Excellent work. As a quick comment, you might play with the shade for CPVI 4. It looks more Pub than CPVI 5. For example compare IL 14, 16 and 18. IL-16 seems to be shaded more towards 18 when it is more D than 14. I suspect that the blue tinting isn't coming through very well there.
Yeah, I see that. The main issue (one of the ones I mentioned above) has to do with using the Atlas blue/red colors. Unlike the maps on here, the colors on the legend are only displayed as a reference and used to create the gradient. Most colors displayed on there fall in between two of those displayed colors in the legend. Hence the inclusion of purple for those that fall around 50/50, as opposed to being in the "40/50% R" or "40/50% D" shades that we're so used to on here.
Purple has a tendency to look darker than some shades of red and causes areas that would be in the low-50s on either side to look like stronger Republican/Democratic areas, making the areas you mentioned look out of sync. Once it gets to around 54% R / R+5, it begins to correct. I may have to consider using an entirely different color scheme to correct this.