Election Results in different voting systems

[CheeseWhiz]

Thought this would be fun:

FPTP

KeystonePhil/MHS2002: 23 – 24.15%
Harry/Ebowed. 19 – 19.95%
Siege40/Emsworth: 18 – 18.90%
King/Dibble: 16 – 16.80%
Supersoulty/WMS: 15 – 15.75%
JFK/Ernest: 14 – 14.70%

KeystonePhil/MHS2002 wins


FPTP with run-off

Run-off between Phil and Harry:

KeystonePhil/MHS2002: 40
Harry/Ebowed. 61

Those who didn’t give either a preference:
CheeseWhiz (Votes for KeystonePhil)
George W. Bush
John Dibble
A18
KucinichforPrez
Banana Republic
opebo
MAS117
TN2024
Ernest (although he gave them both preferences, his ballot seemed to be a joke and I’m not sure if he’d joke in a two way race.)
Peter Bell

Harry wins.

Note: I counted Kodratos & skybridge’s ballots because I figured they’d vote again.
Note: if the above will specify who they would vote for I’ll add them to the vote tally.
Note: something seems wrong, the vote tally is off.  If you figure out the problem, please tell me.

Condorcet

Can’t really count Condorcet, so if someone wants to do this for me, then be my guest.

I know, it’s not very good, but if someone would like to fix it up, you're more than welcome to.

[minionofmidas]

One note:
The fptp result is actually
Keystone/MHS 21
Harry/Ebowed 17
Siege/Emsworth 17
Soulty/WMS 15
King/Dibble 12
JFK/Ernest 11
PD/Migrendel 2
Bono/Philip 1
Dibble/MHS 1
Jesus/Ernest 1
Jesus/ILV 1
Jesus/Tassadar 1
MHS/Philip 1
Ebowed/Dibble 1
Ebowed/Harry 1
Siege/Lewis 1 (thanks Jens )
Nym's Molasses Cookies/Nym's Peanut Butter Cookies 1
Not that it affects the results.

[I spent the winter writing songs about getting better]

I think Brandon or someone linked to a Condorcet calculator somewhere, so we can use that, except it'd take forever to enter all the pages.

However I did do the first page. If we split the pages up we can get teh whole results. I don't know the link now but it's on here somewhere. Here's the first page of voting:

1:KP>H
1:S>JFK>K>KP>S40>H
1:S40>S>JFK>KP>H>K
1:K>JFK>S>KP>S40>H
1:S>JFK>S40>KP
1:KP>K>S>JFK
1:KP>S>H>K>S40>JFK
1:H>S40>KP>JFK>S>K
1:K>S>S40>H>KP
1:JFK>S40>S>K>KP
1:K>JFK>S40>S
1:S
1:JFK>K>H>S40>S>KP
1:S>JFK>K>H>S40>KP

key should be fairly obvious but anyway:

S = Supersoulty
H = Harry
K = King
KP = Keystone Phil
S40 = Seige40
JFK = John F Kennedy

I excluded write-ins.

[I spent the winter writing songs about getting better]

here it is:

http://www.ericgorr.net/condorcet/

[I spent the winter writing songs about getting better]

alright, here's the 2nd page:

1:S>K>H>KP>S40>JFK
1:S>JFK>S40>K>H>KP
1:H>KP
1:KP>K>H
1:KP>S>K>JFK
1:H>S40>K>KP
1:JFK>S40>H>K>S>KP
2:JFK>H>S40>S>K>KP
1:JFK>S>K>S40>H>KP
1:K>H>KP>JFK>S>S40
1:H>S>JFK>S40>K>KP
1:K
1:H>S40>K>JFK>S
1:JFK>S>H>S40>K>KP

[I spent the winter writing songs about getting better]

here's the valid absentees

1:H>S40>K>JFK
1:H>S40>K>JFK>S>KP
1:H>S>JFK>S40>K>KP
1:S40>H>JFK>K>S>KP

[Brandon H]

I'm defintely going to work on this, though it won't happen over night. Hard to find time now with a full time job where they actually monitor network traffic.

[I spent the winter writing songs about getting better]

page 3:

1:S40>S>JFK>K>KP>H
1:S40>H>KP>K
1:S40>H>K>JFK>S>KP
1:KP>S>K
2:K
1:K>JFK>S40>KP>S>H
1:KP>S40>JFK>K>S>H
1:S40>H>JFK>K
1:KP>S>JFK>K>H>S40
1:K>JFK>S>H
1:JFK>S40>H>S>KP>K
1:S40>H>S>JFK>K>KP
1:H>S40>K>KP
1:S40>JFK>K>KP>S>H

[I spent the winter writing songs about getting better]

page 4:


1:S>JFK>S40>KP>H>K
1:S40>H>K>S>JFK
1:KP>S
1:KP>JFK>S40>S>H
1:S>KP>S40>H>K>JFK
1:S40
1:JFK>S>K>S40>H>KP
1:KP
1:K>JFK>S>H>S40>KP
1:H>S40>K>JFK
1:S>H>KP>K
1:K>H>KP>S>S40
1:KP>JFK>K>S>H>S40

[I spent the winter writing songs about getting better]

page 5:



1:KP>K>JFK
1:JFK>K>S40>KP>S>H
1:H>S40>JFK>S
1:KP>H>K>S
1:S40
1:H>K>S40>JFK
1:H>K>JFK
1:KP>K>H>S
1:K>H
1:S>H>K
1:H>KP>S40>JFK>K>S
1:S40>S
1:S40>H>JFK>K
1:H>S40>K>S>KP>JFK

[I spent the winter writing songs about getting better]

page 6:

1:H
1:S>KP>K
1:JFK>KP>H>S
1:KP>H
1:S40>H
1:H>S40
1:JFK>S40>K>S>H>KP
1:KP>H
1:KP>K>S>H>S40>JFK
1:KP>S>K>H
1:K>S>S40>H>JFK>KP
1:S40>H>JFK>K
1:H>S>KP>JFK>K>S40>JFK
1:KP>K
1:KP

[I spent the winter writing songs about getting better]

page 7:


1:JFK>K>S40>KP>H>S
1:S40>H>S>JFK>K
1:KP>S>JFK>K>H>S40
1:S>S40>KP>H>JFK>K
1:S>S40>H>K>JFK
1:JFK>K>H>S40>S
1:S40>JFK>H>S>K
1:K>KP>JFK>S
1:H>S40
1:S
1:KP>JFK>S>K>S40>H
1:S40>K>S>KP

[I spent the winter writing songs about getting better]

and finally page 8:

1:S>K>JFK>KP>H
1:K>S40
1:K>S40>H>JFK>S>KP

I thought it was kind of ironic that MHS put the ticket he was on 4th, although after Phil's behavior not suprising.

Results up soon.

[I spent the winter writing songs about getting better]

According to the calculator, Harry would've won under any Condorcet method. Seige also would've won had we used any other IRV method.

[Peter]

According to the calculator, Harry would've won under any Condorcet method. Seige also would've won had we used any other IRV method.

Its giving me the winner as King under the Condorcet methods.

[King]

According to the calculator, Harry would've won under any Condorcet method. Seige also would've won had we used any other IRV method.

Its giving me the winner as King under the Condorcet methods.

Ooo, lets move to condorcet. just kidding.

[7,052,770]

According to the calculator, Harry would've won under any Condorcet method. Seige also would've won had we used any other IRV method.

All the more reason to show that condorcet is the best

[minionofmidas]

Going by Dakota's figures...
Siege beats Phil, 56-38, beats King, 50-44, beats Soulty, 47-43, beats JFK, 43-39, beats Harry, 46-45.
King loses to Siege, 44-50, Harry, 47-50, beats JFK, 47-42, beats Soulty 50-43, beats Phil, 58-37.
Harry loses to Siege, 45-46, loses to Soulty, 47-48, beats King, 50-47, beats JFK, 50-39, beats Phil, 54-43.
Soulty loses to King, 43-50, loses to Siege, 43-47, loses to JFK, 40-43, beats Harry, 48-47, beats Phil, 50-37.
JFK loses to Harry, 39-50, loses to King, 42-47, loses to Siege, 39-43, beats Soulty, 43-40, beats Phil, 49-41.
Phil loses to JFK, 41-49, loses to Soulty, 37-50, loses to Harry, 43-54, loses to Siege, 38-56, loses to King, 37-58.
Siege wins under Condorcet as well.

[○∙◄☻¥tπ[╪AV┼cVê└]

Siege beats King, 50-44

I think there's a mistake there.

[minionofmidas]

Siege beats King, 50-44

I think there's a mistake there.

Counted just that one again...this time I got it at 48-46, but still for Siege.