County or Precincts where Trump or Clinton finished in third place

[RBH]

Clinton finished in 3rd in:

6 Idaho and 14 Utah Counties (behind McMullin)

Mohave County AZ Precinct 5 - North Canyon (Colorado City, AZ): Trump 781, Johnson 96, Clinton 26 (Same precinct gave more votes to Green Party candidate Gary Swing than Ann Kirkpatrick)

Trump finished 3rd in:

Chicago Ward 6/Precinct 2 (Clinton 489, Stein 7, Johnson 4, Trump 3)
Chicago Ward 6/Precinct 26 (Clinton 443, Johnson 6, Stein 6, Trump 3) - Stein finished ahead of Trump in 6 other Ward 6 precincts and Johnson in another Ward 6 precinct
Madison WI Ward 42 (Clinton 2257, Stein 74, Trump 57)

Probably a lot more in a mix of majority LDS areas and ultra-Dem urban areas/college campuses.

[RBH]

and there's a strong possibility that write-ins for Sanders beat Trump in those precincts.

Looking at Idaho results. Clinton finished 4th in one Madison County (Rexburg) precinct (Porter Park). Trump 201/McMullin 176/Johnson 30/Clinton 25.

Johnson finished ahead of Clinton in 3 other Idaho precincts. In one of those precincts Clinton got 0 votes and Darrell Castle got one vote.

[RBH]

Fremont WA/Amherst MA/Cambridge MA. In all of these I suspect we'll find place where trump finished 3rdmm3rd

Amherst, precinct 9: Clinton 1382, Stein 91, Trump 79, Johnson 48

http://www.amherstma.gov/DocumentCenter/View/36679

Cambridge, ward 2/precinct 2: Clinton 433, Johnson 27, Trump 19, Stein 10, McMullin (write-in) 10

Cambridge, ward 8/precinct 3: Clinton 426, Johnson 15, Trump 11, Stein 6

https://www.cambridgema.gov/~/media/76C861E82C3E47898930ABDF09792DB0.ashx

[RBH]

Ithaca 5-2: Clinton 613, Stein 44, Trump 38, Johnson 11

http://tompkinscountyny.gov/files/boe/Additional_Information/Past_Results_files/2016/General_Election/Results_per_ED_2016_11_08T23_17_43_To%20HTML.HTML

Sioux County ND (Standing Rock):

Cannonball: CLINTON 138, STEIN 33, TRUMP 18
FY East: CLINTON 261, STEIN 35, TRUMP 23
FY West:  CLINTON 235, STEIN 36, TRUMP 27

Oglala Lakota County SD (formerly Shannon), Manderson precinct: Clinton 157, Johnson 10, Trump 7, Castle 5.

[RBH]

Carbon County is a Coal County that has one of the lower LDS adherence rates in the state of Utah

Piute County was one of Trump's better counties in the Caucuses. It's also the second smallest county in the state.

As for third place finishes

NYC AD 70/ED 4 (Keith Wright/Inez Dickens, Harlem-area): Clinton 640, Stein 16, Trump 8, Johnson 4

And in the entirety of AD 56 (Bed-Stuy, Annette Robinson), Trump won 877 votes on the unofficial count and Stein won 814.

Looking at the NYC results map, ED 4 in AD 70 is located in-between Adam Clayton Powell Blvd and Lenox from 112th to 114th. St. Nicholas Ave is also part of the border of the precinct/election district. Google Maps says there is a Vegan restaurant in the election district.

[RBH]

Combing through Salt Lake County precinct results

Out of 829 precincts.. McMullin finished ahead of Clinton in 118 precincts and ahead of Trump in 26 precincts.

McMullin won 9 precincts, mostly very small precincts. He did carry SJD030 in South Jordan (McMullin 390, Trump 350, Clinton 326)

Trump finished third in several large Salt Lake City precincts..

SLC030: Clinton 516, McMullin 59, Trump 53
SLC040: Clinton 315, McMullin 54, Trump 52
SLC080: Clinton 497, McMullin 329, Trump 192
SLC109: Clinton 574, McMullin 69, Trump 63
SLC117: Clinton 422, McMullin 86, Trump 67
SLC129: Clinton 361, McMullin 94, Trump 67
SLC130: Clinton 423, McMullin 132, Trump 130
SLC131: Clinton 387, McMullin 93, Trump 89
SLC132: Clinton 487, McMullin 142, Trump 139
SLC158: Clinton 301, McMullin 84, Trump 71

Clinton won the SLC precincts by a 66/16 margin (50832-12567). Trump carried the rest of the county by 465 votes (125476-125011).

McMullin finished 2nd and Clinton finished 3rd in several large precincts in Bluffdale, Draper, Herriman, Riverton, South Jordan and West Jordan. All communities south of Salt Lake City around Interstate 15.

Herriman had one small precinct where McMullin topped 40% (and lost) which was one of McMullin's best precincts and Clinton's worst precincts, and one small precinct where Johnson topped 11% (and Clinton won with 38%).

[RBH]

Castle was the first listed name on the ballots in Alaska. But that seems like way too much support for just being listed first.

The precincts in 38/39 were Yupik areas, and Kobuk/Point Lay are Inupiaq. Hughes is Athabascan.

[RBH]

Trump finished third in PR06. McMullin 167, Clinton 135, Trump 109.

Looking at the map and JusticeMap, there is a large block that has 400+ people and is 70%+ Hispanic that probably boosted Clinton's numbers enough to get her in second place there.

McMullin got around 50% in the Provo precincts around the BYU Campus.

[RBH]

some third place precinct finishes I found in New Mexico

Johnson finished ahead of Trump in quite a few precincts. Seemingly a lot of reservation/pueblo precincts.

Trump finished 4th in Precinct 6 in Santa Fe County (Clinton 100, Johnson 17, Stein 7, Trump 3)

Evan McMullin's best county was Los Alamos County, and he finished in the 4% range in a few Los Alamos precincts

[RBH]

The result of Kiryas Joel, NY (the electorally notorious Hasidic community in Orange County, NY) produced a result where Trump and Clinton lost to blank ballots (undervotes).

The Results from KJ (Monroe 20 thru 35): Trump 1596, Clinton 1263, Johnson 247, Stein 21. Undervotes 3023.

The KJ voters did feel more inclined to vote on the Karl Brabinec (R) vs Aron Wieder (D) State Assembly race.

Wieder won KJ by a 4633-1497 margin with just 86 undervotes. Most of the KJ votes for Wieder came on the Independence Party line. LJ residents also voted on the Independence Party line in droves for Chuck Schumer and Sean Patrick Maloney (with a good number of undervotes anyways).

IIRC, there were a bunch of intentional-ish undervotes from Kiryas Joel in 2008 and 2012 as well. Like "a majority of undervotes in the county from a village with 10,000 voters" level of undervotes in those years too.

[RBH]

i'd guess that the precinct voted at a polling place with other precincts, but was counted separately

[RBH]

Continuing the "Undervotes defeating the candidates" theme from Kiryas Joel.

Here's the results from Kaser, NY. A Hasidic village in Rockland County, NY.

Trump 630, Clinton 67, Johnson 15, Stein 8. Undervotes 640.

The other Hasidic villages didn't have as much of a strong showing for Undervotes.

Monsey: Trump 5088, Clinton 1255, Johnson 101, Stein 31. Undervotes 899
New Square: Clinton 2455, Trump 121, Johnson 4, Stein 0. Undervotes 46

New Square differed from other Hasidic villages due to the Clinton's strong relationship with local leaders. Meaning that Bill Clinton commuted the sentences of men from New Square and they've been very favorable to Hillary since 2000.

Ramapo 35 (in Kaser) had undervotes for President on half of the ballots (272 undervotes on 543 ballots). Ramapo 97 (also in Kaser) had undervotes for President on 46% of ballots (358 undervotes on 784 ballots).

So, half (1539) of Rockland County's 2865 undervotes came from Kaser or Monsey. Congrats!

As for one of the two major candidates finishing behind a third party candidate...

Jill Stein finished ahead of Donald Trump in the North Bernal Heights neighborhood of San Francisco.

North Bernal Heights: Hillary 7036, Stein 285, Trump 275

Other SF Neighborhoods that had a close Trump/Stein margin

Haight Ashbury: Clinton 12039, Trump 403, Stein 373

Upper Market/Eureka Valley: Clinton 15901, Trump 522, Stein 373.

So there's some SF precincts where Trump finished 4th. Just SF Things.