Is this guy a good guy?

[I spent the winter writing songs about getting better]

A guy is driving in South Africa during apartheid and speeding. He gets pulled over. He then notices that the cop in question was actually earlier enforcing apartheid on blacks. So he pulls out a gun and blows the cop away.

I vote yes. In fact I'd say that simply killing police for no reason at all in South Africa during apartheid was 100% morally justifiable. If you were a cop in South Africa during apartheid, you were a disgusting excuse for a human being. Period, no exceptions;.

[I spent the winter writing songs about getting better]

If you were a cop in South Africa during apartheid, you were a disgusting excuse for a human being. Period, no exceptions;.

I wish I could have your simplistic mind for just a day, BRTD! Really!

OK were all SS officers evil people? How about Saddam's police?

[I spent the winter writing songs about getting better]

If you were a cop in South Africa during apartheid, you were a disgusting excuse for a human being. Period, no exceptions;.

He's what we call a vigilante, which is illegal in pretty much every modern society.

So what? We're talking about the law in South Africa under apartheid here. Is there any moral legitimacy to that law whatsoever?

[I spent the winter writing songs about getting better]

I don't see what's wrong with the logic that only a completely morally bankrupt person could be a cop in a place as reprehensible as South Africa under apartheid.

[I spent the winter writing songs about getting better]

I don't see what's wrong with the logic that only a completely morally bankrupt person could be a cop in a place as reprehensible as South Africa under apartheid.

Your logic is probably correct, but that doesn't make it ok to shoot him!
Are you pro-death penalty BRTD?

No, but in this case it's an act of justified resistance.

I don't see what's wrong with the logic that only a completely morally bankrupt person could be a cop in a place as reprehensible as South Africa under apartheid.

Yeah, because God forbid a "good" person would want to join the local policing agency to try and make things better.  Or was (is?) every white person on the dark continent a horrible person in your eyes?  As I'm sure you've read here a thousand times, the world isn't as black and white as it appears through your young eyes.

You're making quite a leap of logic from "people enforcing apartheid" to "every single white person in Africa"

And a person on the police force abusing blacks is NOT making things better.

[I spent the winter writing songs about getting better]

You're making quite a leap of logic from "people enforcing apartheid" to "every single white person in Africa"

And a person on the police force abusing blacks is NOT making things better.

Well you did say....

I don't see what's wrong with the logic that only a completely morally bankrupt person could be a cop in a place as reprehensible as South Africa under apartheid.

You're saying all cops in South Africa during apartheid were morally bankrupt and I'm saying that's much too simple and incorrect.

I don't see what's wrong with that, since the primary purpose of the police in South Africa was to oppress the black population. It's not much different than saying only a morally bankrupt person could join the SS.

[I spent the winter writing songs about getting better]

     With that in mind, as sbane pointed out, not everyone becomes a cop to beat up folks. Though if this happened in South Central L.A., would you think that the shooter was just as justified?

No. Though this quote does sum up most cops:

"You don't become a cop because you want to serve and protect. You join the force because they let you carry a gun and a badge. You do it because you get respect. Most people respect the badge. Everyone respects the gun."

[I spent the winter writing songs about getting better]

"You don't become a cop because you want to serve and protect. You join the force because they let you carry a gun and a badge. You do it because you get respect. Most people respect the badge. Everyone respects the gun."

No doubt some cops join for that reason, nobody will argue against that.  But your ignorant if you think every single cop during aparthied was a racist bastards itching for a reason to beat on some "darkies".

I have a tough time believing it did not apply to at least the vast majority, I after all could never take a job requiring that I would engage in such repression. Anyone taking it clearly has no moral qualms with doing so anyway.

[I spent the winter writing songs about getting better]

A guy is driving in South Africa during apartheid and speeding. He gets pulled over. He then notices that the cop in question was actually earlier enforcing apartheid on blacks. So he pulls out a gun and blows the cop away.

I vote yes. In fact I'd say that simply killing police for no reason at all in South Africa during apartheid was 100% morally justifiable. If you were a cop in South Africa during apartheid, you were a disgusting excuse for a human being. Period, no exceptions;.

That is so stupid I'm lost for words. You're a stupid teen-ager

24 is not teenage.

who exploits strippers

LOL. If anything the strippers are exploiting me. When I leave a strip club who is richer and who is poorer?

and you think you can sit around and judge thousands of people you don't know anything about?

Is that uncommon on this forum (or any remotely politically related forum for that matter)? See comments about Palestineans for starters...

The cold-hearted, inhuman arrogance of that is nothing but disgusting.

That sounds kind of like apartheid to me.

You don't know anything about apartheid South Africa

I know it was a brutal racist state. What more needs to be said?

or any situation which requires more than drinking beer or buying a Che Guevara t-shirt.

again.

[I spent the winter writing songs about getting better]

I wonder why there was no real depth to the attacks on me here...

Question though: How many innocent blacks were murdered by the police there? Are the police in a criminal regime any better than criminals themselves? Hell, many WERE literally found to be criminals, see all the former members of Saddam's police tried and executed in the past couple years. The leaders of the East German Stasi didn't really get off scot-free either.

[I spent the winter writing songs about getting better]

     With that in mind, as sbane pointed out, not everyone becomes a cop to beat up folks. Though if this happened in South Central L.A., would you think that the shooter was just as justified?

No. Though this quote does sum up most cops:

"You don't become a cop because you want to serve and protect. You join the force because they let you carry a gun and a badge. You do it because you get respect. Most people respect the badge. Everyone respects the gun."

Just curious, did you get that from a movie?  I think I heard it somewhere, but not sure where.

Yes, Righteous Kill. Though the movie is undoubtedly horrible, no question about that.

[I spent the winter writing songs about getting better]

If you were a cop in South Africa during apartheid, you were a disgusting excuse for a human being. Period, no exceptions;.

I wish I could have your simplistic mind for just a day, BRTD! Really!

OK were all SS officers evil people? How about Saddam's police?

No, they weren't, which is why the guy is not a good guy.

Wow, someone willing to do the stuff the SS and Saddam's police did was not evil? There were good-hearted people who were government torturers or even had a job to rape women? LOL, beyond ridiculous.

[I spent the winter writing songs about getting better]

OK, I'll try and explain it to you.

You're taking a large group of people, lumped together by profession. You are unable to say anything about their actions in a collective sense (there is likely no single action that all of them has performed). You've never met any of them. You haven't even been on the same continent as them. And yet you think YOU have the right to casually say that none of them have a right to life, but should be killed on sight.

It is a brutal, arrogant and despicable attitude to other human beings.

The scenario though DOES involve a specific action (abuse of blacks). As stated above too, you could use the same style of argument to the SS.

[I spent the winter writing songs about getting better]

Apartheid was LEGAL racial segregation, which is actually good for some societies. No, the man is a scumbag and should be shot himself. You're acting as if segregation is ethnic-cleansing.

Oh wow. Change avatar immediately.