Which of these countries should have permanent UNSC seats?

[Supersonic]

The New Security Council would consist of;

The U.S
India
China
Germany
Russia
Saudi Arabia
South Africa
Brazil
Britain
Australia
Japan

There is no veto power, and Ties are broken by the Secretary-General

No France?

[NewYorkExpress]

The New Security Council would consist of;

The U.S
India
China
Germany
Russia
Saudi Arabia
South Africa
Brazil
Britain
Australia
Japan

There is no veto power, and Ties are broken by the Secretary-General

No France?

India replaces France "officially" unofficially I was choosing between France, The U.K and Germany... and I only wanted three European Countries (counting Russia).

[Supersonic]

The New Security Council would consist of;

The U.S
India
China
Germany
Russia
Saudi Arabia
South Africa
Brazil
Britain
Australia
Japan

There is no veto power, and Ties are broken by the Secretary-General

No France?

India replaces France "officially" unofficially I was choosing between France, The U.K and Germany... and I only wanted three European Countries (counting Russia).

Ah I see. Thanks for sticking with ol' Blighty.

[Boris]

Give the PRC's seat back to the ROC and Russia's seat to Estonia, recognizing the latter as the legitimate legal successor and personality of the USSR.

[True Federalist (진정한 연방 주의자)]

Give the PRC's seat back to the ROC and Russia's seat to Estonia, recognizing the latter as the legitimate legal successor and personality of the USSR.

Belarus is probably the former Soviet republic that is most like the old USSR these days.

[minionofmidas]

I'm agnostic about the best membership setup, I just want the vetoes abolished.

[Deus Naturae]

The Security Council should be abolished

[Del Tachi]

SEMI-PERMANENT ELECTED VETO POWER.

Five year terms.  Non-consecutive.  Nominated by 3/5 of current permanent members.  2/3 vote for confirmation in the GA.   

This was my proposal to reform the UNSC at one of my high school mock UNSCs.  I was Germany.

[nolesfan2011]

Germany and Japan, and maybe add the EU as well (and keep France).

[Frodo]

I think this list ought to cover it:

United States
China
Russia
European Union
United Kingdom
Japan
India
Brazil
-------------


And eventually Indonesia

[Snowstalker Mk. II]

Leave it at 5, but consolidate Britain and France into an EU slot and give the open space to India.

[Mordecai]

The permanent members of the United Nations Security Council are US, UK, France, Russia, China.  Which other countries should have permanent representation?

Brazil, India and South Africa. And there should be reform so that a veto requires at least two votes from those eight permanent members.

[Cory]

Voted Germany, India, and Brazil. It's time for the UN to stop being the "winners of WWII" club.

[Hash]

5 permanent members:

Saint Pierre-et-Miquelon
Falkland Islands
Pitcairn Islands
Tristan da Cunha
Faroe Islands

[Oldiesfreak1854]

Keep it the way it is.

[Knives]

No one should and if they do then veto power should be removed.

[politicallefty]

I'd be willing to support expanding the permanent seats, but only if the unilateral veto was changed. I could see expanding to 12 seats and requiring 9 votes for any action. In that case, I could see most of the poll options being top candidates for such seats.