grade the quality of the preceding atlasian's postings...

[WalterMitty]

using a scholastic scale (a-f)

consider everythng from information contained to entertainment value to arrive at a score.

[I spent the winter writing songs about getting better]

B

[adam]

B+

[TeePee4Prez]

Incomplete-  Need to be more familiar with.

[bullmoose88]

Solid B.

Usually interesting, if nothing more.

[Jake]

C

Nothing especially flashy or informative.

[TeePee4Prez]

B+.  Sometimes off the wall things are said by his posts and signature, but always backs up what he says well and is informative.   

[Nym90]

B+, but don't feel bad, I'm a tough grader.

[© tweed]

A-

[Gabu]

Freedom fighter.

I mean B+.

[riceowl]

gotta say A

[J. J.]

I'll go with a B+.  Usually, it's reactive, but still fun to read.

[adam]

B+, generally entertaining

[Jake]

I agree with Flyers, but so far, you get a C.

[Nation]

B --- a lot of quality postings, but a few off the wall moments where I can't tell if he's being facetious or not.

[John Dibble]

A-

[Gabu]

A.

A solid poster with a very good head on his shoulders, regardless of how I may disagree with his stances.

[Jake]

B+, which is the best I'm giving anyone except a handful of the best.

[nclib]

B-

[WalterMitty]

b.

[Jake]

A

Behind dazzleman, the best poster here.

[Keystone Phil]

B+

He says some off-the-wall stuff but he is a very smart guy.

[WalterMitty]

b+

he is certainly informative and is a true believer.

however, i wish hed use hyperbole from time to time.

[Keystone Phil]

A

Walter has some...how can I put this...interestingly diverse views that often annoy me but whenever I see a topic written in all lower case, I rush to see what it's about. He is very interesting and very informed. He is totally unpredictable and easily one of my favorite members, something I wouldn't have said awhile ago. I can't say that he's the most massive "freedom fighter" or that I'd vote for him but he has certainly gained my respect and that is something that can be quite difficult to achieve.


Note to the next poster - Feel free to skip over me and grade Walter if you'd like.

[TeePee4Prez]

A-.  One of the most insightful posters here with in-depth political knowledge and analysis.  However, there are times he can be abrasive and obsessive and not very respectful of opposing positions and lifestyles.  When members of your own party critcize you for being belligerent, one has to question which is why the A- instead of an A.

Note: You're not getting off the hook Phil!