I used to dislike this show (I actually think that there was a thread similar to this and I said how I didn't like it) but I'm hooked now. It started when I watched the season one finale (since my mom is a fan, I watched it with her). I then followed the second season and got caught up on everything that happened before when I watched the season one DVD collection (all 24 episodes).
So I was wondering how many other fans are out there. This thread can also be used for comments on episodes and just the show in general.
I never watched the show on TV, but a co-worker gave me Season 1 on DVD last fall, and I watched all 24 shows like you did. By network standards, its great. I'll wait till Season 2 comes out on DVD before I see it again though.
What was in the hatch?
Charlie got annoying after awhile, Claire was always screaming. Hurley seemed to be comic relief, I felt sorry for him.
I liked Sun, Kate, Sayid and John Locke (the name is so obviously symbolic)