Mafia-Game 4 (Day Phase 2)

[vote for pedro]

Is Leinad too obvious of a guess?

[vote for pedro]

I think everyone involved in the story is innocent, and I know I am innocent.  That leaves Mike, AZ, and Cokeland.  2 of the 3 are mafia.

Lynch Cokeland Chastain.

[vote for pedro]

Cokeland Chastain has not been online since the 17th so I don't think it is him as the Mafia did try and kill someone.
https://uselectionatlas.org/FORUM/index.php?action=profile;u=15294

I vote to lynch: vote for pedro

Well that makes it easy.  I didn't realize Cokeland Chastain had not been online.  I stand by my percentages.

Change my vote to lynch AZ.

[vote for pedro]

Since there are already votes to lynch me, I assume I will be a target during the night anyway.  I might as well come clean with what I know:

I, vote for pedro, am the Sheriff.
I investigated Tomhguy and was told he is innocent.

Here are my assumptions:
Goldwater isn’t mafia if someone tried to kill him during the night.

Cokeland Chastain hasn’t been online since Feb 17th so he might be innocent.

Leinad could go either way but it just seems too obvious with the story.

If Cokeland is innocent, then AZ pointing out Cokeland’s absence wasn’t very mafia-like.  Mafia would jump on the chance to lynch a townie.  If Cokeland is guilty, then AZ’s move would make sense to protect his partner.

Or maybe it is Mike and Leinad.  I’m assuming there are 2 mafia members.

It being a 50/50 proposition, and me being a law-abiding lawman; I'll temporarily change my vote (again ) to no lynch pending further evidence.

[vote for pedro]

Also, Pedro, why do you think I'd be Mafia with Leinad of all people? And didn't you say earlier you thought everyone in Enduro's story was innocent? What made you change your mind?

I investigated Tomhguy based on his suspicious voting day 1.  He came back as innocent.

Then the story comes out with Goldwater, Tomhguy, and Leinad all involved. 

Goldwater sure looked innocent, I knew Tomhguy was innocent, and Leinad... well just seemed too obvious.  My comment about all 3 in the story being innocent was just a guess based on what I knew about Tomhguy & Goldwater.

[vote for pedro]

Edit: Also, if cokeland is mafia, maybe his lack of activity is why Goldwater's murder failed? Something I thought of. Cokeland seems like a decent lynch if we have a day with no leads.

I can go along with this.  Even if he is an innocent bystander, he obviously is not insterested in helping the town by voting or telling us what he knows.  Maybe we get lucky and kill half the mafia.

Lynch Cokeland.