Talk Elections

How would the showdown between these two atlas rivals go down? Discuss with maps.


I'd obviously vote for OSR, and personally think he'd win the election.

()

OSR - 278
IceSpear - 260

OSR would pursue a Bush-style campaign that plays well in the West and the South, which reacts negatively to IceSpear's disdain for people from the region.

OSR would win pretty easily

()

OSR also wins the popular vote by a 3% margin.

OSR/OSR

IceSpear/OSR

IceSpear/IceSpear (sane, prefers leaders with IQs above 90)

But do Americans? :P

I wonder what your strategy against me would be, because I likely would make inroads in Dem Suburbs(like Philli Suburbs, Collar Counties , and Washington County) and would still win Trump like numbers in rural areas due to you acting hostile to those areas .

Best Case Scenario for Me(You run a Hillary 2016 style campaign but with even more hostility to rural voters)

()


Internal Polls probably would show thats where the election would go if you run that type of campaign so you probably would be advised to run a pretty populist campaign to lower GOP turnout in Appalachia and WWC counties in the Midwest along with trying to drive a wedge in my base to keep those suburbs in the fold. There are two ways that type of election could end up.

The median Scenario

()


But if it works this would be map:

()



So you would have a chance if you run a 2012 Obama style campaign like you would be advised to but if you ran a 2016 Hillary style campaign it would turn into Kasich vs Hillary.

http://www.270towin.com/maps/zvgoX

IceSpear is just not able to hide his utter contempt for WWC voters and West Virginians in particular (spilling into other states). On top of that, OSR appeals to the types of voters IceSpear needs to win. OSR will make silly Bush II style gaffes, but few will really mind.

I'd vote IceSpear, but OSR would win (and I like him as well, especially personally, so I wouldn't mind).

I like both, but IceSpear is very close to me politically.

OSR/OSR
()

Same here. I would have no difficulty whatsoever in supporting OldSchoolRepublican, and given IceSpear's contempt for much of Middle America (as has been commented on here already), he would win the election easily.

Ice spear Reluctantly

Old school republican is mostly a R hack

IceSpear/Old School Republican

IceSpear/IceSpear. OSR wouldn't be able to excite the Republican base at all. The states IceSpear constantly rails against like West Virginia and Oklahoma won't matter in a presidential race anyway.

Option 3: cyanide.

...Not funny dude. 39 years and a bit of change too late to be funny.

Reluctantly IceSpear/OSR

Both posters are FFs, but I know Old School Repub a little better and agree with him more on policy.

Idk who wins overall, but I do know that OSR wins 80%+ in WV :P

Well yeah, of course. He has the (R) next to his name and I have the anti-white hate group's insignia next to my name. :P