Virginia republican party man arrested after destroying registration forms.

[I spent the winter writing songs about getting better]

So J. J.'s argument ultimately appears to be "There is nothing wrong with this because if you give your voter registration form to a random person on the street they are not obligated to deliver it. Even though this incident did not involve that."

[I spent the winter writing songs about getting better]

So J. J.'s argument ultimately appears to be "There is nothing wrong with this because if you give your voter registration form to a random person on the street they are not obligated to deliver it. Even though this incident did not involve that."

Well, I don't have an obligation, as a private citizen to mail anything for someone else.  This was a bit different because he agreed, presumably, to mail them.

It is obviously different if the person is an official and has a duty to mail them; I'll concede that he might have. 

Which means your example of a private citizen having to mail them is entirely pointless and completely irrelevant to this situation.

Also, most of the forms were duplicates of people already registered, so I would not call those voter suppression.

1. It is not illegal to submit a duplicate voter registration, nor uncommon.
2. Since we have the actual reason he threw them away why are you still continuing on this line anyway?

[I spent the winter writing songs about getting better]

So J. J.'s argument ultimately appears to be "There is nothing wrong with this because if you give your voter registration form to a random person on the street they are not obligated to deliver it. Even though this incident did not involve that."

Well, I don't have an obligation, as a private citizen to mail anything for someone else.  This was a bit different because he agreed, presumably, to mail them.

It is obviously different if the person is an official and has a duty to mail them; I'll concede that he might have. 

Which means your example of a private citizen having to mail them is entirely pointless and completely irrelevant to this situation.

Also, most of the forms were duplicates of people already registered, so I would not call those voter suppression.

1. It is not illegal to submit a duplicate voter registration, nor uncommon.
2. Since we have the actual reason he threw them away why are you still continuing on this line anyway?

Well, in the first place, because it wasn't clear to me he was hired first.

What the hell did you think happened? Eight people just walked up to this guy on the street and at random asked him to submit their voter registration forms?

It isn't voter suppression, or voter fraud, not to register someone who is already registered (unless it was a change of data).

In the eyes of the law, yes it is. As Alcon is stated it is illegal to refuse to deliver a voter registration form by anyone claiming they will do so unless they have written consent of the person in question. Which makes perfect sense, because duplicate registrations aren't really a big deal nor do they affect the rolls any, but allowing individuals in voter drives to just disgard registration forms that they think are duplicates leaves open a pretty big loophole toward deliberate voter suppression (and if the law is "You can throw away duplicate forms but if it turns out you're wrong and the form wasn't a duplicate after all you are guilty of a felony." then why would any person bother to do so anyway instead of simply delivering the forms?)

The reason was, he made a mistake.  That isn't voter suppression either.

No, but it does confound why anyone would continue to defend him.