What a gross misinterpretation of the poll results. "support them even if our interests diverge" in no way means "more loyal".
If Israeli interests were to directly contravene US interests, and these people continue to support those interests anyway, then yes, they are more loyal to Israel than us. This isn't hard.
Sure, let's just add words to the poll question like "directly contravene" after the fact.
Do you ever get tired of spinning this hard for the GOP? You do it more reflexively than most blue avatars around here!
There are no logical leaps going on here. Some people were asked a question; they answered it honestly, clearly without (a) realizing the repercussions of what they were saying, or (b) caring.