The Hillary of 2008 vs. Trump

[Mr. Smith]

She woulda' won by the exact number of EVs suspected back in August when she had double digits.

[Mr. Smith]

And to directly answer the question, Hillary 2008 stuck in cryofreeze for 8 years would have won simply due to not having the email scandal and benghazi.  it was a razor-thin election, after all.

While this is true, let's face it, Hillary 2008 was less complacent, and I highly doubt she would've been so against McCain.