Governors of New York survivor - Nelson Rockefeller survivor

[big bad fab]

George Clinton (D-R / 1777-1795, 1801-1804)
John Jay (F / 1795-1801)
Morgan Lewis (D-R / 1804-1807)
Daniel D. Tompkins (D-R / 1807-1817)
John Tayler (D-R / 1817)
DeWitt Clinton (D-R / 1817-1822, 1825-1828)
Joseph C. Yates (D-R / 1823-1824)
Nathaniel Pitcher (D-R / 1828)
Martin Van Buren (D / 1829)
Enos T. Throop (D / 1829-1832)
William L. Marcy (D / 1833-1838)
William H. Seward (W / 1839-1842)
William C. Bouck (D / 1843-1844)
Silas Wright (D / 1845-1846)
John Young (W / 1847-1848)
Hamilton Fish (W / 1849-1850)
Washington Hunt (W / 1851-1852)
Horatio Seymour (D / 1853-1854, 1863-1864)
Myron H. Clark (W / 1855-1856)
John Alsop King (R / 1857-1858)
Edwin D. Morgan (R / 1859-1862)
Reuben Fenton (R / 1865-1868)
John Thompson Hoffman (D / 1869-1872)
John Adams Dix (R / 1873-1874)
Samuel J. Tilden (D / 1875-1876)
Lucius Robinson (D / 1877-1879)
Alonzo B. Cornell (R / 1880-1882)
Grover Cleveland (D / 1883-1885)
David B. Hill (D / 1885-1891)
Roswell P. Flower (D / 1892-1894)
Levi P. Morton (R / 1895-1896)
Frank S. Black (R / 1897-1898)
Theodore Roosevelt (R / 1899-1900)
Benjamin Barker Odell Jr (R / 1901-1904)
Frank W. Higgins (R / 1905-1906)
Charles Evans Hughes (R / 1907-1910)
Horace White (R / 1910)
John Alden Dix (D / 1911-1912)
William Sulzer (D / 1913)
Martin H. Glynn (D / 1913-1914)
Charles S. Whitman (R / 1915-1918)
Al Smith (D / 1919-1920, 1923-1928)
Nathan Lewis Miller (R / 1921-1922)
Franklin D. Roosevelt (D / 1929-1932)
Herbert H. Lehman (D / 1933-1942)
Charles Poletti (D / 1942)
Thomas Dewey (R / 1943-1954)
W. Averell Harriman (D / 1955-1958)
Nelson Rockefeller (R / 1959-1973)
Malcolm Wilson (R / 1973-1974)
Hugh Carey (D / 1975-1982)
Mario Cuomo (D / 1983-1994)
George Pataki (R / 1995-2006)
Eliot Spitzer (D / 2007-2008)
David Paterson (D / 2008-2010)
Andrew Cuomo (D / 2011-…)

Rules:
Each round will last 24 hours + (the first will be a bit longer).
You can change your vote only if nobody has voted after you: editing your post may so make your vote invalid.
For 13 rounds, we'll eliminate Governors 3 by 3.
Then, for 6 rounds, we'll eliminate Governors 2 by 2.
Then, for the last 5 rounds, we'll eliminate Governors 1 by 1.
In case of a tie, previous points will first be taken into account, with the Governor having received the biggest total being eliminated. In case of a new tie, I'll decide which one is eliminated.

Please try to vote considering the governorship of each of them and not their national career: that'll be funnier !
The Governors of California and the Governors of Massachussetts survivors were fine and this one should be equally mostly unbiased.

Enjoy !

ROUND 1 IS OPEN !
In this round, you have 10 points to eliminate, to cast 4-3-2-1, and 3 points to keep, to cast 1-1-1.

[The Artist Formerly Known As and Now Again Known As Ogis]

Eliminate:

DeWitt Clinton 4
George Clinton 3
Van Buren 2
Seymour 1

Save
John Jay 1
Grover Cleveland 1
FDR 1

[homelycooking]

Eliminate

4 George Clinton
3 William Sulzer
2 Reuben Fenton
1 Horatio Seymour

Keep

John Jay
DeWitt Clinton
Martin Van Buren

[Senator Napoleon]

Eliminate

4- William L. Marcy
3- Alonzo B. Cornell
2- Morgan Lewis
1- John Alden Dix

Keep

1- Hugh Carey
1- Al Smith
1- Samuel J. Tilden

[Vazdul (Formerly Chairman of the Communist Party of Ontario)]

Eliminate:
4 for Sulzer
3 for John Alden Dix
2 for Lewis
1 for Fenton

Keep:
Jay
DeWitt Clinton
Van Buren

[big bad fab]

Wow ! I was about to vote for small ones first, like Tayler or Poletti or Horace White. And to give points to Glynn and Hoffmann, but I need to help save Van Buren and try to save G. Clinton: whatever we think of them, I think its a bit too early.
A very interesting beginning, anyway

Eliminate:
4 William Marcy
3 John Alden Dix
2 Martin Glynn
1 William Sulzer

Keep:
1 Martin Van Buren
1 George Clinton
1 Morgan Lewis

(I don't want especially to see these 3 go very far in this survivor: just a tactical vote here)

[Edu]

4 for William Sulzer
3 for John Alden Dix
2 for Horatio Seymour
1 for Morgan Lewis

Keep
George Clinton
Alonzo B. Cornell
William L. Marcy

[Hans-im-Glück]

Eliminate:

4  William Sulzer
3  John Tayler
2  Horace White
1  Nathaniel Pitcher

Keep:
George Clinton
John Jay
DeWitt Clinton

[big bad fab]

Unexpected events are numerous this week.
I'm forced to be in Paris the whole day this Saturday (CET), at the least.

So don't expect an update until Sunday or even Monday.

[big bad fab]

George Clinton (D-R / 1777-1795, 1801-1804)
John Jay (F / 1795-1801)
Morgan Lewis (D-R / 1804-1807)
Daniel D. Tompkins (D-R / 1807-1817)
John Tayler (D-R / 1817)
DeWitt Clinton (D-R / 1817-1822, 1825-1828)
Joseph C. Yates (D-R / 1823-1824)
Nathaniel Pitcher (D-R / 1828)
Martin Van Buren (D / 1829)
Enos T. Throop (D / 1829-1832)
William L. Marcy (D / 1833-1838)
William H. Seward (W / 1839-1842)
William C. Bouck (D / 1843-1844)
Silas Wright (D / 1845-1846)
John Young (W / 1847-1848)
Hamilton Fish (W / 1849-1850)
Washington Hunt (W / 1851-1852)
Horatio Seymour (D / 1853-1854, 1863-1864)
Myron H. Clark (W / 1855-1856)
John Alsop King (R / 1857-1858)
Edwin D. Morgan (R / 1859-1862)
Reuben Fenton (R / 1865-1868)
John Thompson Hoffman (D / 1869-1872)
John Adams Dix (R / 1873-1874)
Samuel J. Tilden (D / 1875-1876)
Lucius Robinson (D / 1877-1879)
Alonzo B. Cornell (R / 1880-1882)
Grover Cleveland (D / 1883-1885)
David B. Hill (D / 1885-1891)
Roswell P. Flower (D / 1892-1894)
Levi P. Morton (R / 1895-1896)
Frank S. Black (R / 1897-1898)
Theodore Roosevelt (R / 1899-1900)
Benjamin Barker Odell Jr (R / 1901-1904)
Frank W. Higgins (R / 1905-1906)
Charles Evans Hughes (R / 1907-1910)
Horace White (R / 1910)
John Alden Dix (D / 1911-1912)
William Sulzer (D / 1913)
Martin H. Glynn (D / 1913-1914)
Charles S. Whitman (R / 1915-1918)
Al Smith (D / 1919-1920, 1923-1928)
Nathan Lewis Miller (R / 1921-1922)
Franklin D. Roosevelt (D / 1929-1932)
Herbert H. Lehman (D / 1933-1942)
Charles Poletti (D / 1942)
Thomas Dewey (R / 1943-1954)
W. Averell Harriman (D / 1955-1958)
Nelson Rockefeller (R / 1959-1973)
Malcolm Wilson (R / 1973-1974)
Hugh Carey (D / 1975-1982)
Mario Cuomo (D / 1983-1994)
George Pataki (R / 1995-2006)
Eliot Spitzer (D / 2007-2008)
David Paterson (D / 2008-2010)
Andrew Cuomo (D / 2011-…)

Results:
Round 1: Sulzer 16, Alden Dix 10, Marcy 7, George Clinton 4, Lewis 4, Seymour 4, Fenton 3, Tayler 3, Cornell 2, Glynn 2, White 2, DeWitt Clinton 1, Pitcher 1, Carey -1, Cleveland -1, F.D. Roosevelt -1, Tilden -1, Smith -1, Van Buren -1, Jay -4


ROUND 2 IS OPEN !
In this round, you have 10 points to eliminate, to cast 5-2-2-1, and 3 points to keep, to cast 2-1.

[big bad fab]

Eliminate
5 Tayler
2 White
2 Glynn
1 Hoffmann

Keep
2 Van Buren
1 George Clinton

[homelycooking]

Eliminate

5 Fenton
2 Tayler
2 G. Clinton
1 Higgins

Keep

2 D. Clinton
1 Van Buren
1

[big bad fab]

Eliminate

5 Sulzer

Sulzer is already out, homelycooking: you can edit your vote (you can even change the number of points for those for whom you've already voted, of course).

[Vazdul (Formerly Chairman of the Communist Party of Ontario)]

Eliminate:
5 for Lewis
2 for Fenton
2 for White
1 for Poletti

Keep:
2 for Van Buren
1 for George Clinton

[Hans-im-Glück]

Eliminate:
 
5  John Tayler
2  Horace White
2  Nathaniel Pitcher
1  Charles Poletti

Keep:
2  George Clinton
1  DeWitt Clinton

[big bad fab]

George Clinton (D-R / 1777-1795, 1801-1804)
John Jay (F / 1795-1801)
Morgan Lewis (D-R / 1804-1807)
Daniel D. Tompkins (D-R / 1807-1817)
John Tayler (D-R / 1817)
DeWitt Clinton (D-R / 1817-1822, 1825-1828)
Joseph C. Yates (D-R / 1823-1824)
Nathaniel Pitcher (D-R / 1828)
Martin Van Buren (D / 1829)
Enos T. Throop (D / 1829-1832)
William L. Marcy (D / 1833-1838)
William H. Seward (W / 1839-1842)
William C. Bouck (D / 1843-1844)
Silas Wright (D / 1845-1846)
John Young (W / 1847-1848)
Hamilton Fish (W / 1849-1850)
Washington Hunt (W / 1851-1852)
Horatio Seymour (D / 1853-1854, 1863-1864)
Myron H. Clark (W / 1855-1856)
John Alsop King (R / 1857-1858)
Edwin D. Morgan (R / 1859-1862)
Reuben Fenton (R / 1865-1868)
John Thompson Hoffman (D / 1869-1872)
John Adams Dix (R / 1873-1874)
Samuel J. Tilden (D / 1875-1876)
Lucius Robinson (D / 1877-1879)
Alonzo B. Cornell (R / 1880-1882)
Grover Cleveland (D / 1883-1885)
David B. Hill (D / 1885-1891)
Roswell P. Flower (D / 1892-1894)
Levi P. Morton (R / 1895-1896)
Frank S. Black (R / 1897-1898)
Theodore Roosevelt (R / 1899-1900)
Benjamin Barker Odell Jr (R / 1901-1904)
Frank W. Higgins (R / 1905-1906)
Charles Evans Hughes (R / 1907-1910)
Horace White (R / 1910)
John Alden Dix (D / 1911-1912)
William Sulzer (D / 1913)
Martin H. Glynn (D / 1913-1914)
Charles S. Whitman (R / 1915-1918)
Al Smith (D / 1919-1920, 1923-1928)
Nathan Lewis Miller (R / 1921-1922)
Franklin D. Roosevelt (D / 1929-1932)
Herbert H. Lehman (D / 1933-1942)
Charles Poletti (D / 1942)
Thomas Dewey (R / 1943-1954)
W. Averell Harriman (D / 1955-1958)
Nelson Rockefeller (R / 1959-1973)
Malcolm Wilson (R / 1973-1974)
Hugh Carey (D / 1975-1982)
Mario Cuomo (D / 1983-1994)
George Pataki (R / 1995-2006)
Eliot Spitzer (D / 2007-2008)
David Paterson (D / 2008-2010)
Andrew Cuomo (D / 2011-…)

Results:
Round 1: Sulzer 16, Alden Dix 10, Marcy 7, George Clinton 4, Lewis 4, Seymour 4, Fenton 3, Tayler 3, Cornell 2, Glynn 2, White 2, DeWitt Clinton 1, Pitcher 1, Carey -1, Cleveland -1, F.D. Roosevelt -1, Tilden -1, Smith -1, Van Buren -1, Jay -4
Round 2: Tayler 12, Fenton 7, White 6, Lewis 5, Glynn 2, Pitcher 2, Poletti 2, Higgins 1, Hoffmann 1, George Clinton -2, DeWitt Clinton -3, Van Buren -5


ROUND 3 IS OPEN !
In this round, you have 10 points to eliminate, to cast 3-3-3-1, and 3 points to keep, to cast 1-1-1.

[big bad fab]

Eliminate
3 Glynn
3 Poletti
3 Hoffmann
1 Pitcher

Keep
1 G. Clinton
1 Van Buren
1 Seymour

[homelycooking]

Eliminate

3 Poletti
3 Higgins
3 Clark
1 Pitcher

Keep

1 Seymour
1 Van Buren
1 Tompkins

[Hans-im-Glück]

Eliminate:
3  Nathaniel Pitcher
3  Charles Poletti
3  Frank W. Higgins
1  Nathan Lewis Miller

Keep:
1  Myron H. Clark
1  John Thompson Hoffman
1  DeWitt Clinton

[Vazdul (Formerly Chairman of the Communist Party of Ontario)]

Eliminate:
3 for Lewis
3 for Poletti
3 for Glynn
1 for Van Buren

Keep:
1 for Seymour
1 for George Clinton
1 for DeWitt Clinton

[big bad fab]

George Clinton (D-R / 1777-1795, 1801-1804)
John Jay (F / 1795-1801)
Morgan Lewis (D-R / 1804-1807)
Daniel D. Tompkins (D-R / 1807-1817)
John Tayler (D-R / 1817)
DeWitt Clinton (D-R / 1817-1822, 1825-1828)
Joseph C. Yates (D-R / 1823-1824)
Nathaniel Pitcher (D-R / 1828)
Martin Van Buren (D / 1829)
Enos T. Throop (D / 1829-1832)
William L. Marcy (D / 1833-1838)
William H. Seward (W / 1839-1842)
William C. Bouck (D / 1843-1844)
Silas Wright (D / 1845-1846)
John Young (W / 1847-1848)
Hamilton Fish (W / 1849-1850)
Washington Hunt (W / 1851-1852)
Horatio Seymour (D / 1853-1854, 1863-1864)
Myron H. Clark (W / 1855-1856)
John Alsop King (R / 1857-1858)
Edwin D. Morgan (R / 1859-1862)
Reuben Fenton (R / 1865-1868)
John Thompson Hoffman (D / 1869-1872)
John Adams Dix (R / 1873-1874)
Samuel J. Tilden (D / 1875-1876)
Lucius Robinson (D / 1877-1879)
Alonzo B. Cornell (R / 1880-1882)
Grover Cleveland (D / 1883-1885)
David B. Hill (D / 1885-1891)
Roswell P. Flower (D / 1892-1894)
Levi P. Morton (R / 1895-1896)
Frank S. Black (R / 1897-1898)
Theodore Roosevelt (R / 1899-1900)
Benjamin Barker Odell Jr (R / 1901-1904)
Frank W. Higgins (R / 1905-1906)
Charles Evans Hughes (R / 1907-1910)
Horace White (R / 1910)
John Alden Dix (D / 1911-1912)
William Sulzer (D / 1913)
Martin H. Glynn (D / 1913-1914)
Charles S. Whitman (R / 1915-1918)
Al Smith (D / 1919-1920, 1923-1928)
Nathan Lewis Miller (R / 1921-1922)
Franklin D. Roosevelt (D / 1929-1932)
Herbert H. Lehman (D / 1933-1942)
Charles Poletti (D / 1942)
Thomas Dewey (R / 1943-1954)
W. Averell Harriman (D / 1955-1958)
Nelson Rockefeller (R / 1959-1973)
Malcolm Wilson (R / 1973-1974)
Hugh Carey (D / 1975-1982)
Mario Cuomo (D / 1983-1994)
George Pataki (R / 1995-2006)
Eliot Spitzer (D / 2007-2008)
David Paterson (D / 2008-2010)
Andrew Cuomo (D / 2011-…)

Results:
Round 1: Sulzer 16, Alden Dix 10, Marcy 7, George Clinton 4, Lewis 4, Seymour 4, Fenton 3, Tayler 3, Cornell 2, Glynn 2, White 2, DeWitt Clinton 1, Pitcher 1, Carey -1, Cleveland -1, F.D. Roosevelt -1, Tilden -1, Smith -1, Van Buren -1, Jay -4
Round 2: Tayler 12, Fenton 7, White 6, Lewis 5, Glynn 2, Pitcher 2, Poletti 2, Higgins 1, Hoffmann 1, George Clinton -2, DeWitt Clinton -3, Van Buren -5
Round 3: Poletti 12, Glynn 6, Higgins 6, Pitcher 5, Lewis 3, Clark 2, Hoffmann 2, Miller 1, Tompkins -1, Van Buren -1, DeWitt Clinton -2, George Clinton -2, Seymour -3


ROUND 4 IS OPEN !
In this round, you have 10 points to eliminate, to cast 7-1-1-1, and 3 points to keep, to cast 3.

[big bad fab]

Eliminate
7 Hoffmann
1 Pitcher
1 Clark
1 Bouck

Keep
3 Lewis

A very dangerous round, given our low turnout ( BTW: only Palin seems to appeal to forumers, while here, we have FDR, TR, Clintons, Van Buren, Seymour, Harriman, Dewey, Rockefeller, Cleveland, Tilden, etc, etc !)

[homelycooking]

Eliminate
7 Pitcher
1 Robinson
1 Clark
1 Bouck

Keep
3 Yates

A very dangerous round, given our low turnout ( BTW: only Palin seems to appeal to forumers, while here, we have FDR, TR, Clintons, Van Buren, Seymour, Harriman, Dewey, Rockefeller, Cleveland, Tilden, etc, etc !)

...but also a lot of really unremarkable governors.

[Hans-im-Glück]

Eliminate
7  Hunt
1  Pitcher
1  Clark
1  Higgins

Keep
3  Hoffman

[Vazdul (Formerly Chairman of the Communist Party of Ontario)]

Eliminate:
7 Van Buren
1 Lewis
1 Hoffman
1 Bouck

Keep:
3 Hunt