Here's something close to my ideal state map. One state is colored incorrectly by the app as I couldn't get Manhattan transferred, but the hand-filled map below it is accurate. It comes out to a slight Trump win (~280 EV), but is a clear win for an Obama-like candidate. Several of the states are easily winnable for a more conservative Democratic candidate.
Interesting. You have 49 states here, correct? Or am I miscounting?
Yes, I ended up losing one and couldn't get it back unfortunately. I didn't mean to have only 49. I guess you could add Puerto Rico/US Virgin Islands to get back to 50.
Hey, since the app now has the 2012 election, I decided to try to recreate your states using that election's map. Here's what it looks like:
What I find most interesting is that the Rio Grande state apparently voted for Romney by a margin of a bit less than 20,000 votes.