I think we should all admit that white Catholics are the most powerful swing voters in this country. The republicans know that the southern evangelicals will always vote for them.
Now in order to win the swing states, the GOP needs to appeal to the "Reagan Democrats" which are essentially white Catholics (who voted for Kennedy, FDR, etc.).
The southern evangelicals may stay home, but then they concede to the half-black Obama and the Liberal Democrats.
Catholic Paul Ryan ensures Romney victories in Iowa, Ohio, Florida, and Wisconsin.
Reagan Democrats did exist, but by and large,
they weren't the people the media describes as Reagan Democrats. For the most part, they were conservative, traditionally Democratic white and rural Southerners, they type who had voted Wallace in '68, Nixon in '72, Carter in '76, and Reagan in '80 and '84, and who have been reliably Republican since. Reagan didn't win over working-class White Catholics in the North anywhere near as much as the popular mythology holds: just look at the county results from 1984 if you don't believe me.