I myself was very surprised when the show was Uncanceled. Since it had been Screwed By The Network, the Channel Hop was great.
But the Continuity Reboot!
They changed the Amoral Attorney into a total Bishonen as Estrogen Brigade Bait. The first actor was better. They Dropped A Bridge on Uncle Chuck...You Should Know This Already, stop complaining about the spoiler. The show's caught a real case of Cerberus Syndrome, but while it's Darker and Edgier, it's also turned the entire series into an Author's Tract.
And what was with the Staff Chick going all One Winged Angel? That wasn't explained at all! They're at the battle of Wallbanger, and she grows 6 small wings and 1 large one while Ominous Latin Chanting starts. RUINED FOREVER? Discontinuity? Dethroning Moment of Suck?