Bill O'Reilly v. George Will; Who won?

[Torie]

Here's the slugfest. Enjoy.

[Lyin' Steve]

I clicked the wrong button... meant to click George Will.
O'Reilly made an absolute idiot of himself by claiming that he wouldn't talk to any primary sources because "they have skin in the game."  Would he have interviewed Reagan if Reagan was still alive?

[Torie]

I clicked the wrong button... meant to click George Will.
O'Reilly made an absolute idiot of himself by claiming that he wouldn't talk to any primary sources because "they have skin in the game."  Would he have interviewed Reagan if Reagan was still alive?

I think you can change your vote if you wish.

[Iosif]

Who cares? Two tools stepping on each others toes.

[Joe Republic]

I wasn't aware that either of these two old farts were still relevant.

[Crumpets]

George Will might be terrible at analysis and predictions, but he knows DC inside and out, and I trust him a lot more on issues like this than O'Reilly. That being said, I imagine the Fox News crowd probably watched that and thought O'Reilly won, so I voted for a tie overall.

[tpfkaw]

George Will might be terrible at analysis and predictions, but he knows DC inside and out, and I trust him a lot more on issues like this than O'Reilly. That being said, I imagine the Fox News crowd probably watched that and thought O'Reilly won, so I voted for a tie overall.

Although what they're arguing over is O'Reilly's claim that Reagan was brain-damaged after the 1981 assassination attempt to the point of being incapable to continue as president. So that probably gives Will a pretty big boost with the Fox News crowd.