Of all the re-match elections, this is your pick? 1832, 1900, 1944, 1940, 1956, and 1984 are all worse/ more boring.
1832 had Henry Clay losing, something that never gets old. If you mean 1828, where-in Jackson came back to beat Adams after the election four years earlier, that was pretty epic. 1900 is a McKinley victory, which is never boring. 1940 saw the British sabotage of an American political party's convention and its sequel took place with the backdrop of one of the most epic conquests of human history. 1956 and 1984 at least had good results, and the 1984 Dem primaries would've been pretty cool to see play out.