|
Title: ACLU: Michigan cops stealing drivers' phone data Post by: bullmoose88 on April 20, 2011, 01:34:49 AM http://news.cnet.com/8301-17938_105-20055431-1.html
Quote The Michigan State Police have started using handheld machines called "extraction devices" to download personal information from motorists they pull over, even if they're not suspected of any crime. Naturally, the ACLU has a problem with this. See also http://www.thenewspaper.com/news/34/3458.asp I wonder how this would play out as a constitutional challenge...the technology like that in Kyllo isn't regularly available...yet we're not talking about a person's home here either. Title: Re: ACLU: Michigan cops stealing drivers' phone data Post by: True Federalist (진정한 연방 주의자) on April 20, 2011, 07:22:42 AM http://news.cnet.com/8301-17938_105-20055431-1.html Quote The Michigan State Police have started using handheld machines called "extraction devices" to download personal information from motorists they pull over, even if they're not suspected of any crime. Naturally, the ACLU has a problem with this. See also http://www.thenewspaper.com/news/34/3458.asp I wonder how this would play out as a constitutional challenge...the technology like that in Kyllo isn't regularly available...yet we're not talking about a person's home here either. This should be so clear cut a fourth amendment case, you'd think they'd know better than to do this in the first place. Title: Re: ACLU: Michigan cops stealing drivers' phone data Post by: John Dibble on April 20, 2011, 10:34:17 AM I wonder how this would play out as a constitutional challenge...the technology like that in Kyllo isn't regularly available...yet we're not talking about a person's home here either. Well, the Fourth Amendment question isn't about whether or not it's in a person's home or not - it's about a reasonable expectation of privacy. Your personal data on your devices isn't something that is publicly accessible, so an expectation of privacy would be reasonable in regards to it. Title: Re: ACLU: Michigan cops stealing drivers' phone data Post by: bullmoose88 on April 20, 2011, 02:48:36 PM I wonder how this would play out as a constitutional challenge...the technology like that in Kyllo isn't regularly available...yet we're not talking about a person's home here either. Well, the Fourth Amendment question isn't about whether or not it's in a person's home or not - it's about a reasonable expectation of privacy. Your personal data on your devices isn't something that is publicly accessible, so an expectation of privacy would be reasonable in regards to it. And arguably you have a greater expectation of privacy in your home compared to your car. The real question is, like Kyllo, is the technology the police are using to lift the data commonly available to the public. If it is, then you wouldn't have a reasonable expectation of privacy if its so friggin easy to obtain the data just by being near the phone...if on the other hand, this technology like the thermal imaging in Kyllo isn't commonly available, then you have a reasonable expectation of privacy. Title: Re: ACLU: Michigan cops stealing drivers' phone data Post by: John Dibble on April 20, 2011, 03:33:11 PM I wonder how this would play out as a constitutional challenge...the technology like that in Kyllo isn't regularly available...yet we're not talking about a person's home here either. Well, the Fourth Amendment question isn't about whether or not it's in a person's home or not - it's about a reasonable expectation of privacy. Your personal data on your devices isn't something that is publicly accessible, so an expectation of privacy would be reasonable in regards to it. And arguably you have a greater expectation of privacy in your home compared to your car. Actually you arguably have the same expectation of privacy, it's just that more things meet the standard of "in plain sight" which could not be expected to be kept private. The police can't pop open your trunk or your glove box without a warrant or permission anymore than they can enter your house without those things. |