Governor Oldiesfreak1854 (R-MI)/Senator Dean Heller (R-NV) - 285 EVsGovernor Adam C. FitzGerald (D-OH)/Senator Tammy Baldwin (D-WI) - 253 EVsThe election dramatically isolated parts of the nation for one candidate or the other. The Northeast and Pacific stuck with the Democrats while the South and West went for the Republicans. While the Ohio Governor did not fear he would lose his own state, Wisconsin's tossup nature and it's proximity to Michigan resulted in him picking Senator Baldwin in order to better their chances there while also balancing the male/female ticket that were both LGBT.
Oldiesfreak, feeling confident that he could carry Michigan, decides to pick a popular Republican Senator from Nevada after Governor Adam FitzGerald's botched comment early on that he would promise that he would never overturn the ban on prostitution.
In the end, Governor ACF narrowly holds on in Wisconsin, Pennsylvania, New Hampshire, and Oregon while Oldiesfreak sweeps a number of tossup states down south and out west giving him the victory.