Canada with British parties

[Teddy (IDS Legislator)]

 (NOT RIDINGS!, PARTIES!!!)

Discuss with maps.

[Teddy (IDS Legislator)]

[Sibboleth]

Why would Churchill, which is what we would call a mining constituency, be anything other than Labour?

[Teddy (IDS Legislator)]

There's mining up there? Ah. I'd not realized. I had presumed it was more of a remote middle sized town (thompson) which would IMO be more tory-friendly than with Canadian parties.

[Teddy (IDS Legislator)]

I've done a little digging on economics and changed two of the maps.

[Smid]

I'm curious about London North Centre... isn't it mostly manufacturing workers? I could be wrong, that's just the picture I have in my head. 

[Hatman]

I think the 2011 map would be pretty close, no?

[Teddy (IDS Legislator)]

I'm curious about London North Centre... isn't it mostly manufacturing workers? I could be wrong, that's just the picture I have in my head. 

uh... which one is where the university is That's the one the Liberals would win. I think they'd do very well in university areas. Kingston is the only "university town" I think they'd lose because Kingston has a lot more stuff going on.

Earl: this is the 2011 map

[Teddy (IDS Legislator)]

totals btw
C - 142
L - 126
LD - 33
SNP/PC - 6
Green - 1

[Teddy (IDS Legislator)]

Note that the above presumes Quebec as modelled after Scotland. This is Quebec if it were NI.



C-141
L-68 (really hurt by the lack of a scotland/wales)
DUP-39
SDLP-26
LD-23
UUP-6
SF-2 (abstentionist)
APNI-2
Grn-1

Note that I used NI's DUP-over-UUP, but Canada's NDP-nationalism-over-the-BQ-more-extreme-stance, which explains why the DUP and SDLP split the province, and SF is nearly dead.

[Teddy (IDS Legislator)]

I actually think the above, in a modified form, might be a good idea. You could have a Bloc Quebecois for separatists, but a Bloc Canada as well. The Liberals, Conservatives, and NDP would all agree not to run candidates in Quebec, and endorse the Bloc Canada, which would run head to head with the Bloc Quebecois, and then the BC could form a coalition with whomever wins the election in the RoC.

Then again, the NDP has truly, I feel, done permanent damage to the Bloc. No more will leftos in Quebec vote for the Bloc because there is no other lefto option. I can not see a time when the NDP will have less than 3 MP's in the province, and the vote splitting with the NDP and Bloc will ensure that the Bloc will never see 50 seats again.

[Smid]

I'm curious about London North Centre... isn't it mostly manufacturing workers? I could be wrong, that's just the picture I have in my head. 

uh... which one is where the university is That's the one the Liberals would win. I think they'd do very well in university areas. Kingston is the only "university town" I think they'd lose because Kingston has a lot more stuff going on.

No worries, I stand corrected!

[Hatman]

I'm curious about London North Centre... isn't it mostly manufacturing workers? I could be wrong, that's just the picture I have in my head. 

uh... which one is where the university is That's the one the Liberals would win. I think they'd do very well in university areas. Kingston is the only "university town" I think they'd lose because Kingston has a lot more stuff going on.

Earl: this is the 2011 map

No, I mean the 2011 Canadian map would look a lot like a map using British parties.

[Sibboleth]

No, I mean the 2011 Canadian map would look a lot like a map using British parties.

Much, much closer than any previous federal map, yeah.

[Hatman]

No, I mean the 2011 Canadian map would look a lot like a map using British parties.

Much, much closer than any previous federal map, yeah.

This would have been a much more interesting exercise prior to 2011.

[Teddy (IDS Legislator)]

No, I mean the 2011 Canadian map would look a lot like a map using British parties.

Much, much closer than any previous federal map, yeah.

This would have been a much more interesting exercise prior to 2011.

Give me a bit on that.

[afleitch]

No, I mean the 2011 Canadian map would look a lot like a map using British parties.

Much, much closer than any previous federal map, yeah.

This would have been a much more interesting exercise prior to 2011.

Give me a bit on that.

How would Quebec vote in provincial elections with Scottish parties?

[Teddy (IDS Legislator)]

No, I mean the 2011 Canadian map would look a lot like a map using British parties.

Much, much closer than any previous federal map, yeah.

This would have been a much more interesting exercise prior to 2011.

Give me a bit on that.

How would Quebec vote in provincial elections with Scottish parties?

[Hatman]

Labour is almost always translated as "Parti travailliste", at least when I see PM's question time on CPAC and according to Wikipedia.

[Teddy (IDS Legislator)]

ok??

[King of Kensington]

Why are York West and Etobicoke North Lib Dem seats?  These would be Labour through and through (OK, maybe Etobicoke North would be where the Galloway upset occurred?)  Don Valley West is more likely to be Lib Dem than either of these two.

[adma]

And for that matter, Etobicoke Centre is more likely to be Lib Dem as well...

[Sibboleth]

(OK, maybe Etobicoke North would be where the Galloway upset occurred?)

Is it dominated by a single minority group with its own (opaque to outsiders) political traditions though? That's not a rhetorical question.

[You kip if you want to...]

(OK, maybe Etobicoke North would be where the Galloway upset occurred?)

Is it dominated by a single minority group with its own (opaque to outsiders) political traditions though? That's not a rhetorical question.

^This. Bradford is probably one of the more... unique places you'll find across the entire commonwealth.