Which of these cities would you most want to live in?

[Horus]

Atlanta, of course.

[SWE]

Madison

[Clarko95 📚💰📈]

Chicago (Normal; sane; etc.)

[Antonio the Sixth]

Ugh, what are you people, snowmen? I feel cold just by looking at these poll's results.

What are you? A cactus?

I've been to Atlanta. It's not even that warm.

[Hash]

You Atlanta-loving people remind me of the people here wearing big winter coats because it's 15c in Manizales. Absolutely insane.

[Kushahontas]

Between the two, which is more walkable and better served by transit, Madison or Minneapolis? I'm thinking the latter.

[ilikeverin]

Not just a cactus, but a cactus who wants to be stuck in traffic for the rest of his life.

And not just a cactus stuck in traffic for the rest of his life, but a cactus stuck in traffic for the rest of his life with a scowl on his face. 

What?  I've found Atlanta to be very friendly!  I mean, it's no Upper Midwest, but nowhere else is

[Goldwater]

You Atlanta-loving people remind me of the people here wearing big winter coats because it's 15c in Manizales. Absolutely insane.

Maybe quite big winter coat weather, but I would consider 59F/15C jacket weather, especially if there is no sun. Really, my ideal temperature is something like 80sF/27-32C.

[Gass3268]

Between the two, which is more walkable and better served by transit, Madison or Minneapolis? I'm thinking the latter.

Minneapolis

Madison has tired a number of times to get light rail, but we usually get shutdown by the state or the suburbs (while they vote heavily Democrat in Federal and State elections, are very conservative in local elections).  

To answer the question:

Madison > Minneapolis > Chicago > Atlanta > Sioux Falls

[Badger]

Chicago > Madison > Minneapolis > Atlanta > Sioux Falls

And forgive my ignorance, but what is the common denominator here?

[Sol]

Chicago > Madison > Minneapolis > Atlanta > Sioux Falls

And forgive my ignorance, but what is the common denominator here?

Ingress.

[I spent the winter writing songs about getting better]

Chicago > Madison > Minneapolis > Atlanta > Sioux Falls

And forgive my ignorance, but what is the common denominator here?

Ingress.

Ding. I've gone to specific events in all these cities, or will in the case of Atlanta.

[MasterJedi]

Chicago, IL easily take the big city closest to Milwaukee. Madison is really just a big college town that thinks it's hot stuff but is really just provincial compared to Milwaukee.

[Del Tachi]

Atlanta, of course.