Neither of those are really correct, though 1996 is better than 1972.
Both Conservative would be 1924, if just considering the two major party candidates
Both Liberal would be 1936.
Didnt Clinton Run on Welfare Reform, Lowering Taxes, and Cutting Spending or was that 1992
Clinton 1996 was a pretty right-wing campaign. His top adviser, Dick Morris told him he had to go totally 3rd way to win. Because Dick Morris is so great at predicting elections that he had Arkansas as safe Obama in 2008.
At least he did get the Romney winning by 325 electoral votes thing right though.