Who would you vote for?

[Goldwater]

Who knows? 

The second option isn't even necessarily more libertarian. Someone could call themselves "fiscally conservative and socially liberal" because they want to cut property taxes and support abortion, even as they make frequent use of eminent domain and support the drug war.

Not to mention that "Fiscal Liberal" isn't actually a term anybody uses to describe themselves, meaning that it could just as easily refer to economic liberalism as it could to any sort of left leaning economic views.