I know this is primarily aimed towards Republicans, but being the New Yorker that I am I would probably vote for Guiliani for President. He may be a scumbag, but so was Clinton 
LOL. Being exposed to Rudy on a daliy basis you realize he is an ego-maniac and a publicity whore--what politician isn't. He is a funny guy though and I agree with him on a lot. I would vote for Rudy. New York was going down the crapper before he came around. He helped change the political climate in NYC. There were certainly other factors involved in New Yorks resurgence but the efforts of Rudy and Bratton should not be overlooked.
