shoot them if they won't surrender their guns peacefully.
Money quote!
You completely ignored the rest of the quote... I also suggested drafting them into the military, where they would be allowed to use a gun to their heart's content as long as they're there, or paying them sizable sums of money to buy the guns from them.
Your endgame, if needed, is still the mass murder of US citizens if they don't comply with being disarmed.
You would have another civil war on your hands in a hurry.
As much as I disagree with you on everything else, on this we can agree. what NewYorkExpress is talking about is an amazingly horrible idea.