Franklin D. Roosevelt vs. Ronald Reagan today

[President Johnson]

What might be the result of a presidential contest between Franklin D. Roosevelt and Ronald Reagan today? FDR is the highest-rated Democrat in the past 100 years, while Reagan is the highest rated Republican since TR (moderates might prefer Eisenhower; but Ike would be too liberal of the modern GOP). And both, FDR and Reagan, were charismatic figures.
Discuss with maps if possible.

[Goldwater]

285-253

[Skill and Chance]

285-253

Assuming that both take modern positions on social issues, I basically agree with this.  Given the labor angle to an election between them, I would flip CO, OH and FL (social security!).  I'm not sure about VA, but I would guess it still barely goes to FDR.

[Mr. Smith]

This,...except add North Carolina, and flip Ohio and Florida.

[DKrol]

This,...except add North Carolina, and flip Ohio and Florida.

I think Florida's senior citizens would vote with the elderly Reagan.

[Türkisblau]

This,...except add North Carolina, and flip Ohio and Florida.

I think Florida's senior citizens would vote with the elderly Reagan.

But FDR represents the good old days.

FDR wins because Reagan doesn't have a World War victory to run off of.

[Jerseyrules]

This,...except add North Carolina, and flip Ohio and Florida.

I think Florida's senior citizens would vote with the elderly Reagan.

But FDR represents the good old days.

FDR wins because Reagan doesn't have a World War victory to run off of.

But Reagan had a Cold War victory to run on, which many elderly voters can still remember