I do not see how any one with a positive economic score could ever tolerate voting for FDR.
I see. I would have voted for FDR because he seemed to have better ideas and was fresher then Hoover was. In 1936, I probably would have remembered the last recession happened during a Republican administration, and liked that FDR had began to inspire the nation and help lift it from its woes. In 1940 and 1944, I would have voted for Willkie and Dewey.
When I make those lists I make them as if I was an actual voter at the time, without a window into future events.