Which Quarterback season was more impressive?

[JRP1994]

2007 Tom Brady
398/578 = 68.9%
4,806yd
50 TD
8 INT
Notes: Led Patriots to 18-1 record, losing SB42 to the Giants (17-14)

2013 Peyton Manning
450/659 = 68.3%
5,477yd
55 TD
10 INT
Notes: Led Broncos to 15-4 record, losing SB48 to the Seahawks (43-8)

[© tweed]

probably Brady's 2007 by a nose, but consider Manning has two of the top four QB seasons of all-time.  (Marino 1984, Manning 2004, Brady 2007, Manning 2013)


incidentally, for the championship fetishists, none of these four won Super Bowls.

[Grumpier Than Thou]

I'd say lean Brady for having a slightly less impressive core of receivers, and for having a perfect regular season.

[DemPGH]

Brady '07. Objectively should have won that Super Bowl.

I'd say lean Brady for having a slightly less impressive core of receivers, and for having a perfect regular season.

While he had Randy Moss that year, I agree with you. Brady has never had receivers like Manning has had. And I'll take Brady over Manning in a big game, i.e. post season, as well.