Talk Elections

Presidential Elections - Analysis and Discussion => Alternative Elections => Topic started by: JRP1994 on July 29, 2013, 10:10:54 PM



Title: 1896: Mark Twain (R) vs William Jennings Bryan (D)
Post by: JRP1994 on July 29, 2013, 10:10:54 PM
Who wins, and what does the popular/electoral vote total look like?


Title: Re: 1896: Mark Twain (R) vs William Jennings Bryan (D)
Post by: FEMA Camp Administrator on July 30, 2013, 05:14:17 PM
Awesome matchup. However, I have no idea what party Twain was or favored, and he seems to have mainly been on the left--civil rights, anti-imperialism, favoring unions--and whatnot. It'd be fun to see what type of support he could pick up, geographically, given his background. I'd guess the National Democrats do a bit better as well.


Title: Re: 1896: Mark Twain (R) vs William Jennings Bryan (D)
Post by: Citizen Hats on October 29, 2013, 01:16:45 PM
Awesome matchup. However, I have no idea what party Twain was or favored, and he seems to have mainly been on the left--civil rights, anti-imperialism, favoring unions--and whatnot. It'd be fun to see what type of support he could pick up, geographically, given his background. I'd guess the National Democrats do a bit better as well.

In his autobiography, Twain indicates that he was generally a Republican in his middle age, and one of those 19th Century Radical Republicans to some extent, especially as he grew older.  There are only three people in his autobiography whom Twain paints a positive picture of- his deceased wife, his deceased daughter, and General Grant, whom he revered. All others are mercilessly skewered.

He did vote for Cleveland in 1884, joining the Mugwumps in their dissatisfaction with James G. Blaine, which caused some social discomfort for himself and the town preacher in their heavily Republican town (voting was public in 1884 Connecticut). I would be surprised (though I haven't researched) if he voted for William J. Bryan in 1896, but I wouldn't be surprised if he voted for him in 1900. He bitterly skewered Theodore Roosevelt as a war-monger, personally arrogant and rude, and deeply unpleasant, so he may well have abandoned his Republican inclinations late in life