Yes to a perma for Tweed, BK's should be temporary (few months), Griffin shouldn't have been banned at all.
From what I understand (not everything) that seems about right.
Punishment does not align with my values system
We seem to have similar values systems, then!
Jesus only unbanned people when He knew they were definitely better, though. That would be harder to do in this case, because none of us are omniscient deities. I'm very much against the death penalty, but, well, being permabanned from Atlas is hardly death.