Make a map of the above four posters as two tickets

[Atlas Has Shrugged]

Senator Scott (D-CT)/Congressman Alfred Jones (D-NY)-315
Governor Shua, gm (R-VA)/Senator Goldwater Republican (R-WA)-223

Shua and Goldwater Republican fire up the Republican base, and for a while, lead the Scott ticket, as his pick of Alfred Jones is controversial. However, the paleoconservative'ish ticket of Shua is spun by Scott, who wins over the elderly in Florida. The Scott campaign plays on populist sentiment and performs strongly in the midwest, and is able to win over the swing states.

[Atlas Has Shrugged]

Senator SJoyceFla (R-FL)/Senator Goldwater (R-WA)-272 EV, 50.1%
Governor Nix (D-NY)/Congressman Clinton1996 (D-VA)-266 EV, 49.9%

Close call. I think Sam would carry the traditional Republican states, while bringing in New Hampshire, Colorado, and Nevada. Nix would do well in traditional Democratic/leftist areas, but might not be able to build the coalition needed to win. Sam is like Jon Huntsman with Gary Johnsons views-he attracts independents. Nix would also attract independents, but not to the degree Sam does due to his slightly less mainstream views of left-libertarianism.