IRV in past Presidential elections

[sparkey]

Suppose that past Presidential elections had the same candidates, but instead of the electoral college, they used a national IRV vote. How would your ballots have looked? I'm particularly interested in the races with more than 2 major candidates, namely: 1824, 1836, 1856, 1860, and 1912; and let's throw in 1848, 1948, and 1996 even though Van Buren, Thurmond, Wallace, and Perot weren't exactly major candidates those years.

Here are mine:

1824
1. Crawford
2. Jackson
3. Adams
4. Clay

1836
1. Van Buren
(wouldn't have cared too much about the order of Whigs)

1848
1. Van Buren
2. Smith
3. Taylor
4. Cass

1856
1. Frémont
2. Buchanan
3. Fillmore

1860
1. Lincoln
2. Douglas
3. Bell
4. Breckinridge

1912
1. Taft
2. Roosevelt
3. Wilson
4. Debs

1948
1. Dewey
2. Truman
3. Wallace
(no vote for Thurmond or minor candidates)

1996
1. Browne
2. Perot
3. Dole
4. Nader
5. Clinton
6. Phillips
7. Hagelin

[Unconditional Surrender Truman]

1824
[1] John Q. Adams (DR)
[2] Henry Clay (DR)
[3] William H. Crawford (DR)
[4] Andrew Jackson (DR)

1836*
[1] Daniel Webster (W)
[2] Martin Van Buren (D)
[3] William H. Harrison (W)
[4] Hugh L. White (W)
[5] Willie P. Magnum (W)

(*IRL, I wouldn't have had a choice between all four Whigs, as the party only ran one candidate per Region.)

1848
[1] Martin Van Buren (FS)
[2] Zachary Taylor (W)
[3] Lewis Cass (D)

1856
[1] John C. Fremont (R)
[2] James Buchanan (D)
[3] Millard Fillmore (A)

1860
[1] Abraham Lincoln (R)
[2] Stephen Douglass (D)
[3] John Bell (CU)
[4] NOTA

1912
[1] Theodore Roosevelt (P)
[2] Woodrow Wilson (D)
[3] William H. Taft (R)
[4] Eugene V. Debs (S)

1948
[1] Harry S. Truman (D)
[2] Thomas Dewey (R)
[3] Henry Wallace (P)
[4] NOTA

1992
[1] Bill Clinton (D)
[2] Ross Perot (I)
[3] George H. W. Bush (R)

[Clark Kent]

1824

[1] John Quincy Adams
[2] Henry Clay
[3] Andrew Jackson
[4] William Crawford

1828

[1] John Quincy Adams
[2] Andrew Jackson

1832

[1] Henry Clay
[2] William Wirt
[3] Andrew Jackson

1836

[1] Martin van Buren
[2] Daniel Webster (Northeastern Whig)

1840

[1] Martin van Buren
[2] William Henry Harrison

1844

[1] James K. Polk
[2] Henry Clay

1848

[1] Martin van Buren
[2] Zachary Taylor
[3] Lewis Cass

1852

[1] John P. Hale
[2] Winfield Scott
[3] Franklin Pierce

1856

[1] John C. Fremont
[2] James Buchanan
[3] Millard Fillmore

1860

[1] Abraham Lincoln
[2] Stephen Douglas
[3] John Bell
[  ] John C. Breckinridge

1864

[1] Abraham Lincoln
[2] George B. McClellan

1868

[1] Ulysses S. Grant
[2] Horatio Seymour

1872

[1] Ulysses S. Grant
[2] Horace Greeley

1876

[1] Samuel Tilden
[2] Rutherford B. Hayes

1880

[1] James Garfield
[2] Winfield Hancock

1884

[1] James G. Blaine
[2] Grover Cleveland

1888

[1] Grover Cleveland
[2] Benjamin Harrison

1892

[1] Grover Cleveland
[2] Benjamin Harrison
[  ] James B. Weaver

1896

[1] William McKinley
[2] William Jennings Bryan

1900

[1] William McKinley
[2] William Jennings Bryan

1904

[1] Alton B. Parker
[2] Theodore Roosevelt

1908

[1] William Howard Taft
[2] William Jennings Bryan

1912

[1] William Howard Taft
[2] Theodore Roosevelt
[3] Woodrow Wilson
[  ] Eugene V. Debs

1916

[1] Charles Evan Hughes
[2] Woodrow Wilson

1920

[1] Warren Harding
[2] James Cox

1924

[1] Calvin Coolidge
[2] John Davis
[3] Robert LaFollette

1928

[1] Herbert Hoover
[2] Al Smith

1932

[1] Herbert Hoover
[2] Franklin D. Roosevelt

1936

[1] Alf Landon
[2] Franklin D. Roosevelt

1940

[1] Wendell Wilkie
[2] Franklin D. Roosevelt

1944

[1] Thomas Dewey
[2] Franklin D. Roosevelt

1948

[1] Thomas Dewey
[2] Harry S. Truman
[  ] Strom Thurmond
[  ] Henry A. Wallace

1952

[1] Dwight D. Eisenhower
[2] Adlai Stevenson

1956

[1] Dwight D. Eisenhower
[2] Adlai Stevenson

1960

[1] Richard Nixon
[2] John F. Kennedy
[  ] Harry Byrd

1964

[1] Barry Goldwater
[2] Lyndon B. Johnson

1968

[1] Richard Nixon
[2] Hubert Humphrey
[  ] George Wallace

1972

[1] Richard Nixon
[2] George McGovern

1976

[1] Gerald Ford
[2] Jimmy Carter

1980

[1] Ronald Reagan
[2] John Anderson
[3] Jimmy Carter

1984

[1] Ronald Reagan
[2] Walter Mondale

1988

[1] George H.W. Bush
[2] Michael Dukakis

1992

[1] George H.W. Bush
[2] Bill Clinton
[3] Ross Perot

1996

[1] Bob Dole
[2] Bill Clinton
[3] Ross Perot

2000

[1] George W. Bush
[2] Al Gore

2004

[1] George W. Bush
[2] John Kerry

2008

[1] John McCain
[2] Barack Obama

2012

[1] Mitt Romney
[2] Gary Johnson
[3] Barack Obama

[TNF]

2012
[1] Jerry White (Socialist Equality)
[2] James Harris (Socialist Workers)
[3] Peta Lindsay (Socialism and Liberation)
[4] Stewart Alexander (Socialist)

2008
[1] Roger Calero (Socialist Workers)
[2] Gloria LaRiva (Socialism and Liberation)
[3] Brian Moore (Socialist)

2004
[1] Bill Van Auken (Socialist Equality)
[2] Roger Calero (Socialist Workers)
[3] John Parker (Workers World)
[4] Walt Brown (Socialist)

2000
[1] James Harris (Socialist Workers)
[2] Monica Moorehead (Workers World)
[3] David McReynolds (Socialist)

1996
[1] Jerome White (Socialist Equality)
[2] James Harris (Socialist Workers)
[3] Monica Moorehead (Workers World)
[4] Mary Cal Hollis (Socialist)
[5] Marsha Feinland (Peace and Freedom)

1992
[1] Helen Halyard (Workers League)
[2] James Warren (Socialist Workers)
[3] Gloria LaRiva (Workers World)
[4] J. Quinn Brisben (Socialist)
[5] Ron Daniels (Peace and Freedom)

1988
[1] Edward Winn (Workers League)
[2] James Warren (Socialist Workers)
[3] Larry Holmes (Workers World)
[4] Willa Kenoyer (Socialist)
[5] Herbert Lewin (Peace and Freedom)

1984
[1] Edward Winn (Workers League)
[2] Melvin Mason (Socialist Workers)
[3] Larry Holmes (Workers World)
[4] Gus Hall (Communist)

1980
[1] Clifton DeBerry (Socialist Workers)
[2] Deidre Griswold (Workers World)
[3] Gus Hall (Communist)
[4] David McReynolds (Socialist)

1976
[1] Peter Camejo (Socialist Workers)
[2] Gus Hall (Communist)
[3] Julius Levin (Socialist Labor)
[4] Frank Zeidler (Socialist)

1972
[1] Linda Jenness (Socialist Workers)
[2] Gus Hall (Communist)
[3] Louis Fisher (Socialist Labor)

1968
[1] Fred Halstead (Socialist Workers)
[2] Charlene Mitchell (Communist)
[3] Henning Blomen (Socialist Labor)
[4] Dick Gregory (Peace and Freedom)

1964
[1] Clifton DeBerry (Socialist Workers)
[2] Eric Hass (Socialist Labor)

1960
[1] Farrell Dobbs (Socialist Workers)
[2] Eric Hass (Socialist Labor)

1956
[1] Farrell Dobbs (Socialist Workers)
[2] Eric Hass (Socialist Labor)
[3] Darlington Hoopes (Socialist)

1952
[1] Farrell Dobbs (Socialist Workers)
[2] Eric Hass (Socialist Labor)
[3] Darlington Hoopes (Socialist)

1948
[1] Farrell Dobbs (Socialist Workers)
[2] Edward Teichert (Socialist Labor)
[3] Norman Thomas (Socialist)

1944
[1] Edward Teichert (Socialist Labor)
[2] Norman Thomas (Socialist)

1940
[1] Earl Browder (Communist)
[2] John Aiken (Socialist Labor)
[3] Norman Thomas (Socialist)

1936
[1] Norman Thomas (Socialist)
[2] Earl Browder (Communist)
[3] John Aiken (Socialist Labor)

1932
[1] William Z. Foster (Communist)
[2] Verne Reynolds (Socialist Labor)
[3] Norman Thomas (Socialist)
[4] Jacob Coxey (Farmer-Labor)

1928
[1] William Z. Foster (Communist)
[2] Verne Reynolds (Socialist Labor)
[3] Norman Thomas (Socialist)
[4] Frank Webb (Farmer-Labor)

1924
[1] William Z. Foster (Communist)
[2] Frank Johns (Socialist Labor)

1920
[1] Eugene Debs (Socialist)
[2] William Cox (Socialist Labor)
[3] Parley Christiansen (Farmer-Labor)

1916
[1] Arthur Reimer (Socialist Labor)
[2] Allan Benson (Socialist)

1912
[1] Eugene Debs (Socialist)
[2] Arthur Reimer (Socialist Labor)

[ElectionsGuy]

All elections 1824-present with all candidates receiving >.5% of the vote (rounded):

1824

[1] Andrew Jackson
[2] Quincy Adams
[3] William Crawford
[4] Henry Clay

1832

[1] Andrew Jackson
[2] William Wirt
[3] Henry Clay

1836

[1] Martin Van Buren
[2] Hugh White
[3] William Harrison
[4] Daniel Webster

1840

[1] Martin Van Buren
[2] James Birney
[3] William Harrison

1844

[1] James Birney
[2] James Polk
[3] Henry Clay

1848

[1] Martin Van Buren
[2] Zachary Taylor
[3] Lewis Cass

1852

[1] John Hale
[2] Winfield Scott
[3] Franklin Pierce

1856

[1] John Fremont
[2] James Buchanan
[3] Millard Fillmore

1860

[1] Abraham Lincoln
[2] Stephen Douglas
[3] John Bell
[4] John Breckinridge

1876

[1] Samuel Tilden
[2] Rutherford Hayes
[3] Peter Cooper

1880

[1] Winfield Hancock
[2] James Garfield
[3] James Weaver

1884

[1] Grover Cleveland
[2] James Blaine
[3] John St John
[4] Benjamin Butler

1888

[1] Grover Cleveland
[2] Benjamin Harrison
[3] Clinton Fisk
[4] Alson Streeter

1892

[1] Grover Cleveland
[2] James Weaver
[3] Benjamin Harrison
[4] John Bidwell

1896

[1] John Palmer
[2] William McKinley
[3] William Bryan
[4] Joshua Levering

1900

[1] William Bryan
[2] William McKinley
[3] John Woolley
[4] Eugene Debs

1904

[1] Alton Parker
[2] Theodore Roosevelt
[3] Thomas Watson
[4] Silas Swallow
[5] Eugene Debs

1908

[1] William Taft
[2] William Bryan
[3] Thomas Hisgen
[4] Eugene Chafin
[5] Eugene Debs

1912

[1] William Taft
[2] Theodore Roosevelt
[3] Woodrow Wilson
[4] Eugene Chafin
[5] Eugene Debs

1916

[1] Charles Hughes
[2] James Hanly
[3] Woodrow Wilson
[4] Allan Benson

1920

[1] Warren Harding
[2] James Cox
[3] Parley Christiansen
[4] Aaron Watkins
[5] Eugene Debs

1924

[1] Calvin Coolidge
[2] John Davis
[3] Robert LaFollette

1928

[1] Herbert Hoover (with no hindsight)
[2] Al Smith
[3] Norman Thomas

1932

[1] Franklin Roosevelt
[2] Herbert Hoover
[3] Norman Thomas

1936

[1] Alfred Landon
[2] William Lemke
[3] Franklin Roosevelt

1948

[1] Thomas Dewey
[2] Harry Truman
[3] Henry Wallace
[4] Strom Thurmond

1968

[1] Richard Nixon
[2] Hubert Humprey
[3] George Wallace

1972

[1] George McGovern
[2] Richard Nixon
[3] John Schmitz

1976

[1] Gerald Ford
[2] James Carter
[3] Eugene McCarthy

1980

[1] Ed Clark
[2] Ronald Reagan
[3] James Carter
[4] John Anderson

1988

[1] Ron Paul
[2] George Bush
[3] Michael Dukakis

1992

[1] Ross Perot
[2] George Bush
[3] Bill Clinton

1996

[1] Harry Browne
[2] Robert Dole
[3] William Clinton
[4] Ross Perot
[5] Ralph Nader

2000

[1] George Bush
[2] Al Gore
[3] Ralph Nader

2008

[1] Barack Obama
[2] John McCain
[3] Ralph Nader

2012

[1] Gary Johnson
[2] Mitt Romney
[3] Barack Obama

[sparkey]

Well, not an overwhelming response yet, but here are the tallies so far for the elections I was most interested in:

1824: Adams in 2 rounds (no votes for Clay, Jackson eliminated, then Adams over Crawford).

1836: Van Buren in 1 round.

1848: Van Buren unanimously. Taylor without Van Buren.

1856: Frémont unanimously. Buchanan without Frémont.

1860: Lincoln unanimously. Douglas without Lincoln.

1912: Taft in 2 rounds (Roosevelt, Wilson, and Debs eliminated at the same time; enough votes transfer to Taft)

1948: Dewey in 1 round.

1996: Harry Browne in 1 round (lol).

[Unconditional Surrender Truman]

1848: Van Buren unanimously. Taylor without Van Buren.

1856: Frémont unanimously. Buchanan without Frémont.

1860: Lincoln unanimously. Douglas without Lincoln.

Glad to see the forum is still sane.

[VPH]

1824
[1] Quincy Adams
[2] Henry Clay
[3] Andrew Jackson
[4] William Crawford


1832
[1] Henry Clay
[2] Andrew Jackson
[X] William Wirt


1836
[1] Martin Van Buren
[2] William Harrison
[3] Daniel Webster
[X] Hugh White

1840

[1] James Birney
[2] Martin Van Buren
[3] William Harrison

1844

[1] James Birney
[2] Henry Clay
[3] James Polk

1848

[1] Martin Van Buren
[2] Zachary Taylor
[3] Lewis Cass

1852

[1] John Hale
[2] Winfield Scott
[3] Franklin Pierce

1856

[1] John Fremont
[2] James Buchanan
[X] Millard Fillmore

1860

[1] Abraham Lincoln
[2] Stephen Douglas
[X] John Bell
[X] John Breckinridge

1876

[1] Peter Cooper
[2] Rutherford Hayes
[3] Samuel Tilden

1880

[1] James Weaver
[2] James Garfield
[3] Winfield Hancock

1884

[1] Benjamin Butler
[2] John St John
[3] James Blaine
[4] Grover Cleveland

1888

[1] Alson Streeter
[2] Benjamin Harrison
[3] Clinton Fisk
[X] Grover Cleveland

1892

[1] James Weaver
[2] Benjamin Harrison
[3] John Bidwell
[X] Grover Cleveland

1896

[1] William Jennings Bryan
[2] John Palmer
[3] William McKinley
[4] Joshua Levering

1900

[1] William Jennings Bryan
[2] Eugene Debs
[3] William McKinley
[4] John Wooley

1904

[1] Theodore Roosevelt
[2] Eugene Debs
[3] Alton Parker
[4] Silas Swallow
[X] Thomas Watson

1908

[1] William Jennings Bryan
[2] Eugene Debs
[3] Thomas Hisgen
[4] William Taft
[5] Eugene Chafin

1912

[1] Theodore Roosevelt
[2] Woodrow Wilson
[3] Eugene Debs
[4] William Taft
[5] Eugene Chafin

1916

[1] Woodrow Wilson
[2] Charles Evans Hughes
[3] Allan Benson
[4] James Hanly

1920

[1] Eugene Debs
[2] Parley Christiansen
[3] James Cox
[4] Warren Harding
[5] Aaron Watkins

1924

[1] Robert LaFollette
[2] John Davis
[3] Calvin Coolidge

1928

[1] Al Smith
[2] Norman Thomas
[3] Herbert Hoover

1932

[1] Franklin Roosevelt
[2] Norman Thomas
[3] Herbert Hoover

1936

[1] Franklin Roosevelt
[2] Alf Landon
[3] William Lemke

1948

[1] Harry Truman
[2] Henry Wallace
[3] Thomas Dewey
[X] Strom Thurmond

1968

[1] Hubert Humphrey
[2] Richard Nixon
[X] George Wallace

1972

[1] George McGovern
[2] Richard Nixon
[X] John Schmitz

1976

[1] Jimmy Carter
[2] Eugene McCarthy
[3] Gerald Ford

1980

[1] John Anderson
[2] Jimmy Carter
[3] Ronald Reagan
[X] Ed Clark

1988

[1] Michael Dukakis
[2] George Bush
[X] Ron Paul

1992

[1] Ross Perot
[2] Bill Clinton
[3] George Bush

1996

[1] Bill Clinton
[2] Ross Perot
[3] Bob Dole
[4] Ralph Nader
[X] Harry Browne

2000

[1] Ralph Nader
[2] Al Gore
[X] George W. Bush

2008

[1] Barack Obama
[2] Ralph Nader
[3] John McCain

2012

[1] Barack Obama
[2] Mitt Romney
[X] Gary Johnson

[mencken]

1824
1. Crawford
2. Jackson
3. Adams
4. Clay

1836
1. Van Buren
2. Magnum
3. White
4. Webster
5. Harrison

1848
1. Van Buren
2. Smith
3. Taylor
4. Cass

1860
1. Bell
2. Douglas
3. Breckinridge
4. Lincoln

1912
1. Taft
2. Debs
3. Wilson
4. Roosevelt

1948
1. Thurmond
2. Thomas
3. Dewey
4. Truman
5. Wallace

1992
1. Phillips
2. Perot
3. Marrou
4. Bush
5. Gritz
6. Clinton

1996
1. Browne
2. Phillips
3. Perot
4. Nader
5. Dole
6. Clinton

[Kingpoleon]

1824:
1. Henry Clay/Nathan Sanford(D-R)
2. John Quincy Adams/John Calhoun(D-R)
3. William Crawford/Nathaniel Macon(D-R)
4. Andrew Jackson/John Calhoun(D-R)

1836:
1. Martin Van Buren/Richard Mentor Johnson
2. William Harrison/Francis Granger
3. Daniel Webster/Francis Granger
4. Willie Mangum/John Tyler
5. Hugh White/John Tyler

1848:
1. Zachary Taylor/Millard Fillmore(Whig)
2. Gerritt Smith/Charles Foote(Liberty)
3. Martin Van Buren/Charles Francis Adams, Sr.(Free Soil
4. Lewis Cass/William Orlando Butler(D)

1856:
1. John Fremont/William Dayton
2. James Buchanan/John Breckinridge
3. Millard Fillmore/Andrew Donelson

1860:
1. John Bell/Edward Everett
2. Abraham Lincoln/Hannibal Hamlin
3. Stephen Douglas/Herschel Johnson
4. John Breckinridge/Joseph Lane

1872:
1. Horace Greeley/Benjamin Gatz Brown
2. Charles O'Conor/John Quincy Adams II
3. Ulysses Grant/Henry Wilson

1892:
1. James Weaver/James Field
2. Grover Cleveland/Adlai Stevenson I
3. Benjamin Harrison/Whitelaw Reid

1896:
1. William Jennings Bryan/Thomas Watson
2. John M. Palmer/Simon Bolivar Buckner(National Democratic)
3. William McKinley/Arthur Hobart

1912:
1. Theodore Roosevelt/Hiram Johnson
2. William Howard Taft/Nicholas Butler
3. Eugene Chafin/Aaron Watkins(Prohibition
4. Woodrow Wilson/Thomas Marshall

1920:
1. James Cox/Franklin D. Roosevelt
2. Parley Cristensen/Max Hayes(Farmer-Labor)
3. Warren G. Harding/Calvin Coolidge

1924:
1. John W. Davis/Charles Bryan
2. Robert La Follette, Sr./Burton Wheeler
3. Calvin Coolidge/Charles Dawes

1948:
1. Thomas Dewey/Earl Warren
2. Henry Wallace/Glen Taylor
3. Harry Truman/Alben Barkley

1968:
1. Hubert Humphrey/Edmund Muskie
2. Richard Nixon/Spiro Agnew

1976:
1. Gerald Ford/Bob Dole
2. Eugene McCarthy/Various
3. Jimmy Carter/Walter Mondale

1980:
1. Ed Clark/David Koch
2. John B. Anderson/Patrick Lucey
3. Barry Commoner/La Donna Harris
4. Ronald Reagan/George Bush
5. Jimmy Carter/Walter Mondale

1988:
1. Ron Paul/Andre Marrou
2. George Bush/Dan Quayle
3. Mike Dukakis/Lloyd Bentsen

1992:
1. Andre Marrou/Nancy Lord
2. Ross Perot/James Stockdale
3. George Bush/Dan Quayle
4. Bill Clinton/Al Gore

1996:
1. Harry Browne/Jo Jorgensen
2. Ross Perot/Pat Choate
3. Bob Dole/Jack Kemp
4. Bill Clinton/Al Gore

2004:
1. Michael Badnarik/Richard Campagna
2. David Cobb/Pat LaMarche
3. George W. Bush/Dick Cheney
4. John Kerry/John Edwards

[evergreenarbor]

1824
1. Henry Clay (Democratic-Republican [D-R])
2. John Quincy Adams (D-R)
3. William Crawford (D-R)
4. Andrew Jackson (D-R)

1832
1. Henry Clay (National Republican)
2. Andrew Jackson (Democratic [D])
2. William Wirt (Anti-Masonic)

1836
1. Martin Van Buren (D)
2. William Henry Harrison (Whig [W])
3. Daniel Webster (W)
4. Hugh White (W)

1844
1. Henry Clay (W)
2. James Birney (Liberty)
3. James K. Polk (D)

1848
1. Martin Van Buren (Free Soil [FS])
2. Zachary Taylor (W)
3. Gerrit Smith (National Liberty)
4. Lewis Cass (D)

1852
1. John Hale (FS)
2. Winfield Scott (W)
3. Franklin Pierce (D)

1856
1. John Fremont (Republican [R])
2. Millard Fillmore (Whig-American)
3. James Buchanan (D)

1860
1. Abraham Lincoln (R)
2. Stephen Douglas (D)
3. John Bell (Constitutional Union)
4. John Breckenridge (Southern Democrat)

1876
1. Peter Cooper (Greenback [GB])
2. Rutherford B. Hayes (R)
3. Samuel Tilden (D)

1880
1. James Weaver (GB)
2. James Garfield (R)
3. Winfield Hancock (D)

1892
1. James Weaver (Populist [PO])
2. Benjamin Harrison (R)
3. Grover Cleveland (D)

1896
1. William J. Bryan (D)
2. John M. Palmer (National Democrat)
3. William McKinley (R)

1900
1. Eugene V. Debs (Socialist [SO])
2. William J. Bryan (D)
3. William McKinley (R)

1904
1. Eugene V. Debs (SO)
2. Theodore Roosevelt (R)
3. Thomas Watson (PO)
4. Alton Parker (D)

1908
1. Eugene V. Debs (SO)
2. Thomas Hisgen (Independence)
3. William J. Bryan (D)
4. William H. Taft (R)

1912
1. Theodore Roosevelt (Progressive [P])
2. Eugene V. Debs (SO)
3. William H. Taft (R)
4. Woodrow Wilson (D)

1916
1. Allan Benson (SO)
2. Charles E. Hughes (R)
3. Woodrow Wilson (D)

1920
1. Eugene V. Debs (SO)
2. Parley Christiansen (Farmer-Labor)
3. James Cox (D)
4. Warren Harding (R)

1924
1. Robert LaFollette (P)
2. Calvin Coolidge (R)
3. John W. Davis (D)

1928
1. Norman Thomas (SO)
2. Herbert Hoover (R)
3. Al Smith (D)

1932
1. Franklin D. Roosevelt (D)
2. Norman Thomas (SO)
3. Herbert Hoover (R)

1936
1. Franklin D. Roosevelt (D)
2. William Lemke (Union)
3. Alf Landon (R)

1948
1. Henry Wallace (P)
2. Harry Truman (D)
3. Thomas Dewey (R)
4. Strom Thurmond (State's Rights)

1968
1. Hubert Humphrey (D)
2. Richard Nixon (R)
3. George Wallace (American Independence)

1972
1. George McGovern (D)
2. Richard Nixon (R)
3. John Schmitz (American)

1976
1. Eugene McCarthy (Independent [IN])
2. Jimmy Carter (D)
3. Gerald Ford (R)

1980
1. Jimmy Carter (D)
2. John Anderson (IN)
3. Edward Clark (Libertarian [L])
4. Ronald Reagan (R)

1992
1. Bill Clinton (D)
2. Ross Perot (IN)
3. George HW Bush (R)

1996
1. Ralph Nader (Green [G])
2. Bill Clinton (D)
3. Harry Browne (L)
4. Ross Perot (Reform)
5. Bob Dole (R)

2000
1. Ralph Nader (G)
2. Al Gore (D)
3. George W. Bush (R)

2008
1. Barack Obama (D)
2. Ralph Nader (IN)
3. John McCain (R)

2012
1. Barack Obama (D)
2. Gary Johnson (L)
3. Mitt Romney (R)

[Unconditional Surrender Truman]

1824
[1] Henry Clay (DR)
[2] John Q. Adams (DR)
[3] William H. Crawford (DR)
[4] Andrew Jackson (DR)

1832
[1] Henry Clay (NR)
[2] William Wirt (AM)
[3] Andrew Jackson (D)

1836
[1] Daniel Webster (W)
[2] William H. Harrison (W)
[3] Martin Van Buren (D)
[4] Hugh L. White (W)
[4] Willie P. Magnum (W)

1848
[1] Martin Van Buren (FS)
[2] Zachary Taylor (W)
[3] Lewis Cass (D)

1852
[1] John P. Hale (FS)
[2] Winfield Scott (W)
[3] Franklin Pierce (D)

1856
[1] John C. Fremont (R)
[2] James Buchanan (D)
[3] Millard Fillmore (A)

1860
[1] Abraham Lincoln (R)
[2] Stephen Douglas (D)
[3] John Bell (CU)
[4] John C. Breckinridge (D)

1892
[1] James B. Weaver (P)
[2] Grover Cleveland (D)
[3] Benjamin Harrison (R)

1912
[1] Theodore Roosevelt (P)
[2] Woodrow Wilson (D)*
[3] William H. Taft (R)
[4] Eugene V. Debs (S)

*Due to the nomination of Indiana's Thomas Marshall for veep

1924
[1] Robert M. La Follette (P)
[2] Calvin Coolidge (R)
[3] John W. Davis (D)

1948
[1] Harry S. Truman (D)
[2] Thomas Dewey (R)
[3] Henry Wallace (P)
[4] Strom Thurmond (SRD)

1968
[1] Hubert Humphrey (D)
[2] Richard Nixon (R)
[3] George Wallace (AI)

1980
[1] Jimmy Carter (D)
[2] John B. Anderson (I)
[3] Ronald Reagan (R)

1992
[1] Bill Clinton (D)
[2] Ross Perot (I)
[3] George H.W. Bush (R)

1996
[1] Bill Clinton (D)
[2] Ross Perot (RF)
[3] Bob Dole (R)

2000
[1] Al Gore (D)
[2] Ralph Nader (G)
[3] George W. Bush (R)

2016
[1] Hillary Clinton (D)
[2] Gary Johnson (L)
[3] Donald Trump (R)

[sparkey]

Since this was bumped, I'll tally again:

1824: Adams in 3 rounds. Jackson eliminated in the 1st round (2 votes to 3 for all others), Crawford and Clay eliminated together after the 2nd round (3 votes each to Adams' 5) and enough votes transfer to Adams.

1836: Van Buren in 1 round (8 votes to Webster's 2 and White's 1)

1848: Van Buren in 1 round (9 votes to Taylor's 2)

1856: Fremont unanimously (10 votes)

1860: Lincoln in 1 round (9 votes to Bell's 2)

1912: Roosevelt in 2 rounds. Wilson and Debs eliminated after 1st round (1 vote each vs. 6 for Roosevelt and 4 for Taft), and Roosevelt wins 2nd round with 6 votes to Taft's 5.

1948: TIE between Dewey and Truman in the 2nd round. Wallace, Thurmond, and Dobbs are eliminated after the 1st round (1 vote each to Dewey's 4 and Truman's 4), and Dewey and Truman tie with 5 each in the 2nd.

1996: TIE between Clinton and Harry Browne in the 2nd round. Dole, Nader, and White are eliminated after the 1st round (1 vote each to Browne's 5 and Clinton's 3), and Browne and Clinton tie with 5 each in the 2nd.

[Lexii, harbinger of chaos and sexual anarchy]

1836
Hugh Lawson White
[2] WilliamHenry_Harrison (W)
[] Daniel Webster (W)


1840
[1] James G. Birney (Liberty)
[2] WilliamHenry_Harrison (W)
[3] Martin Van Buren (D)


1844
[1] James G. Birney (Liberty)
[1] Henry Clay (W)
[3] James K. Polk (D)

1848
[1] Martin Van Buren (FS)
[2] Zachary Taylor (W)
[3] Lewis Cass (D)
1852
[1] John Hale
[2] Franklin Pierce
[3] Winfield Scott

1856
[1] John Frémont (R)
[2] Millard Fillmore (know-nothing)
[3] James Buchanan (D)

1860
[1]Abraham Lincoln (R)
[2]John Bell (Constit. Union)
[3]Stephen Douglas (D [north])
[4]John C Breckenridge (D [south])

1864
[1] Abraham Lincoln (Nat. Union)
[2] George McClellan (D)

1868
[1] Ulysses S Grant (R)
[2] Horatio Seymour (D)

1872
[1] Horace Greely (Lib. R)
[2] Ulysses S Grant (R)
[3] Charles O'Conor (D)

1876
[1]Peter Cooper (Gb)
[2]Rutheford B Hayes R)
[3] Samuel Tilden (D)

1880
[1] James Garfield (Gb)
[2] James Weaver (R)
[3] Winfield Hancock (D)

1884
[1]Grover Cleveland (D)
[2]John St. John (Prohib)
[3]Benjamin Butler (Gb)
[4]James Blaine (R)

1888
[1]Alson Streeter (Labor)
[2]Benjamin Harrison (R)
[3]Grover Cleeveland (D)
Clinton B. Fisk (Prohib)

1896
William Jennings Bryan (D)
John M. Palmer (Nat. D)
Joshua Levering (prohib)
William McKinley (R)

1900
[1] Eugene V Debs (S)
[2] William Jennings Bryan (D)
[3] William McKinley (R)
[4] Wharton Barker (Pop.)
[5] John G. Woolley (prohib)

1904
[1] Eugene V. Debs (S)
[2] Alton B. Parker (D) (?)
[3] Theodore Roosevelt (R)
[4] Silas C. Swallow (prohib)
[5] Thomas E Watson (Pop.)

1908
Eugene V Debs (S)
Thomas L. Hisgen (Independence)
William Jennings Bryan (D)
William Howard Taft (R)


1912
Theodore Roosevelt (Prog.)
Eugene V Debs (S)
Woodrow Wilson (D)
William Howard Taft (R)
Edward B Chafin (prohib.)

1916
Allan Benson (S)
Woodrow Wilson (D)
Charles Evans Hughes (R)
Frank Hanly (prohib.)

1920:
[1] Eugene V Debs (S)
[2]Parley P. Christensen (F-L)
[3]Aaron S. Watkins (prohib)
[4]James Cox (D)
[5]Warren G Harding (R)

1924
[1] Robert M. La Follette (Prog.)
[2] Calvin Coolidge (R)
[3] John W Davis (D)

1928
[1] Norman Thomas (S)
[2] Al Smith (D)
[3] Herbert Hoover (D)

1932
[1] Norman Thomas (S)
[2] Herbert Hoover (R)
[3] Franklin D Roosevelt (D)

1936
[1] Franklin D Roosevelt (D)
[2] Norman Thomas (S)
[3] Alf Landon (R)
[4] William Lenke (Union)

1940
[1] Franklin D Roosevelt (D)
[2] Wendell Willkie (R)

1944
[1] Franklin D Roosevelt (D)
[2] Thomas Dewey (R)

1948
[1] Henry Wallace (Prog.)
[2] Thomas Dewey (R)
[3] Harry Truman (D)
[4] Strom Thurmond (Dix.)

1952
[1] Adlai Stevenson (R)
[2] Dwight Eisenhower (D)

1956
[1] Adlai Stevenson (D)
[2] Dwight Eisenhower (R)

1960
[1] John F Kennedy (D)
[2] Richard Nixon (R)

1964
[1] Lyndon B Johnson (D)
[2] Barry Goldwater (R)

1968
[1] Hubert Humphrey (D)
[2] Richard Nixon (R)
[3] George Wallace (AIP)

1972
[1] George McGovern (D)
[2] Richard Nixon(R)
[3] John G. Schmitz (AIP)

1976
[1] Eugene McCarthy (I)
[2] Jimmy Carter (D)
[3] Gerald Ford (R)

1980
[1] John B. Anderson (I)
[2] Jimmy Carter (D)
[3] Ed Clark(L)
[4] Ronald Reagan (R)

1984
[1] Walter Mondale (D)
[2] Ronald Reagan (R)

1988
[1] Michael Dukakis (D)
[2] George HW Bush (R)
[3] Ron Paul (L)

1992:
[1] Bill Clinton (D)
[2] Ross Perot (Reform)
[3] George HW Bush (R)

1996:
[1]Ralph Nader (G)
[2] Bill Clinton (D)
[4] Ross Perot (Ref)
[3] Bob Dole (R)
[5] Harry Browne (L)

2000:
[1]Ralph Nader (G)
[2]Al Gore (D)
[3]Harry Browne (L)
[4]George W Bush (R)
[5]Pat Buchanan (Ref)

2004:
[1] Ralph Nader (I)
[2] John Kerry (D)
[3] Michael Badnarik (L)
[4] George W Bush (R)

2008:
[1] Barack Obama (D)
[2] Ralph Nader (I)
[3] John McCain (R)
[4] Bob Barr (L)

2012
[1] Jill Stein (G)
[2] Barack Obama (D)
[3] Gary Johnson (L)
[4] Mitt Romney (R)

[Continential]

This is how I'd vote after looking at the platforms and some of my choices are for the memes and some of them are to send a message.
Only doing the top six candidates in each election.

2020
[1] Rocky De La Fuente (Alliance)
[2] Joe Biden (Democratic)
[3] Howie Hawkins (Green)
[4] Jo Jorgensen (Libertarian)
[5] Gloria La Riva (Party of Socialism and Liberation)
[6] Donald Trump (Republican)

2016
[1] Hillary Clinton (Democratic)
[2] Gary Johnson (Libertarian)
[3] Jill Stein (Green)
[4] Evan McMullin (Independent)
[5] Donald Trump (Republican)
[6] Darrell Castle (Constitution)

2012
[1] Barack Obama (Democratic)
[2] Rocky Anderson (Independent)
[3] Jill Stein (Green)
[4] Gary Johnson (Libertarian)
[5] Mitt Romney (Republican)
[6] Virgil Goode (Constitution)

2008
[1] Ralph Nader (Independent)
[2] Barack Obama (Democratic)
[3] John McCain (Republican)
[4] Bob Barr (Libertarian)
[5] Cynthia McKinney (Green)
[6] Chuck Baldwin (Constitution)

2004
[1] Ralph Nader (Independent)
[2] John Kerry (Democratic)
[3] David Cobb (Green)
[4] Michael Badnarik (Libertarian)
[5] George W. Bush (Republican)
[6] Michael Peroutka (Constitution)

2000
[1] Ralph Nader (Green)
[2] Al Gore (Democratic)
[3] Harry Browne (Libertarian)
[4] George W. Bush (Republican)
[5] Pat Buchanan (Reform)
[6] Michael Peroutka (Constitution)
I'll do the rest later

[sparkey]

I don't remember making this thread but I would keep my rankings from 6 years ago. I guess I'm consistent.

[Unconditional Surrender Truman]

1824
[1] John Quincy Adams
[2] Andrew Jackson
[3] Henry Clay
[4] William Harris Crawford

1832
[1] William Wirt (Antimasonic)
[2] Andrew Jackson (Democratic Republican)
[3] Henry Clay (National Republican)
[4] John Floyd (State Rights)

1836
[1] Daniel Webster (Whig)
[2] Martin Van Buren (Democratic Republican)
[3] William Henry Harrison (Whig)
[4] Hugh Lawson White (State Rights)
[5] Willie Person Magnum (State Rights)

1840
[1] James Gillespie Birney (Liberty)
[2] Martin Van Buren (Democratic)
[3] William Henry Harrison (Whig)

1844
[1] James Gillespie Birney (Liberty)
[3] James Knox Polk (Democratic)
[2] Henry Clay (Whig)

1848
[1] Gerrit Smith (Liberty)
[2] Martin Van Buren (Free Soil)
[3] Zachary Taylor (Whig)
[4] Lewis Cass (Democratic)

1852
[1] John Parker Hale (Free Soil)
[2] William Goodell (Liberty)
[3] Winfield Scott (Whig)
[4] Daniel Webster (Union)
[5] Franklin Pierce (Democratic)
[6] Jacob Broom (Native American)
[7] George McIntosh Troup (Southern Rights)

1856
[1] Gerrit Smith (Liberty)
[2] John Charles Frémont (Republican)
[3] James Buchanan (Democratic)
[4] Millard Fillmore (American)

1860
[1] Abraham Lincoln (Republican)
[2] Gerrit Smith (Liberty)
[3] Stephen Arnold Douglas (Northern Democratic)
[4] John Bell (Constitutional Union)
[5] John Cabell Breckinridge (Southern Democratic)

1872
[1] Ulysses S. Grant (Republican)
[2] Horace Greeley (Liberal Republican–Democratic)
[3] James Black (Prohibition)
[4] Charles O'Connor (Straight-Out Democratic)

1876
[1] Peter Cooper (National Independent)
[2] Green Clay Smith (Prohibition)
[3] Samuel Jones Tilden (Democratic)
[4] Rutherford Birchard Hayes (Republican)

1880
[1] James Baird Weaver (Greenback Labor)
[2] Neal Dow (Prohibition)
[3] James Abram Garfield (Republican)
[4] Winfield Scott Hancock (Democratic)

1884
[1] Belva Ann Lockwood (Equal Rights)
[2] Benjamin Franklin Butler (Greenback Labor)
[3] John Pierce St. John (Prohibition)
[4] Stephen Grover Cleveland (Democratic)
[5] James Gillespie Blaine (Republican)

1888
[1] Alson Jenness Streeter (Union Labor)
[2] Benjamin Harrison (Republican)
[3] Clinton Bowen Fisk (Prohibition)
[4] Stephen Grover Cleveland (Democratic)

1892
[1] James Baird Weaver (People's)
[2] Benjamin Harrison (Republican)
[3] John Bidwell (Prohibition)
[4] Simon Wing (Socialist Labor)
[5] Stephen Grover Cleveland (Democratic)

1896
[1] William Jennings Bryan (Democratic–People's)
[2] Charles Eugene Bentley (National Prohibition)
[3] Charles Horatio Matchett (Socialist Labor)
[4] John McAuley Palmer (National Democratic)
[5] William McKinley (Republican)
[6] Joshua Levering (Prohibition)

1900
[1] Eugene Victor Debs (Socialist)
[2] William Jennings Bryan (Democratic)
[3] Wharton Baker (People's)
[4] Joseph Francis Maloney (Socialist Labor)
[5] William McKinley (Republican)
[6] John Granville Woolley (Prohibition)

1904
[1] Eugene Victor Debs (Socialist)
[2] Theodore Roosevelt (Republican)
[3] Charles Hunter Corregan (Socialist Labor)
[4] Alton Brooks Parker (Democratic)
[5] Silas Comfort Swallow (Prohibition)
[6] Thomas Edward Watson (People's)

1908
[1] Eugene Victor Debs (Socialist)
[2] William Jennings Bryan (Democratic)
[3] William Howard Taft (Republican)
[4] Thomas Louis Hisgen (Independence)
[5] August Gilhaus (Socialist Labor)
[6] Eugene Wilder Chafin (Prohibition)
[7] Thomas Edward Watson (People's)

1912
[1] Eugene Victor Debs (Socialist)
[2] Theodore Roosevelt (Progressive)
[3] Thomas Woodrow Wilson (Democratic)
[4] William Howard Taft (Republican)
[5] Arthur Elmer Reimer (Socialist Labor)
[6] Eugene Wilder Chafin (Prohibition)

1916
[1] Allan Louis Benson (Socialist)
[2] Thomas Woodrow Wilson (Democratic)
[3] Arthur Elmer Reimer (Socialist Labor)
[4] Charles Evans Hughes (Republican)
[5] James Frank Hanly (Prohibition)

1920
[1] Eugene Victor Debs (Socialist)
[2] Parley Parker Christiansen (Farmer-Labor)
[3] William Wesley Cox (Socialist Labor)
[4] James Middleton Cox (Democratic)
[5] Warren Gamaliel Harding (Republican)
[6] Aaron Sherman Watkins (Prohibition)
[7] James Edward Ferguson (American)

1924
[1] Robert Marion La Follette (Progressive)
[2] Frank Tetes Johns (Socialist Labor)
[3] John William Davis (Democratic)
[4] John Calvin Coolidge (Republican)
[5] William Z. Foster (Communist)
[6] Herman Preston Faris (Prohibition)
[7] William Gilbert Owens (American)

1928
[1] Norman Mattoon Thomas (Socialist)
[2] Alfred Emanuel Smith (Democratic)
[3] Verne L. Reynolds (Socialist Labor)
[4] Herbert Clark Hoover (Republican)
[5] William Z. Foster (Communist)
[6] William Frederick Varney (Prohibition)

1932
[1] Norman Mattoon Thomas (Socialist)
[2] Franklin Delano Roosevelt (Democratic)
[3] William Hope Harvey (Liberty)
[4] Verne L. Reynolds (Socialist Labor)
[5] William Z. Foster (Communist)
[6] William David Upshaw (Prohibition)
[7] Herbert Clark Hoover (Republican)

1936
[1] Franklin Delano Roosevelt (Democratic)
[2] Norman Mattoon Thomas (Socialist)
[3] Alfred Mossman Langdon (Republican)
[4] William Frederick Lemke (Union)
[5] David Leigh Colvin (Prohibition)
[6] Earl Russell Browder (Communist)

1940
[1] Franklin Delano Roosevelt (Democratic)
[2] Norman Mattoon Thomas (Socialist)
[3] Wendell Lewis Willkie (Republican)
[4] Roger Ward Babson (Prohibition)
[5] Earl Russell Browder (Communist)

1944
[1] Franklin Delano Roosevelt (Democratic)
[2] Norman Mattoon Thomas (Socialist)
[3] Thomas Edmund Dewey (Republican)
[4] Edward A. Teichert (Socialist Labor)
[5] Claude A. Watson (Prohibition)

1948
[1] Harry S. Truman (Democratic)
[2] Norman Mattoon Thomas (Socialist)
[3] Thomas Edmund Dewey (Republican)
[4] Henry Agard Wallace (Progressive)
[5] Edward A. Teichert (Socialist Labor)
[6] Claude A. Watson (Prohibition)
[7] James Strom Thurmond (States' Rights Democratic)

1952
[1] Adlai Ewing Stevenson (Democratic)
[2] Dwight David Eisenhower (Republican)
[3] Vincent Hallinan (Progressive)
[4] Eric Hass (Socialist Labour)
[5] Stuart Hamblen (Prohibition)

1956
[1] Adlai Ewing Stevenson (Democratic)
[2] Dwight David Eisenhower (Republican)
[3] Eric Hass (Socialist Labour)
[4] Enoch Arden Holtwick (Prohibition)
[5] Thomas Coleman Andrews (States' Rights–Constitution)

1960
[1] John Fitzgerald Kennedy (Democratic)
[2] Eric Hass (Socialist Labor)
[3] Farrell Dobbs (Socialist Workers')
[4] Richard Milhous Nixon (Republican)
[5] Rutherford Losey Decker (Prohibition)
[6] Write-in: Harry Flood Byrd (States' Rights Democratic)
[7] Orval Eugene Faubus (National States' Rights)

1964
[1] Lyndon Baines Johnson (Democratic)
[2] Eric Hass (Socialist Labor)
[3] Clifton DeBerry (Socialist Workers')
[4] Barry Morris Goldwater (Republican)

1968
[1] Hubert Horatio Humphrey (Democratic)
[2] Fred W. Halstead (Socialist Workers')
[3] Richard Claxton Gregory (Freedom & Peace)
[4] Henning A. Blomen (Socialist Labor)
[5] Eldridge Cleaver (Peace & Freedom)
[6] Richard Milhous Nixon (Republican)
[7] George Corley Wallace (American Independent)

1972
[1] George Sidney McGovern (Democratic)
[2] Benjamin McLane Spock (People's)
[3] Linda Jenness (Socialist Workers')
[4] Louis Fisher (Socialist Labor)
[5] Richard Milhous Nixon (Republican)
[6] John George Schmitz (American Independent)

1976
[1] Margaret Wright (People's)
[2] James Earl Carter (Democratic)
[3] Gerald Rudolph Ford (Republican)
[4] Peter Miguel Camejo (Socialist Workers')
[5] Eugene Joseph McCarthy (Independent)
[6] Roger Lea MacBride (Libertarian)
[7] Gus Hall (Communist)
[8] Lyndon Hermyle LaRouche (Labor)
[9] Thomas Jefferson Anderson (American)
[10] Lester Garfield Maddox (American Independent)

1980
[1] Barry Commoner (Citizens')
[2] John Bayard Anderson (Independent)
[3] James Earl Carter (Democratic)
[4] Edward E. Clark (Libertarian)
[5] Gus Hall (Communist)
[6] Ronald Wilson Reagan (Republican)
[7] John Richard Rarick (American Independent)

1984
[1] Walter Frederick Mondale (Democratic)
[2] Sonia Ann Johnson (Citizens')
[3] Dennis L. Serrette (New Alliance)
[4] David Bergland (Libertarian)
[5] Ronald Wilson Reagan (Republican)
[6] Lyndon Hermyle LaRouche (Independent)
[7] Robert Eugene Richards (Populist)

1988
[1] Michael Stanley Dukakis (Democratic)
[2] Lenora Branch Fulani (New Alliance)
[3] George Herbert Walker Bush (Republican)
[4] Ronald Ernest Paul (Libertarian)
[5] David Ernest Duke (Populist)

1992
[1] William Jefferson Clinton (Democratic)
[2] Lenora Branch Fulani (New Alliance)
[3] Henry Ross Perot (Independent)
[4] George Herbert Walker Bush (Republican)
[5] Andre Verne Marrou (Libertarian)
[6] James Gordon Gritz (Populist)

1996
[1] Ralph Nader (Green)
[2] William Jefferson Clinton (Democratic)
[3] Henry Ross Perot (Reform)
[4] Robert Joseph Dole (Republican)
[5] Harry Edson Browne (Libertarian)
[6] John Samuel Hagelin (Natural Law)
[7] Howard Jay Phillips (Taxpayers')

2000
[1] Ralph Nader (Green)
[2] Albert Arnold Gore (Democratic)
[3] George Walker Bush (Republican)
[4] Harry Edson Browne (Libertarian)
[5] Patrick Joseph Buchanan (Reform)
[6] John Samuel Hagelin (Natural Law)
[7] Howard Jay Phillips (Constitution)

2004
[1] Ralph Nader (Independent)
[2] John Forbes Kerry (Democratic)
[3] David Keith Cobb (Green)
[4] Michael J. Badnarick (Libertarian)
[5] George Walker Bush (Republican)
[6] Michael Anthony Peroutka (Constitution)

2008
[1] Barack Hussein Obama (Democratic)
[2] Ralph Nader (Independent)
[3] John Sidney McCain (Republican)
[4] Cynthia Ann McKinney (Green)
[5] Robert Laurence Barr (Libertarian)
[6] Charles Obadiah Baldwin (Constitution)

2012
[1] Barack Hussein Obama (Democratic)
[2] Gary Earl Johnson (Libertarian)
[3] Jill Ellen Stein (Green)
[4] Willard Mitt Romney (Republican)
[5] Roseanne Cherrie Barr (Peace & Freedom)
[6] Virgil Hamlin Goode (Constitution)

2016
[1] Hillary Rodham Clinton (Democratic)
[2] Gary Earl Johnson (Libertarian)
[3] Jill Ellen Stein (Green)
[4] David Evan McMullin (Independent)
[5] Gloria Estella La Riva (Party of Socialism and Liberation)
[6] Darrell L. Castle (Constitution)
[7] Donald John Trump (Republican)

2020
[1] Joseph Robinette Biden (Democratic)
[2] Howard Gresham Hawkins (Green)
[3] Roque De La Fuente (Alliance)
[4] Gloria Estella La Riva (Party of Socialism and Liberation)
[5] Jo Jorgensen (Libertarian)
[6] Donald John Trump (Republican)

[beaver2.0]

I stole Ishan's post and rearranged it.

2020
[1] Howie Hawkins (Green)
[2] Joe Biden (Democratic)
[3] Rocky De La Fuente (Alliance)
[4] Gloria La Riva (Party of Socialism and Liberation)
[5] Donald Trump (Republican)
[6] Jo Jorgensen (Libertarian)

2016
[1] Evan McMullin (Independent)
[2] Hillary Clinton (Democratic)
[3] Gary Johnson (Libertarian)
[4] Jill Stein (Green)
[5] Donald Trump (Republican)
[6] Darrell Castle (Constitution)

2012
[1] Rocky Anderson (Independent)
[2] Barack Obama (Democratic)
[3] Virgil Goode (Constitution)
[4] Mitt Romney (Republican)
[5] Gary Johnson (Libertarian)
[6] Jill Stein (Green)

2008
[1] Barack Obama (Democratic)
[1] Ralph Nader (Independent)
[3] John McCain (Republican)
[4] Bob Barr (Libertarian)
[5] Cynthia McKinney (Green)
[6] Chuck Baldwin (Constitution)

2004
[1] John Kerry (Democratic)
[2] Ralph Nader (Independent)
[3] David Cobb (Green)
[4] George W. Bush (Republican)
[5] Michael Badnarik (Libertarian)
[6] Michael Peroutka (Constitution)

2000
[1] Al Gore (Democratic)
[2] Ralph Nader (Green)
[3] Pat Buchanan (Reform)
[4] George W. Bush (Republican)
[5] Harry Browne (Libertarian)
[6] Michael Peroutka (Constitution)

[Make America Grumpy Again]

While I wouldn't vote for a third party normally (main exceptions are Perot and possibly Teddy Roosevelt/Nader), I included them since it wouldn't matter with RCV. These are without hindsight too.

1824
1. Jackson
2. Clay
3. Crawford
4. Adams

1836
1. Van Buren
(wouldn't have cared too much about the order of Whigs)

1848
1. Van Buren
2. Smith
3. Cass
4. Taylor

1856
1. Buchanan
2. Fillmore
3. Frémont

1860
1. Lincoln
2. Douglas
3. Bell
4. Breckinridge

1912
1. Roosevelt
2. Wilson
3. Taft
4. Debs

1948
1. Wallace
2. Dewey
3. Truman

1996
1. Perot
2. Nader
3. Phillips
4. Dole
5. Clinton
6. Browne
7. Hagelin

Might make another post with other elections at some point.

[Make America Grumpy Again]

While I'd probably vote for third parties that gained steam in real life (Perot is a notable example), I'd be far more inclined to vote for them in a IRV system than in the current winner-take all system.

1824
1. Unpledged Electors
2. Adams

1828:
1. Jackson
2. Adams

1832:
1. Jackson
2. Wirt
3. Clay

1836
1. Van Buren
(wouldn't have cared too much about the order of Whigs)

1840:
1. Van Buren
2. Harrison

1844:
1. Birney
2. Polk
3. Clay

1848
1. Van Buren
2. Cass
3. Taylor

1852:
1. Hale
2. Pierce
3. Scott

1856
1. Fillmore
2. Buchanan
3. Frémont

1860
1. Bell
2. Douglas
3. Lincoln
4. Breckinridge

1864:
1. McClellan
2. Lincoln

1868:
1. Seymour
2. Grant

1872:
1. Greeley
2. Grant

1876:
1. Tilden
2. Hayes

1880:
1. Weaver
2. Dow
3. Hancock
4. Garfield

1884:
1. Butler
2. St. John
3. Blaine
4. Cleveland

1888:
1. Cleveland
2. Fisk
3. Harrison

1892:
1. Weaver
2. Wing
3. Birdwell
4. Cleveland
5. Harrison

1896:
1. Bryan
2. Matchett
3. Levering
4. McKinley
5. Palmer

1900:
1. Bryan
2. Debs
3. Woolley
4. Malloney
5. McKinley

1904:
1. Watson
2. Roosevelt
3. Parker
4. Swallow
5. Debs
6. Corregon

1908:
1. Hisgen
2. Bryan
3. Taft
4. Chafin
5. Debs
6. Gillhaus

1912
1. Roosevelt
2. Wilson
3. Taft
4. Debs

1916:
1. Wilson
2. Hughes
3. Hanly
4. Benson
5. Reimer

1920:
1. Harding
2. Convict #9653
3. James M. Cox
4. William W. Cox

1924:
1. LaFollette
2. Coolidge
3. Davis
4. Johns
5. Foster

1928:
1. Hoover
2. Smith
3. Thomas
4. Reynolds
5. Foster

1932:
1. FDR
2. Hoover
3. Thomas
4. Reynolds
5. Upshaw
6. Foster

1936:
1. Lemke
2. FDR
3. Landon
4. Colvin
5. Thomas
6. Aiken
7. Browder

1940:
1. Roosevelt
2. Wilkie
3. Thomas
4. Babson
5. Aiken
6. Browder

1944:
1. Roosevelt
2. Dewey
3. Watson
4. Teichert

1948
1. Wallace
2. Dewey
3. Truman
4. Watson
5. Teichert

1952:
1. Eisenhower
2. Stevenson
3. Hamblen
4. Hallinan
5. Hass

1956:
1. Eisenhower
2. Stevenson
3. Holtwick
4. Hass

1960:
1. Kennedy
2. Nixon
3. Decker
4. Hass

1964:
1. Johnson
2. Goldwater
3. Hass

1968:
1. Nixon
2. Wallace
3. Humphrey
4. Munn
5. Blomen

1972:
1. Nixon
2. McGovern
3. Jenness

1976:
1. Carter
2. McCarthy
3. Ford
4. LaRouche
5. Anderson
6. Camejo

1980:
1. Carter
2. Anderson
3. Reagan
4. Clark
5. DeBerry

1984:
1. Mondale
2. Reagan
3. Serrette

1988:
1. Dukakis
2. Paul
3. Bush
4. Fulani

1992:
1. Perot
2. Clinton
3. Bush
4. Phillips
5. Marrou
6. LaRouche
7. Fulani
8. Hagelin

1996
1. Perot
2. Phillips
3. Dole
4. Clinton
5. Browne
6. Hagelin
7. Moorehead

2000:
1. Nader
2. Buchanan
3. Gore
4. Bush
5. Browne
6. Hagelin

2004:
1. Kerry
2. Bush
3. Cobb
4. Badnerik

2008:
1. Obama
2. McKinney
3. Nader
4. Baldwin
5. Barr
6. McCain

2012:
1. Obama
2. Johnson
3. Stein
4. Romney

2016:
1. Johnson
2. Trump
3. Clinton
4. Stein

2020:
1. Trump
2.  Jorgenson
3. Hawkins
4. Biden