The Battle of Yorktown was lost in 1776

[Harry Hayfield]

And as a result the USA became known as "The British Commonweath of America" and adopted in 1789 a parliamentary democracy with a First Minister of America who would shuttle between Washington and London to discuss the rights of the new nation.

In 2010, David Cameron wins the UK general election with a landslide and says that he feels that the Commonwealth should be given more powers akin to the Scottish Parliament and a referendum is called for the following summer.

How would the American nation vote in such a referendum where green means YES and red means NO?

[True Federalist (진정한 연방 주의자)]

Well first off, the Siege of Yorktown was in 1781 not 1776.  Secondly Yorktown was a foregone conclusion once the French Navy beat the Royal Navy at the Battle of the Chesapeake.  Thirdly, had the British actually won the Revolution, trying to speculate on what result a vote in 2010 without some idea of what had happened in intervening 23 decades would be pointless.   So you'll have to wait for gporter to discuss this with maps.

[Hash]

Well first off, the Siege of Yorktown was in 1781 not 1776.  Secondly Yorktown was a foregone conclusion once the French Navy beat the Royal Navy at the Battle of the Chesapeake.  Thirdly, had the British actually won the Revolution, trying to speculate on what result a vote in 2010 without some idea of what had happened in intervening 23 decades would be pointless.   So you'll have to wait for gporter to discuss this with maps.

Indeed. If the British had won the Revolution, we'd be looking at an entirely different world complete with entirely different geopolitics, demographics, and politics.

[Associate Justice PiT]

Well first off, the Siege of Yorktown was in 1781 not 1776.  Secondly Yorktown was a foregone conclusion once the French Navy beat the Royal Navy at the Battle of the Chesapeake.  Thirdly, had the British actually won the Revolution, trying to speculate on what result a vote in 2010 without some idea of what had happened in intervening 23 decades would be pointless.   So you'll have to wait for gporter to discuss this with maps.

Indeed. If the British had won the Revolution, we'd be looking at an entirely different world complete with entirely different geopolitics, demographics, and politics.

     Agreed. An event with the ramifications of the American Revolution would have such a profound impact on society after that long that we could not even begin to recognize a world today without it.

     I mean, the War of 1812 almost certainly would not have happened. The tensions between England & the Union in the American Civil War would not have materialized. Provided that the Civil War even happens in the first place without an independent United States.