left wing extremists vs. right wing extremists

[There Are Some Remedies Worse Than The Disease]

let's see, left wing extremists:

me
migrendel
Texasgurl
freedomburns
nclib
Siege
bandit73
Lewis Trondheim

8

right wing extremists:

Justin
StevenNick
StatesRights
supersoulty
AuH2O
Brambila
Josh22
NixonNow
Liberty
Keystone Phil
jcmfst
ijohn57s

12

I guess there's more right wing extremists.

[Keystone Phil]

I'm not a right wing extremist. I have no extreme views. But since you think I am "extreme" tell me some of these extreme views I hold.

[There Are Some Remedies Worse Than The Disease]

you're a big fan of Rick Santorum, a right wing extremist, and you supported right wing extremist Pat Toomey over moderate Arlen Specter.

[Keystone Phil]

you're a big fan of Rick Santorum, a right wing extremist, and you supported right wing extremist Pat Toomey over moderate Arlen Specter.

Santorum and Toomey are not extremists, in my opinion. And if that were so I guess that 53% of Pennsylvanians are right wing extremists since thats the amount that re-elected Santorum in 2000 and 53% approval of his job as Senator.

And I guess if someone is more conservative than a liberal like Specter, that makes them extreme? Please. 49% of Pennsylvania Republicans that voted for Toomey are extreme?

So BRTD, what views do I hold that are extreme? I mean if you think I'm that far right, you must have some proof of this, right? I think you should just give up on this argument of trying to prove that I am an extremist. Others have tried at it and failed. But if you want to continue...go ahead. Find for me an extremist view that I hold.

[Bandit3 the Worker]

There's no such thing as a left-wing extremist.

[The Duke]

I don't think Soulty is an extremist.

I also think NixonNow is not an extremist, although he is exceedingly partisan.  He is htmldon without the brains and class.

[There Are Some Remedies Worse Than The Disease]

You're an admitted extremist Phil, look at your signature. You are extreme fiscally and socially. Who are some examples of true right wing extremists then?

Look at this way, name some specific views of mine that make me a left wing extremist. Well basically ever view of mine is the ideological mirror of your's.

supersoulty is an extremist because of his support of Santorum and Toomey as well, although you have a point about NixonNow. I was thinking of his political compass.

[MarkDel]

let's see, left wing extremists:

me
migrendel
Texasgurl
freedomburns
nclib
Siege
bandit73
Lewis Trondheim

8

right wing extremists:

Justin
StevenNick
StatesRights
supersoulty
AuH2O
Brambila
Josh22
NixonNow
Liberty
Keystone Phil
jcmfst
ijohn57s

12

I guess there's more right wing extremists.

BetterRed,

On the Left Wing side, you forgot Nomorelies, Shira, Wakie, Alfie...just to name a few. Also, Supersoulty an extremist? What world are you living in? Also, StevenNick, StatesRights, ijohn57s, Keystone Phil...none of them are extremists for sure, plus many of the other Right Wingers you cited are not extremists.

[Keystone Phil]

You're an admitted extremist Phil, look at your signature. You are extreme fiscally and socially. Who are some examples of true right wing extremists then?

Right wing extremists: Jerry Falwell, Pat Robertson, Jesse Helms.
I am not from that wing of the GOP.

And you STILL refuse to point out what view I hold that is extreme right. Oh wait I'm supposed to believe that because I'm a social and fiscal conservative I'm now an extremist? If that's the case BRTD a good amount of Americans are extremists. But is that the case? Absolutley not.

So I ask you for what... a third time now...what view do I hold that is extreme?

[Keystone Phil]

supersoulty is an extremist because of his support of Santorum and Toomey as well

You do realize that 53% of Pennsylvanians support Santorum, right? 53% approve of his job as Senator. Are you going to call these people far right wingers, too, BRTD?

[There Are Some Remedies Worse Than The Disease]

none of the leftist you mentioned are extremists, just ultra-partisans.

I explained supersoulty. He supports Rick Santorum and Pat Toomey.

StevenNick and Keystone Phil have no moderate stances, StatesRights is a Confederate sympathizer who wants to reinstate the Alien and Sedition Acts.

ijohn57s started the "ultra-conservative" thread. He therefore admitted to being an extremist.

[Brambila]

I'm an extremist, but not a right-wing extremist. Just becuase I'm pro-life and against gay adoption doesn't make me a right-wing extremist.

[Keystone Phil]

StevenNick and Keystone Phil have no moderate stances,

Oh wait I get it....you're either moderate or extremist, right BRTD? You can't be conservative, right? Moderate or Extremist.

[There Are Some Remedies Worse Than The Disease]

StevenNick and Keystone Phil have no moderate stances,

Oh wait I get it....you're either moderate or extremist, right BRTD? You can't be conservative, right? Moderate or Extremist.

you can be a moderate conservative such as MSH2002 and John Ford or an extremist conservative like the ones I mentioned.

And the question again: what are my extremist stances?

[Keystone Phil]

StevenNick and Keystone Phil have no moderate stances,

Oh wait I get it....you're either moderate or extremist, right BRTD? You can't be conservative, right? Moderate or Extremist.

And the question again: what are my extremist stances?

So you can't be a conservative BRTD? You can't be a traditional conservative?

And in referrence to your question, I will not answer until you provide me with my extremist views. Don't try to change the subject here. You said I'm an extremist so back up what you say. What views do I have that are extreme?

[There Are Some Remedies Worse Than The Disease]

well I divide the spectrum into 5 categories:

extreme left
moderate left
centrist
moderate right
extreme right

you fall on the extreme right.

and to give some contrast, the other categories examples:

moderate left: Nym, Handzus, raggage, Harry
center: bullmoose, Tweed
moderate right: the ones I mentioned + htmldon and WalterMitty

virtually ALL of your views are extremist.

[Keystone Phil]

well I divide the spectrum into 5 categories:

extreme left
moderate left
centrist
moderate right
extreme right

you fall on the extreme right.

and to give some contrast, the other categories examples:

moderate left: Nym, Handzus, raggage, Harry
center: bullmoose, Tweed
moderate right: the ones I mentioned + htmldon and WalterMitty

virtually ALL of your views are extremist.

SO start pointing them out BRTD. I know your game. You want to accuse me of being far right without backing it up. If you're going to say that being against abortion except in the cases of rape/life of the mother is extreme, thats foolish. If you want to say that supporting capital punishment is extreme, thats foolish. I can go on and on and you can't. You can't give any far right views I have.  And if you're going to call anyone to the right of Don extreme, thats also foolish.

[Keystone Phil]

moderate left: Nym, Handzus, raggage, Harry

Funny how you say Handzus is a moderate liberal when you compared him earlier to Che Guevara. Hmmmm anyone else get a good laugh out of that?

[There Are Some Remedies Worse Than The Disease]

I compared him to Che Guevara not because of his ideology, but because he was a left wing revolutionary in the scenario.

I don't see any difference between you and the 3 examples you mentioned as extremists, especially not Jesse Helms.

What are your views on taxation?

[Keystone Phil]

What are your views on taxation?

See. You don't even know my views on the issues. Before you call me an extremist, make sure you have some views of mine that are extreme.

[There Are Some Remedies Worse Than The Disease]

I was just asking because I think I saw you say once you supported abolishing the income tax.

Do you consider Kerry a left wing extremist? Most Republicans I've met do. If that's the case around 45-50% who say they'll vote for him in the polls are left wing extremists.

[Keystone Phil]

I don't see any difference between you and the 3 examples you mentioned as extremists, especially not Jesse Helms.

You are actually going to say I am in the same wing of Robertson and Falwell? Wow...so tell me what views I share with Robertson and Falwell. I really want you to accuse me of believing something I don't believe in. I'm just waiting for it. So go ahead.

[Keystone Phil]

Do you consider Kerry a left wing extremist? Most Republicans I've met do.

I'll tell you this...I don't believe he is the most liberal member of the Senate.

[There Are Some Remedies Worse Than The Disease]

All social issues.

And of course, that infamous Santorum quote:

"If the Supreme Court rules you have the right to consensual sex, you have the right to bigamy, you have the right to polygamy, you have the right to incest, you have the right to adultery. You have the right to anything."

That view is what I consider extremist.

[Keystone Phil]

All social issues.

Name my extreme social views. Are you really going to tell me that being against abortion except in the cases of rape/life of the mother is at risk  is extreme? Is being in favor of capital punishment extreme? Is being against gay marriage extreme? If all these views are extreme, BRTD, then MANY Americans are extreme. But that's not the case and you know it.