RE: BRTD's link, my family was Missouri Synod Lutheran before liking our ELCA church in Iowa City better than its Missouri Synod counterpart ... I get arguments could be made for it being "Evangelical," but I have never heard a single Missouri Synod person describe themselves that way, and that probably matters more. Personally, I think the simple distinction of falling under the umbrella of any of the traditional Mainline denominations (e.g., Lutheran, Methodist, Presbyterian, etc.) means your Mainline. Period. It's not like you can't be a theologically conservative Mainliner, after all.
Most people have much more parochial/idiosyncratic reasons for picking a church from one sub-denomination over another (ex. ELCA vs LCMS; PCA vs PCUSA). People can go from a "mainline" congregation to an "evangelical" one for perfectly mundane reasons like "I like the choir better" or "We moved across town and this one is closer."
And local demographics often drive the tone of the church more than national doctrines that largely exist only on paper. The United Methodist Church is a "mainline" denomination but if you go to a Methodist church in Texas, it probably feels more like a Southern Baptist church than a Methodist church that Hillary Clinton would go to in Upstate New York.