Who would you vote for confirm as a judge?

[I spent the winter writing songs about getting better]

Basically imagine you're a Senator and all of these forum members have been nominated for judicial positions. Say whether you'd vote to confirm them or not:

1-Philip
2-BRTD
3-John Dibble
4-opebo
5-Lunar
6-jfern
7-bandit
8-Flyers
9-Keystone Phil
10-StatesRights
11-Jake
12-Al
13-migrendel
14-nclib
15-nickshepDEM
16-Sam Spade
17-Harry
18-Ebowed
19-John Ford
20-John Engle
21-WMS
22-Lewis Trondheim
23-KEmperor
24-Bob
25-angus
26-Nym
27-Ernest
28-Peter Bell
29-Mike Naso
30-phknrocket1k

[I spent the winter writing songs about getting better]

1-no
2-yes
3-yes
4-only if it was ensured he wouldn't preside over any child molestation cases
5-yes (he'd be a perfect judicial candidate actually)
6-yes
7-yes (we can expect some interesting rulings here)
8-yes
9-no
10-no
11-no
12-yes
13-only if I could be ensured he wouldn't legalize infantcide
14-yes (another great pick)
15-yes
16-hmm, yes
17-yes
18-yes
19-no
20-would be entertaining, but no
21-yes
22-yes
23-no
24-yes
25-yes
26-yes
27-yes (another perfect candidate)
28-yes
29-no
30-yes

[I spent the winter writing songs about getting better]

what's wrong with bandit? I Think he'd make some entertaining rulings.

[I spent the winter writing songs about getting better]

10-StatesRights - No

What? Is this a conservative coup against me?

Dude, it pained me to put that in writing, but I had to be honest.  While I agree with some of your views, I think your interpretation of certain key issues is a bit extreme.

I am a hardline constitutionalist.

You think the 16th Amendment is Unconstitutional.

[I spent the winter writing songs about getting better]

Why the hell is everyone voting for John Dibble? You know he probably agrees with me on 90% of the issues, right?

He doesn't support restricting voting rights, doesn't endorse discrimination against homosexuals and has a little thing called "maturity".

[I spent the winter writing songs about getting better]

1-Philip - Yes

er, why?