a non-toss up toss up (search mode)
Pages: [1]
Author Topic: AZ a non-toss up toss up  (Read 4743 times)
millwx
Jr. Member
***
Posts: 402


« on: June 20, 2004, 06:42:41 AM »

A new Arizona poll (June 10th-13th, 600 LV, by Market Solutions Group) shows Bush 44%, Kerry 41%, Nader 2%, Other 2%, and undecided 11%.

I think it's safe to presume that AZ is at least "Lean Bush" since every poll shows him ahead.  But the last two have him up by only 3%, and this latest one was conducted during the Reaganathon.

By most people's standards (5% lead), it looks like AZ is a toss-up.  It's to GW Bush as Washington is to Kerry (all the polls have Kerry ahead in Washington, so he almost certainly is; but they're also all close enough so that the 5% "rule" makes it a toss-up).
Logged
millwx
Jr. Member
***
Posts: 402


« Reply #1 on: June 20, 2004, 07:41:14 AM »
« Edited: June 20, 2004, 07:45:15 AM by millwx »

Most polls are showing AZ less strongly Bush than in 2000 but still highly likley to go for "W" in November.
Yes, they do all show Bush winning there... as I said.  But I'm not sure what "most polls" you're talking about.  Since April only one poll (out of about 5) shows him with greater than a 5% lead... and that was in a 3-way matchup; in that same poll Bush was only up 4% head-to-head (though the 3-way may be more correct, since Nader has gained ballot access in AZ).  Well respected Public Opinion Strategies, in fact, also showed it only a 3% Bush lead in AZ.

Anyway, yes, I have no doubt that AZ will go to Bush.  But, I just find these non-tossup tossups to be interesting.  There are a lot of states grouped into the "tossup" category that are consistently polling in favor of one candidate.  Check out the list, using the tossup criteria here on the Atlas:

Washington: 6 polls, 6-of-6 for Kerry.  A non-tossup tossup.
Oregon: 6 polls, 3 Kerry, 2 Bush, 1 tie.  A true tossup!
New Mexico: 2 polls, 1 Kerry, 1 Bush.  A true tossup!
Minnesota: 5 polls, 5-of-5 for Kerry.  A non-tossup tossup.
Iowa: 7 polls, 6-of-7 for Kerry.  A non-tossup tossup.
Wisconsin: 6 polls, 4 Kerry, 2 Bush.  Borderline tossup.
Michigan: 9 polls, 8 Kerry, 1 Bush.  A non-tossup tossup.
Ohio: 7 polls, 3 Kerry, 4 Bush.  A true tossup!
West Virginia: 6 polls, 2 Kerry, 3 Bush, 1 tie.  A true tossup!
Pennsylvania: 8 polls, 6 Kerry, 2 Bush.  A non-tossup tossup.
New Hampshire: 5 polls, 2 Kerry, 1 Bush, 2 ties.  A true tossup!
Florida: 7 polls, 3 Kerry, 4 Bush.  A true tossup!

Depending on Dave's formula, Arizona *MIGHT* now get tossed into the tossup pool.  If so, it would be...
Arizona: 4 polls, 4 Bush.  A non-tossup tossup.

So... my point is, of the 12 "tossups" (not including AZ) almost half of them (5) look like solid "leaners".  If AZ now gets ruled a tossup, it's 6 of 13 that are solid "leaners".  So, we've really only got about 7 true tossups, and given some of the nuances, we might not even have that.  For example, Bush has been +5% and +7% in FL the last two polls... it may be truly "leaning" Bush.  On the flip side, the one poll in NH that Bush led was the oldest; the most recent 4 have been ties or Kerry leads... it's clearly VERY close there, but it may be truly "leaning" Kerry.  Similarly, Bush has led in 4 of the last 5 Ohio polls, with that 5th being the dreaded LA Times poll... so, OH may be "lean" Bush.

Sure, of course all of these "slight leans" are still in play.  The leader clearly only has, at best, a 3-5% lead... something easily surmountable by the trailing candidate if the news breaks his way and/or if he focuses his campaign on the state(s).  But, as it stands, I see only four truly undecided tossup states... Oregon, Wisconsin, West Virginia and New Mexico. .. and even Wisconsin is debatable as Bush led in only the two least reliable polls while Kerry led in the rest.

Oh, and incidentally, the two non-tossup tossups that Bush takes (FL and OH) would give him 269 EVs.  So, Kerry needs to pray for that heavy undecided break in his favor which seems so questionable, or he'd better do something.  A tie goes to the incumbent, given the makeup of the House.  Lucky for Kerry, he's got 4+ months and can also hope that some of Bush's poll numbers reflect the Reagan effect.  Otherwise, as things stand now, he's toast.  If he takes all of his non-tossup tossups PLUS all of the true tossups (WV, OR, WI and NM), he'll tie Bush at 269 EVs.
Logged
millwx
Jr. Member
***
Posts: 402


« Reply #2 on: June 20, 2004, 09:00:18 AM »

The Vorlon... got it off of Polling Report subscription section.  So, I don't really have a link.  However, it was done for the Arizona Republic.  I went to their web site...
http://www.azcentral.com/arizonarepublic/
...the story is on their front page (second story down) but, oddly, the link doesn't work.

...uh, just tried it again, it worked...
http://www.azcentral.com/arizonarepublic/news/articles/0620azpoll20.html
Logged
millwx
Jr. Member
***
Posts: 402


« Reply #3 on: June 20, 2004, 03:01:46 PM »

The recent Arizona PUBLIC polls have been seriously defective.

Arizona is solidy Bush.

Bush has a better chance of carrying California than Kerry does of carrying Arizona.

The poll cited is so defective it makes the recent LA Times poll look good.
Sorry Carl,

The Public Opinion Strategies poll, which is largely agreed to NOT be defective showed the same thing, a 3% Bush lead.  I don't disagree AT ALL with your notion that Bush will go to AZ.  But all this talk (not just by you) that Bush has a better chance of taking CA than Kerry has of taking AZ is just plain silly.  AZ is close, period.  Your accusation of the latest polls is not only unfounded, but not supported by the best "analyst" here...

http://www.uselectionatlas.org/USPRESIDENT/GENERAL/CAMPAIGN/2004/polls.php?action=indpoll&id=4200406080
Logged
millwx
Jr. Member
***
Posts: 402


« Reply #4 on: June 20, 2004, 04:10:42 PM »

Bush won Arizona by 6.62% in 2000, and the Demographics are slowly sliding the Democrat's way in that state.

The result is not "crazy" but other than that, I don't have enough information to comment specifically on this poll.

GOP "base" is pretty complacent in that state, so the small lead number among "likely" voters reflects that.

Bush +2 to 4% - matches my map Smiley so I thinks it's "ok"

Arizona to Bush is like Minnesota to Kerry.
Vorlon... thank you for the unbiased Wink assessment.
Logged
millwx
Jr. Member
***
Posts: 402


« Reply #5 on: June 20, 2004, 06:36:21 PM »

There is none.  For the last three months...

ASU (4/23-26) showed Bush 41%, Kerry 38%
BRC (4/29-5/4) had Bush 45%, Kerry 37%
KAET/ASU (5/20-5/23) had Bush 43%, Kerry 38%
POS (6/8) had Bush 48%, Kerry 45%
Market Solutions (6/10-6/13) had Bush 44%, Kerry 41%

The pro-Bushers will claim bias in the ASU polls... not an entirely unfounded accusation, but not a certain conclusion either.  Then they'll hang their hats on the BRC/Rocky Mountain poll... ignoring its large Nader factor (head-to-head it was much closer).  As for POS and Market Solutions?  I've heard one pro-Busher argue that the POS polls were all biased towards Kerry to try to invigorate the Republicans.  Give me a HUGE break.  Must be that vast right wing conspiracy!  Cheesy  Please.  And now that Market Solutions agrees?  Oh, well, no one is familiar with Market Solutions, so it must be biased too.  Sheesh, enough already!  Not only is there no "proof" that Bush is solid in AZ, there's not a single piece of evidence.  On top of that, folks here are really arguing over nuances anyway.  No one (you may think otherwise, I don't know) has stated any belief that Kerry will take Arizona.  Last I checked, Arizona doesn't partition their EVs.  So, whether Bush wins it by 1% or 12% is irrelevant.  The only relevance any of this has is strategy... if it's close, Bush will need to spend money in AZ to secure his victory.  And I'm sure Bush's team will believe these polls before believing some vague perception that he's "solid" in AZ... the average of these polls is 4.4%, and the single most reliable one (POS) has 3%.  So, Bush will, and probably already is, spending money in AZ.
Logged
Pages: [1]  
Jump to:  


Login with username, password and session length

Terms of Service - DMCA Agent and Policy - Privacy Policy and Cookies

Powered by SMF 1.1.21 | SMF © 2015, Simple Machines

Page created in 0.037 seconds with 15 queries.