Which George W. Bush accomplishment is your favorite?

[mencken]

John Roberts

Of "Obamacare is a tax except when it isn't" fame?

[mencken]

John Roberts

Of "Obamacare is a tax except when it isn't" fame?

Obamacare is constitutional so it can't be thrown out by courts . It can only be repealed by congress .

Only if one tautologically defines "constitutional" as "what the Supreme Court says is constitutional." Otherwise how can one say that a provision is a tax within Congress's delegated powers but not a tax that would need to originate in the House as constitutionally mandated?